Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Edinburgh Live
Edinburgh Live
National
Sean Murphy

We tried Edinburgh's best rated fish and chips to see what all the fuss was about

Edinburgh is a city that loves a good fish and chips, so much so, that when visitors head here it's usually the first dish they seek out to try – after haggis of course.

But with so many top-notch chippies on offer, how do you find the best one? As with most things, many people turn to TripAdvisor to find the answer but incredibly, one of the top-rated places for fish and chips is actually a bar in the Old Town.

Located close to Edinburgh University, Doctors, which takes its name from its links to the old Royal Infirmary, is sitting in fifth place in the review site's best restaurant list beating out some of the capital's more famous restaurants – and it's all thanks to its epic fish and chips.

The portion was massive (SM)

READ NEXT: Incredible throwback video shows Edinburgh fish and chip shop in the 1960s

Keen to see what all the fuss was about, we headed along on a Thursday afternoon to see and found the bar already bustling with crowds and with a friendly wave from the welcoming staff behind the bar, we grabbed the first free seat.

After decanting our stuff we headed to the bar, where assistant manager Michael Kelly, who was deftly manning the bar on his own, took our order. Joking that we should probably wait to see the size of the fish and chips (which cost £14.95) before ordering sides, he asked if we wanted mushy or garden peas (mushy is always the option here) and poured our drinks.

Inside the pub is like any great Edinburgh bar should be, with sturdy wooden interiors and plenty of drams and great beers on offer but also has the added coolness factor of displaying items like the apothecary's shelves and a full replica of a human spine on its walls to remind people of its rich history and connections to the location you find it in.

Thankfully, even though the bar was rammed, we didn't have long to wait and pretty soon a smiling Michael was approaching with an absolute whale-sized slab of golden battered fish and some very enticing-looking chips.

We cleaned the plate (SM)

When we asked how many they usually sell of these a week, Michael guessed around 120 on an average week. Which is pretty impressive and shows its popularity.

Cutting into the fish, (after we'd added the customary salt and vinegar) the batter passed the crunch test, while the fish inside was flaky and pristine looking, so far so good.

The taste was exactly what you want, the crumbly fish and crunchy batter perfectly cooked, we can see why it's popular, and we were happy to note it was on the right side of the grease scale.

Doctor's pride themselves on their fish and chips (SM)

The chips too were crisp on the outside and fluffy on the in, and though they weren't as good as the best chippy chips they were pretty close.

It's obvious to us now why it rivals even the top capital chippies in the ratings.

Overall, we cleaned the plate and enjoyed every bite, and we would definitely recommend it, especially when added to the excellent service on offer (seriously give that man Michael a raise) and the buzzing atmosphere.

It's a pity Good Friday is tomorrow, otherwise, we might have used it as an excuse to come back for another portion, two nights in a row might be pushing it though.

READ MORE:

Fun Edinburgh Easter activities and events for kids and families to enjoy

The underrated Edinburgh spot just named on Scotland's 'most picturesque' list

Edinburgh's five Michelin star restaurants and how much it costs to eat at them

I spent a day in Scotland's 'best place to live' to find out what makes it special

The underrated Edinburgh spot just named on Scotland's 'most picturesque' list

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.