100s of titles, one news app for just $10 a month.
Dive Deeper:
Coinbase CEO says UPI payments suspended due to 'informal pressure' from RBI
In a strong-worded response, Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong said, 'India is a unique market, in the sense that the Supreme…
Indian Government Informally Intimidated Coinbase To Halt Trading Of Bitcoin, Dogecoin, Says CEO
American cryptocurrency exchange platform Coinbase Global Inc's (NASDAQ: COIN) chief blamed India's central bank for putting "informal pressure" weeks after…
Bitcoin tumbles, a stablecoin plunges in wild week in crypto
It’s been a wild week in crypto, even by crypto standards
Crypto meltdown prompts Yellen to call for new regulation
Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen, responding to the recent sharp decline in cryptocurrencies, says additional federal regulation is needed to respond…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Coinbase Customers Sue Over Stablecoin That’s ‘Anything But’
Coinbase Global Inc. was sued over its role in the promotion and trading of a stablecoin that allegedly was “anything…
Coinbase CEO Armstrong Clarifies New Disclosure Does Not Mean Bankruptcy Risk
Coinbase Global Inc (NASDAQ:COIN) chief executive stated that the disclosure in its latest quarterly filing did not indicate the cryptocurrency exchange…
Get all your news in one place
Latest Comment news:
Gareth Hughes: Budgets must do more than patch failures
Comment: When you spend up large just fixing the problems caused by your existing economic system, that's called Failure Demand,…
Read news from The Economist, FT, Bloomberg and more, with one subscription
Learn More
Yesterdaze: Our satiable appetite for Hoskingese
When the weather's bad, the economy's hitting headwinds, and the country's 'in the crapper', who do you turn to for…
The audience chuckled at George W Bush’s Iraq-Ukraine gaffe. I’m not laughing
I don’t think it’s possible to overstate the depravity and horror of the former president’s 2003 invasion of Iraq
Opinion: A Universal Standard for Sustainability Reporting is Needed for Sustainable Prosperity
A yardstick is required not just to measure and compare progress, but also for companies to hold themselves and others…
A fierce fight for south of Sydney, but the Coalition manages to hold on in Kelly land
This election result shows how fed up communities are — not only with the Coalition but with politics in general.
From analysis to good news, read the world’s best news in one place
The Weekly Wrap for Saturday, 21 May 2022
As you read this, Australians are at the polls, munching on sausages (a quixotically Australian tradition), and electing a new…
Taylor Swift: inspiring students about the importance of being earnest
The singer’s commencement speech steered clear of snark, and focused on genuine life advice for the NYU graduates

What Coinbase row signals about the regulator’s intent

By Mint SnapView
Photo: Bloomberg

Its CEO and co-founder, Brian Armstrong, has gone public to say that his firm, which launched its digital trading services in early April, was within days forced to disable its Unified Payments Interface, or UPI, under “informal pressure from the Reserve Bank of India" (RBI). The Indian central bank, he has said on record, forced the company, pressing it from behind the scenes, to disable some of the payments which may be going through the UPI. And not is just the RBI but “elements in the government" too were putting a spoke in the wheels of crypto exchanges, says Armstrong, although the Supreme Court had shot down in 2020 a ban placed by the RBI on banks supporting cryptocurrencies.

The RBI and the government have not denied the charges so far.

It is not that regulators in many other jurisdictions always take such stuff on the chin. But if Armstrong’s charge is true, then what is unsettling is the Indian banking and payments and settlements regulator’s growing recourse to behind-the-scenes moves for signalling its intent. Plus, this episode also raises valid concerns about the framework of regulation. The regulatory framework and the law on digital assets remain a work in progress. India has offered no clarity on what the government’s position on cryptocurrencies and stable coins is or will be. Confusion and speculation rule, as a consequence.

True, the growth in digital assets such as cryptocurrencies and stable coins has posed severe challenges not just here but globally too. And regulators even in advanced economies are grappling with these issues. But the sequence of events in India has taken a strange turn.

First, while the preparation of a draft for the law on cryptocurrencies is still in the works, the government has gone ahead to impose a 30% tax on private cryptocurrencies and a one percent TDS on every digital asset transaction. This was done in the budget presented on 1 February.

Then, days later, RBI Governor Shaktikanta Das issued a warning to investors, making the Indian central bank’s discomfort plain in this emerging investment segment, saying that it was his duty to tell investors that when they invest in cryptocurrencies, it was at their own risk. “They should keep in mind that these cryptocurrencies have no underlying asset. Not even a tulip", he told a press conference in February.

And now, a Nasdaq-listed company has charged the RBI with slapping it with a shadow ban and behind-the-scenes arm-twisting in order to restrain its operations, despite there being no law yet that restricts, allows, or regulates its activities.

Should regulators in a mature economy indulge in such practices? If Das could issue a warning to investors, and he was absolutely right to do so, then surely the RBI could have just as transparently, through a public statement, reminded Coinbase and others like it of the risks to their business from the prevailing regulatory vacuum that will last until the time the government’s legislation is ready and cleared by Parliament. The RBI could have openly and publicly encouraged Coinbase to be mindful of its discomfort. That would have been a far more credible way of restraining Coinbase. Remember, the issue here is not what the RBI wants, but how it has gone about accomplishing it.

There is far more concern now globally, especially after the war in Ukraine, about the need to introduce uniform rules and regulations on cryptocurrencies or digital assets. The US Presidential order in March this year flags off many concerns that the country has on this front. The Presidential order which mandates the Secretary of the Treasury to submit a report in 180 days says that digital asset issuers, exchanges and trading platforms, and intermediaries whose activities may increase risks to financial stability, should, as appropriate, be subject to and in compliance with regulatory and supervisory standards that govern traditional market infrastructures and financial firms, in line with the general principle of the same business, same risks, same rules.

The Chair of the US Federal Reserve, Jerome Powell too said at a BIS meeting in March that many Americans who buy stable coins and cryptocurrencies may not fully comprehend the extent of their potential losses or the fact that such investments do not offer protection from the government which is available to many of the traditional financial investments and services. The Bank of England, the Bank of Japan and others too agree on the dire need for enhanced regulatory and enforcement frameworks.

This cannot be stressed enough.

The cornerstone of good regulations and policymaking which are key to reforms and growth are predictability, transparency and a participatory approach involving all stakeholders. The RBI too should pass the smell test on this. There is a strong case for the Indian central bank to shed the behind-the-scenes approach and be more open, upfront and reasoned in its regulatory actions. That would only enhance its credibility and lead to better economic outcomes besides reflecting a confident central bank at work like its global peers.

What is inkl?
The world’s most important news, from 100+ trusted global sources, in one place.
Morning Edition
Your daily
news overview

Morning Edition ensures you start your day well informed.

No paywalls, no clickbait, no ads
Enjoy beautiful reading

Content is only half the story. The world's best news experience is free from distraction: ad-free, clickbait-free, and beautifully designed.

Expert Curation
The news you need to know

Stories are ranked by proprietary algorithms based on importance and curated by real news journalists to ensure that you receive the most important stories as they break.

Dive Deeper:
Coinbase CEO says UPI payments suspended due to 'informal pressure' from RBI
In a strong-worded response, Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong said, 'India is a unique market, in the sense that the Supreme…
Indian Government Informally Intimidated Coinbase To Halt Trading Of Bitcoin, Dogecoin, Says CEO
American cryptocurrency exchange platform Coinbase Global Inc's (NASDAQ: COIN) chief blamed India's central bank for putting "informal pressure" weeks after…
Bitcoin tumbles, a stablecoin plunges in wild week in crypto
It’s been a wild week in crypto, even by crypto standards
Crypto meltdown prompts Yellen to call for new regulation
Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen, responding to the recent sharp decline in cryptocurrencies, says additional federal regulation is needed to respond…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Coinbase Customers Sue Over Stablecoin That’s ‘Anything But’
Coinbase Global Inc. was sued over its role in the promotion and trading of a stablecoin that allegedly was “anything…
Coinbase CEO Armstrong Clarifies New Disclosure Does Not Mean Bankruptcy Risk
Coinbase Global Inc (NASDAQ:COIN) chief executive stated that the disclosure in its latest quarterly filing did not indicate the cryptocurrency exchange…
Get all your news in one place