One woman was surprised to tune into Love Island Season 7 and see a man she claims was her high school bully.
“[No expletive] way!” Sky (@skysdaynknights) exclaims in a viral TikTok posted by Angela Juarez (@angeladjuarezz). “He literally used to bully me.”
She then pulls up a high school photo on her phone to show to Juarez. “No way. How—when did he get hot?” Sky asks before the video comes to a close.
In the caption, Juarez writes, “As it turns out Jeremiah from Love Island is @Sky old high school bully HAHAHAH.”
It doesn’t stop there
In a follow-up video, Sky can be seen running her hands along a wall as she screams, “No! Why?”
The reason? She knows another contestant.
In the caption, Juarez writes, “Cierra haunting sky for the rest of summer hahahaha.”
In a second follow-up, Juarez explains that there’s not much more to the story, and it’s not her story to tell; the women just found it to be a funny coincidence that Sky knew two contestants.
‘SO SHOULD WE VOTE HIM OUT TOO???’
In the comments section of the initial video, viewers were supportive of Sky.
“We rise for you girl,” one wrote.
Others shared concerns about Jeremiah and a woman he appears to be courting, Huda.
“I had high hopes for him pls,” one viewer said, to which Juarez replied, “Hopefully he’s not as mean anymore haha.”
User Liv wrote, “NOO so he’s def love bombing. Cheater AND a bully??? Huda ruuuuun.”
“HUDA GIRL RUN AWAYYYYY PLEASE FOR US,” a third viewer said.
@angeladjuarezz As it turns out Jeremiah from Love Island is @Sky old high school bully HAHAHAH @Love Island USA #LoveIsland #loveislandusa #jeremiah #season7 #loveisland2025 ♬ original sound – AngelaJuarez
This isn’t the only drama Jeremiah has been in
One week before the Season 7 premiere, a contestant on Temptation Island Season 1, Amiah Brooks, revealed that a man she was flirting with ghosted her to be on Love Island USA. She did not name the man, but fans speculated it was Jeremiah Brown, 25, based on the fact that the two follow each other on Instagram.
After Brooks’ post, fans suggested she surprise Brown as a Casa Amor Bombshell. Casa Amor is a mid-season twist where half of the original cast go to the Casa Amor villa while the rest of the cast stays put. Six new “Bombshells” are then introduced to each villa to see if it’ll shake up any of the established relationships on the show.
Given that Brooks is filming her own reality dating show, it is likely she will be unable to appear for this twist, but who knows?
The Mary Sue contacted Juarez via TikTok comment and direct message. It contacted Brown and Brooks via email and Instagram direct message. It was unable to contact Sky.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]
