
Cinderella is settling in nicely in the village, but unfortunately, some pesky critters stole some of her most important tools in Disney Dreamlight Valley. She comes to you asking for help with her level four friendship quest, which is Critter Chaos.
Dealing with troublesome animals is no easy task, and Cinderella is missing quite a few tools, so navigating through this one can be tough. If any part of it has you stumped and unable to progress, here’s a complete walkthrough for the Critter Chaos quest in Disney Dreamlight Valley.
Table of contents
- How to complete Critter Chaos in Disney Dreamlight Valley
- Ask for Alice's help
- Try to negotiate with Rude Raccoon
- Gather the ingredients for a Whimsical Pie
- Cook a Whimsical Pie
- Give the Whimsical Pie to the Rude Raccoon
- Ask Cheshire Cat for clues
- Find Cinderella's Thread with an unusual turtle on Dazzle Beach
- Fish Cinderella's Pencil out of the water in the Glade of Trust
- Give Cinderella back her tools
- Place the tea party set on Dazzle Beach
- Pick up the White Buttons that just appeared on Dazzle Beach
How to complete Critter Chaos in Disney Dreamlight Valley

To complete the Critter Chaos quest, you need to team up with Cinderella, Alice, and the Cheshire Cat to get Cinderella's tools back from some pesky critters. It's not an easy process to navigate through, so here's a full step-by-step breakdown of how to get it done.
Ask for Alice's help
This mission isn't one you can tackle on your own, so start by tracking down Alice around the valley. Chat with her about the situation once you find her to learn that the thief in question is actually a Raccoon, then meet up with Cinderella to share what you learned. This Raccoon actually returned to her home, so head into Cinderella's castle to meet and talk to the thief.
Try to negotiate with Rude Raccoon
Once you're inside Cinderella's house, walk over to the Rude Raccoon and chat with them to see if you can negotiate. Unfortunately, this pesky critter isn't very cooperative, so nothing you say makes any difference. Follow Cinderella and Alice over to a different part of the castle and chat with Alice about what to do next.

Gather the ingredients for a Whimsical Pie
The group decides that the Rude Raccoon might be a bit more receptive to a deliciously cooked dish, so your next task is to gather the ingredients to make a Whimsical Pie. Before you can cook this dessert, you need to obtain:
- Sugarcane – Can be grown from Sugarcane Seeds. You can buy these seeds from Goofy's Stall in the Dazzle Beach biome for five Star Coins.
- Wheat – Can be grown from Wheat Seeds, which can be bought from Goofy's Stall in the Peaceful Meadow biome for one Star Coin.
- Whimsical Berries – Given to you by Alice in the previous step of this quest, so they should already be in your inventory.
Cook a Whimsical Pie
With all of the required ingredients gathered, you can now head to a cooking station to make the Whimsical Pie. Toss in one of each of the three required ingredients to make it, then return to Cinderella's house with this item.

Give the Whimsical Pie to the Rude Raccoon
Walk over to the Rude Raccoon near the back of Cinderella's house, close to the bedroom, and interact with them to transfer over the freshly cooked Whimsical Pie. This critter will finally give back Cinderella's first missing tool, so walk over to her to give her this item and discuss the remaining missing tools.
Ask Cheshire Cat for clues
There's no other critter more mischievous than the Cheshire Cat, so meet up with him to see if he has any insight into where Cinderella's other tools might be. Of course, nothing's ever straightforward with this guy, so he gives you some cryptic clues to solve.
Find Cinderella's Thread with an unusual turtle on Dazzle Beach

The first item you need to find is Cinderella's Thread, which is hidden with an unusual Sea Turtle found in the Dazzle Beach biome. This critter can be found swimming swiftly through the water close to Skull Rock island, just off the coast of the region.
You can distinguish this critter from regular Sea Turtles by the pink spool of thread attached to its shell. This turtle is also a lot faster than all the others in this area. Chase after the critter and interact with it to grab Cinderella's Thread.
Fish Cinderella's Pencil out of the water in the Glade of Trust
Head over to the Glade of Trust biome and search all bodies of water in this area until you find a gold ripple spot with golden sparkles on it. The bubble spot you need to fish out of here looks a bit different from the rest, making it easy to spot once you know what to look for. Equip your Royal Fishing rod, throw the line into the bubble spot, and catch Cinderella's Pencil.

Give Cinderella back her tools
Meet up with Cinderella once you have both items to give her back the tools. Listen as she and Alice chat about the situation and decide the three of you should enjoy some tea together to celebrate your success.
Place the tea party set on Dazzle Beach
Cinderella and Alice give you a tea party set to place down in the valley. Open your inventory, select the Furniture tab, click on the Cinderella quest icon, select the tea party set, and place it anywhere you like around the Dazzle Beach biome. You can always move it around after the quest is complete, so don't worry too much about where you place it.
Pick up the White Buttons that just appeared on Dazzle Beach
Once the tea party is over, some mysterious White Buttons will appear nearby. Pick them up and chat with Cinderella to see what she thinks. As soon as you do, the Critter Chaos quest will officially be complete.
The post Critter Chaos quest walkthrough in Disney Dreamlight Valley appeared first on Destructoid.