Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
Aidy Smith

17 best champagnes taste tested by a wine expert, from supermarket to luxury fizz

The UK is one of the biggest consumers of bubbles - (Aidy Smith/The Independent/iStock)

There’s nothing quite like taking a sip from one of the best bottles of champagne. So, whether you’re after a stellar supermarket fizz or your next luxury indulgence, if you’re in the market for a bottle of bubbly, you’ve come to the right place.

It’s no secret that champagne can cost a pretty penny (though I have found some serious bargains below) but, for the right occasion, a decent bottle absolutely justifies the cost, whereas an underwhelming one can sting.

As a wine lover and industry expert with many years of experience tasting, studying, and selecting exceptional bottles of everything from the best proseccos to the best red wine, I’ve come to know exactly what separates a good champagne from a truly unforgettable one. I look for balance alongside complexity on the nose and a finish that lingers with elegance. Whether it’s the citrus depth of a perfectly aged vintage or the mineral precision of a cuvée, each bottle tells a story.

Over the past few months, I’ve been hard at work exploring a wide spectrum of champagne, from the brilliant, budget-friendly surprises crafted by independent producers to the liquid gold poured by iconic maisons. Each sip has been a discovery, and I’m thrilled to share the best of what I’ve found, including my top pick – the Porte Noire 2013 vintage grand cru, which wowed me with its fragrant aromas of ripe pear and zippy lemon.

Keep reading to discover my all-time favorite bottles of champagne – handpicked for every occasion, taste, and budget – whether you're celebrating something big or simply indulging in a sparkling moment just because.

How I tested

Testing some of the best champagnes (someone had to do it) (Aidy Smith)

Each champagne was tasted with the following criteria in mind:

  • Tasting process: Each bottle was chilled in the fridge to between 6C and 9C. Once opened, the sparkling wine was allowed to sit in the glass for 10 minutes, to open up and warm slightly to the ideal drinking temperature of 8C to 13C before tasting.
  • Appearance: I wanted the champagnes to look bright and clear, while the bubbles had to be fine and persistent (both signs of quality) to make the cut.
  • Taste: Most importantly, I looked for champagnes that had a long, clean and complex finish that lingered long after my sip. I considered the balance of acidity and sweetness in each bottle, as well as the bite of the bubbles. Only the ones that impressed me the most made it into my final line-up.
  • Growers: I only included reputable Champagne houses and growers, from independent creations to legendary champagne houses.

Why you can trust IndyBest reviews

Aidy Smith is an award-winning broadcaster, TV presenter, journalist and inclusivity spokesperson. A leading expert in wine and champagne, he was the co-presenter of The Three Drinkers on Amazon Prime – a travel-meets-drinks TV series exploring the world’s finest beverages. In 2024, he was also ranked number 5 in Drinks Retailing's ‘Top 100 most influential people in the drinks industry’, underscoring his authority. His expertise makes him exceptionally well-placed to review the best champagnes, and he regularly writes for IndyBest on top spirits including the best gins, best tequilas, and best whiskies from around the world.

The best champagnes for 2025 are:

  • Best overall – Porte Noire 2013 vintage grand cru: £79.20, Amathusdrinks.com
  • Best budget bottle – Veuve Monsigny champagne brut: £14.95, Aldi.co.uk
  • Best for sweeter tastes – Sainsbury’s demi-sec champagne: £24, Sainsburys.co.uk
  • Best special gift – Bollinger La Grande annee rosé 2015: £152, Thefinestbubble.com

Porte Noire 2013 vintage grand cru

Rating: 5/5

Best: Overall champagne

Vintage: 2013

Grape variety : Chardonnay

ABV: 12.5%

Tasting notes: Cooked apple, pear, butter and lime

Why we love it

  • Bright flavour
  • Still light

This exceptional blanc de blancs was crafted by the renowned Sanger Champagne house in partnership with Idris Elba. Its history is incredible and a testament to the quality of the liquid itself. The nose presents fragrant aromas of ripe pear, dried tropical fruits and rich buttery scent. The first sip through the generous cloud of fizz unfolds zippy lemon and lime, more juicy pear and an autumnal hint of spiced apple turnover. These bright flavours are cleansed wonderfully by a crisp finish generated by the chalky terroir. Creating such a vivid, buttery and bold expression that retains its lightness is what makes this fizz so exquisite.

Buy now £79.20, Amathusdrinks.com

Veuve Monsigny champagne brut

Rating: 4/5

Best: Budget champagne

Vintage: N/A

ABV: 12.5%

Tasting notes: Apple, peach, buttery brioche

Why we love it

  • Affordable
  • Refreshing

Less of a well-kept secret than it once was, Aldi’s veuve monsigny is the definitive budget bubbly that punches above its price tag. Crafted by Philizot et Fils in the Marne Valley, this equal blend of chardonnay, pinot noir, and pinot meunier delivers baked apple, bright peach, and buttery brioche flavours with a soft mousse and crisp acidity. Perfect for toasting or mixing into a classy bucks fizz, it’s no wonder this refreshing champagne is a UK favourite. Affordable yet impressive, it’s the definition of bang-for-buck brilliance.

Buy now £14.95, Aldi.co.uk

Sainsbury’s demi-sec champagne

Rating: 4/5

Best: Champagne for a sweeter taste

Vintage: NV

ABV: 12%

Tasting notes: Apple, stone fruits, and toasted bread

Why we love it

  • Sweet and fruity
  • Affordable

Sticking with supermarkets offering smooth champagne that easily outperforms more expensive bottles, this demi-sec from Sainsbury’s is an absolute gem. If you love your slightly sweeter, fruitier champagnes, then this is the one for you.

Made by the Louis Kremer Champagne House in Reims, you can expect ripe stone fruits and crisp apple as well as toasted bread and minerality. It’s not cursed by the excessive acidity that can hurt champagnes at this level, and it would be a wonderful pairing with some spicy meals too. A steal at this price.

Buy now £24.00, Sainsburys.co.uk

Waitrose rosé champagne brut

Rating: 4/5

Best: Rosé champagne

Vintage: NV

Grape variety: 100% pinot noir

ABV: 12.5%

Tasting notes: Strawberry, cherry and cream

Why we love it

  • Depth
  • Fresh

Fresh, fruity, and utterly charming, this rosé champagne is crafted exclusively for Waitrose by Maison Alexandre Bonnet. Made from 100 per cent pinot noir, with grapes sourced from its premium vineyards around Le Riceys, it exudes fragrant red cherry as well as gloriously pungent wild strawberry aromas. Two years on the lees lends creamy finesse, while a touch of skin contact adds depth. It’s straight-forward, easy to love rosé champagne that feels like a glass of summer – delicious.

Buy now £30.00, Waitrose.com

Pommery ‘brut royal’ champagne

Rating: 4.5/5

Best: Champagne for affordable luxury

Vintage: NV

Grape varieties : 35% chardonnay, 35% pinot noir and 30% pinot meunier

ABV: 12.5%

Tasting notes: Apple, peach, buttery brioche

Why we love it

  • Perfectly balanced
  • Affordable

This iconic champagne owes its existence to Madame Pommery, who revolutionised the style by creating a crisp, dry brut ideal for any occasion. A pale lemon hue hints at its vibrant character, offering aromas of brioche, green apple, and floral honey with a touch of citrus zest – but without sharpness. Aged for at least three years in deep underground cellars, this blend of chardonnay, pinot noir, and pinot meunier is creamy, delicate, and perfectly balanced, delivering a luxury style without the price to match.

Buy now £44.99, Thebottleclub.com

Champagne Gremillet ambassadeur brut

Rating: 4/5

Best: Reliable all-rounder champagne

Vintage: NV

Grape varieties : Pinot noir dominant

ABV: 12.5%

Tasting notes: Peach, biscuit and pear

Why we love it

  • Elegant
  • Reliable

This small but beautiful family-owned champagne house is judged by its flagship ambassadeur brut because it’s made such a name for itself. Off the bat, fresh floral aromas flood the nose flanked by sweet brioche and baked biscuit. Fresh peach and vivid citrus round out the profile, and 18 months of ageing on lees delivers a fine mousse and a crisp, rich elegance to the finish. Forever reliable, the florality and fruits are just so endlessly quaffable.

Buy now £32.99, Virginwines.co.uk

Telmont Réserve brut champagne

Rating: 5/5

Best: Liquid gold champagne

Vintage: NV

Grape varieties : Chardonnay, pinot noir, pinot meunier

ABV: 12.5%

Tasting notes : Baked apple, cream and almond

Why we love it

  • Lively
  • Fruity
  • Iconic house

Every champagne drinker knows this liquid gold. Ludovic du Plessis took over Telmont in 2020 and has done wonderful things. It stands out for including a higher pinot meunier percentage in the blend, so expect generous supple fruits. Think baked apple, crème brûlée, and almond tart, dressed with candied tropical fruits and cleansed by a lingering, saline finish. The bubbles are lively, the balance of richness, fruit and minerality is on point, and on top of all that, Telmont is pushing for 100 per cent organic vineyards by 2025. Bravo from start to finish.

Buy now £47.50, Masterofmalt.com

Taittinger brut prestige rosé champagne

Rating: 4/5

Best: Champagne for pairing with desserts

Vintage: NV

Grape varieties : Chardonnay, pinot Noir, meunie

ABV: 12.5%

Tasting notes: Strawberry, cherry and blackcurrant

Why we love it

  • Rich blend
  • Famous, family-run house

Delicately hued in salmon-pink, this elegant full-bodied rosé champagne is a vibrant blend of 70 per cent pinot noir and 30 per cent chardonnay, with 15 per cent of the wine vinified as red for added richness. Bursting with aromas of wild strawberries, cherries, and blackcurrants, it offers a creamy palate of red fruit, subtle citrus, and a hint of spice. With deep flavours, fine bubbles and a refined mousse, it’s perfect as an aperitif or paired with oysters and fruit desserts. A crisp, fruity indulgence from one of champagne’s last great family-run houses.

Buy now £48.49, Thebottleclub.com

Bruno Paillard cuvee 72 3yrs late disgorged

Rating: 4/5

Best: Complex champagne

Vintage: NV

Grape varieties: Pinot Noir, chardonnay, pinot meunier

ABV: 12%

Tasting notes : White flowers, blackcurrants, honey and nuts

Why we love it

  • Long, balanced finish
  • Luxurious

A celebration of time and precision, this champagne from one of the younger houses matures for 72 months – 36 on lees and 36 post-disgorgement. A secret blend of pinot noir, chardonnay, and pinot meunier from reserve wines as old as 1985 creates a golden-hued masterpiece. Expect aromas of citrus, white flowers, dark fruits and spice, evolving into honeyed, nutty notes on the palate with a creamy texture and luxurious richness. Its delicate mousse, lively acidity, and long, balanced finish make this a luxurious, refined choice for any occasion. So much happening and so much to love.

Buy now £67.00, Wanderlust.co.uk

Pol Roger vintage rosé 2018

Rating: 4.5/5

Best: Independent champagne

Vintage: 2018

Grape varieties : Pinot noir, chardonnay

ABV: 12%

Tasting notes: Blood orange, plum, strawberry and tangerine

Why we love it

  • Glittering bubbles
  • Complex yet refreshing

Young Pol Roger was just 19 when he began his champagne estate and it remains a family-run enterprise today, with fifth-generation Hubert de Billy at the helm. Despite the prestigious reputation, it’s just a team of 10 producing these beautiful bubbles. The vintage rosé is produced from 20 grand and premier crus and fermented at a cooler-than-average temperature, resulting in its signature fine and glittering bubbles. Aromas of wild strawberries, red berries, and citrus lead to a palate of blood orange, plum, and delicate tangerine notes. Complex yet refreshing, its bright acidity and chalky texture give it a gastronomic edge. The poise between delicacy and intensity is perfect.

Buy now £94.00, Thefinestbubble.com

Champagne Laurent-Perrier la cuvee magnum

Rating: 4.5/5

Best: Champagne for celebrations

Vintage: NV

Grape varieties : Chardonnay, pinot noir, pinot meunier

ABV: 12%

Tasting notes: White flowers, lemon and stone fruits

Why we love it

  • Crisp palate
  • Affordable magnum

Champagne royalty, Laurent-Perrier has given its classic brut NV a sophisticated makeover, upping the chardonnay percentage to over half, tempering the sweetness and ageing for up to four years. Once it’s released, it pours a pale gold with a fine persistent mousse, delivering distinct citrus and white flower aromas. That lemon continues into a crisp palate yet retains richness with tasty stone fruits and a surprise smoke to the finish. Perfect as an apéritif, this magnum format makes sure that there’s plenty to celebrate – the exceptional value for one.

Buy now £99.99, Virginwines.co.uk

Bruno Paillard rose premiere cuvee magnum

Rating: 4.5/5

Best: Champagne for Christmas feasts

Vintage: NV

Grape varieties : Pinot noir, chardonnay

ABV: 12%

Tasting notes: Raspberry, cranberry and peach

Why we love it

  • Crisp fruitness
  • Perfectly balanced

This exquisite rosé champagne is a tribute to the elegance of pinot noir, crafted with meticulous care by the independent Bruno Paillard House. A copper-tinged salmon pink, it entices with aromas of peach, raspberry, citrus, and delicate violets. The fine bubbles create a silky, creamy texture, while the low dosage enhances its crisp freshness. Balanced notes of cranberries and subtle chalky minerality linger on the palate. Perfect with charcuterie, light poultry, or a selection of hard cheeses, the stars have aligned for this magnum to be the perfect choice for festive gatherings and feasts.

Buy now £125.00, Wanderlustwine.co.uk

Bollinger la grande annee rose 2015

Rating: 4.5/5

Best: Champagne for gifting

Vintage: 2015

Grape varieties: Pinot noir, chardonnay

ABV: 12%

Tasting notes: Almonds, orange peel and orchard fruits

Why we love it

  • Depth
  • Oily texture

Bollinger and luxury champagne go hand in hand, and this is its rosé masterpiece from the 2015 harvest, blending 62 per cent pinot noir and 38 per cent chardonnay, with five per cent pinot noir vinified as red wine from the legendary Côte aux Enfants plot. Aged on lees for nearly a decade, it offers aromas of sugar-dusted almonds, citrus, and savoury nuances. The palate is opulent, with vibrant acidity, silky tannins, and a fine mousse. That youthful, fresh fruit is definitely retained but matched with the quality red wine and ageing, there’s so much depth to explore and a lovely oiliness to the texture.

Buy now £160.00, Thefinestbubble.com

Rare brut millesime 2012

Rating: 4.5/5

Best: Champagne for intensity

Vintage: 2012

Grape varieties: Chardonnay, pinot noir

ABV: 12%

Tasting notes : Mango, cocoa, brioche, lemon and white flowers

Why we love it

  • Reflects decades of dedication

A masterpiece from Piper-Heidsieck, this 2012 vintage showcases chardonnay-dominant elegance. Its graceful bouquet unfurls with golden fruits, hazelnut, and cocoa, alongside exotic hints of mango and fig. The palate reveals vibrant lemony acidity, white flowers, and a subtle smokiness, balanced by emerging flavours of brioche, butter, and mineral notes. Its refined effervescence and genuinely remarkable depth reflect decades of dedication. Utterly impressive – a reminder of why champagne can be so special.

Buy now £158.00, Thefinestbubble.com

Pol Roger Sir Winston Churchill 2015

Rating: 5/5

Best: Indulgent champagne

Vintage: 2015

Grape varieties : Secret (Likely pinot noir dominant with a little chardonnay)

ABV: 12%

Tasting notes: Brioche, butter, cream, dried fruits and hazelnut

Why we love it

  • Depth and complexity
  • Well matured

Paying homage to its most famous admirer, this cuvée embodies Churchill’s preference for robust and mature champagne. He first tasted it in 1945 and a friendship blossomed, where he would receive a case every year from that point. Crafted from grand cru pinot noir and chardonnay (in a secret blend), the 2015 vintage dazzles with aromas of spice, hazelnut, and dried fruits, underpinned by toasted brioche and candied citrus on the palate. Its rich, creamy mousse and seamless acidity enhance its depth and complexity. Mature, succulent, exceptional champagne.

Buy now £184.00, Thefinestbubble.com

Pommery ‘cuvée Louise’ 2006

Rating: 5/5

Best: Older vintage champagne

Vintage: 2005

Grape varieties: Chardonnay, pinot noir

ABV: 12%

Tasting notes: Peach, hazelnut, vanilla and minerality

Why we love it

  • Rare
  • Refined finish

Crafted in honour of Louise Pommery, this grand cru champagne epitomises finesse and purity. From the prized vineyards of Avize, Cramant, and Ay, its nose unveils floral notes of hawthorn and peach, as you’d expect from a late disgorged fizz. These are then enriched with hazelnut, vanilla, and a hint of tobacco from the extended ageing. On the palate, its creamy texture and harmonious minerality lead to a refined finish with honey and citrus, as the promise of a seductive nose is realised with each sip. The way Pommery hops between delicate flavours, firm structure and velvety mouthfeel is stunning – there’s almost too much to enjoy at one time.

Buy now £199.00, Thechampagnecompany.com

Louis Roederer cristal 2015

Rating: 5/5

Best: Champagne for biodynamic perfection

Vintage: 2015

Grape varieties: Pinot Noir, chardonnay

ABV: 12.5%

Tasting notes: Peach, almond, cream, citrus confit and red fruits

Why we love it

  • Vibrant palate
  • Perfectly balanced
  • Iconic wine

A biodynamic triumph, Cristal 2015 undoubtedly sits at the pinnacle of champagne craftsmanship. Blending chardonnay and pinot noir from seven grand crus, it delights with aromas of white peach, toasted almond, and candied citrus. Aged for more than six years on lees, its vibrant palate balances creamy texture with red berry freshness, finishing with saline, slightly oaky elegance.

Simply put, it does everything to perfection, including its own biodynamic vineyards, the largest independent family-managed champagne house, and deep, perfectly poised flavours – no wonder this is one of champagne’s most iconic wines. Worth every penny.

Buy now £259.00, Thebottleclub.com

Krug rosé champagne

Rating: 4.5/5

Best: Unforgettable rosé champagne

Vintage: NV

Grape varieties: Chardonnay, pinot noir, pinot meunier

ABV: 12.5%

Tasting notes : Cranberries, strawberries, wild flowers, honey and pastries

Why we love it

  • A once-in-a-lifetime rosé

In an industry full of competing prestigious names, some say Krug sits on the throne. A bottle of Krug is a rare thing for most of us, renowned for building up a specific vintage with complementary additions from other years.

This is a once-in-a-lifetime rosé of incomparable complexity and elegance. The open and inviting nose enchants wild berries, wildflowers, honey and pastries, and as the pinot noir-led masterpiece truly blooms in the mouth, five years of maturing come to the fore. Rich and silky, dried cranberries, strawberries and exotic spices echo around the mouth. Krug is forever tinkering with changing styles, hence its use of reserve wines, treating champagne as it should be treated; as an art and a science.

Buy now £330.00, Masterofmalt.com

Your questions on the best champagnes answered

What is the best champagne?

Bringing quality of taste, price point and older vintage into the equation, we were really blown away by Porte Noire’s 2013 blanc de blanc grand cru. If you haven’t had a moment to learn about where this remarkable champagne is produced, it’s well worth a read. The rich history behind the talent and craftsmanship going into each and every bottle is something to be celebrated and the elegance of the liquid inside will undoubtedly put a smile on your face.

While the house may be associated with Idris Elba, make no mistake, this is not just a “celebrity” bottle, it is so, so much more. A distinct richness and elegance come across on the palate with a nose that just keeps on giving and giving. The only issue you’ll find here is that once the bottle is finished, you’ll want another immediately.

For something more affordable and on the supermarket front, we were particularly delighted with own-label expressions from Aldi, Sainsbury’s and Waitrose – the bottles delivered not only from a quality standpoint but also don’t break the bank.

Want more inspiration? Browse our tried and tested round-up of the best white wines

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.