We are trained to be vigilant about expiry dates on our food. We check them in the store and often discard items the moment the date passes, fearing illness or spoilage. Labels like “Best Before,” “Sell By,” and “Use By” seem like strict, non-negotiable deadlines. However, the reality of these dates is far more complex and less about safety than most people believe. This confusion leads to massive food waste. It also benefits grocers in ways they might not want you to think about too closely. Here’s a look at the myth of expiry dates and what it means for you.
Deconstructing the Dates: Quality vs. Safety
The most important secret is that most date labels are not about food safety. The only federally regulated date label for safety is on infant formula. For other foods:
- “Best If Used By” or “Best Before”: This is a manufacturer’s suggestion for peak quality. It indicates when the product will have the best flavor and texture. It is not a safety deadline.
- “Sell By”: This date is a guide for retailers to manage their inventory. It tells them when to pull a product from the shelves to ensure it still has a reasonable shelf life for the consumer at home.
- “Use By”: This is the closest to a safety-related date for perishable items like meat or prepared salads. It’s the last date recommended for use while at peak quality.
The Secret: Grocers Benefit From Your Confusion
The lack of a standardized, clear system for date labeling benefits grocers. When consumers misinterpret a “Best Before” date as a safety deadline, they are more likely to throw out perfectly good food at home. What does that lead to? They have to return to the store to buy a replacement sooner. This cycle of premature disposal and repurchasing directly increases a store’s sales volume over time. Your unnecessary food waste is their gain.
How Dates Are Used to Drive Urgency and Stock Rotation
Grocers use these dates to their advantage. Items nearing their “Sell By” date are often marked down with “Manager’s Special” stickers. This creates a sense of urgency, encouraging a quick purchase of an item the store needs to move. The entire stock rotation system (“First In, First Out”) relies on getting you to buy the slightly older product at the front of the shelf before its date approaches. They don’t want you to know that the item at the back might have weeks more of “peak quality” life.
The Real Way to Judge Food Freshness: Your Senses
What grocers don’t emphasize is that the best tools for judging food quality are your own senses. For most foods past their “Best Before” date, a simple look, sniff, and (if appropriate) small taste can tell you if it’s still good.
- Look: Is there visible mold? Has the color changed dramatically?
- Smell: Does it have an off, sour, or rancid odor?
- Touch: Is the texture slimy, mushy, or unexpectedly hard? Trusting your senses over a conservative quality date can save you from throwing away perfectly edible and delicious food.
The Myth That All Foods Spoil at the Same Rate
The current dating system implies a uniform decline, but that’s not how food works. A can of beans stored in a cool, dark pantry is likely safe and tasty for years past its “Best Before” date. A bag of chips might go slightly stale, but it is still safe. A carton of yogurt, if unopened and properly refrigerated, is often good for a week or more past its date. Grocers benefit from a system that doesn’t account for these nuances, encouraging a more cautious (and wasteful) approach from consumers.
The Power of Proper Storage
Grocers also don’t spend much time educating consumers on how proper storage can dramatically extend a food’s life beyond its printed date. Storing items correctly (e.g., airtight containers, correct refrigerator temperatures, a dark pantry) is far more important for preserving quality and safety than the date on the package. Good storage practices mean you can confidently ignore many “Best Before” dates, reducing your need to repurchase items as frequently.
Shop with Knowledge, Not Fear
The system of food date labeling is more of a manufacturer’s quality suggestion than a strict safety mandate. This widespread misunderstanding creates a cycle of unnecessary food waste that financially benefits grocery retailers. They don’t want you to know that your senses are often a better guide than their dates, or that proper storage can make “Best Before” dates almost irrelevant for many products. By understanding the myth of expiry dates, you can reduce waste, save significant money, and become a more empowered, confident consumer. Don’t let a conservative date label trick you into throwing away perfectly good food.
How do you handle food that is past its “Best Before” date in your home? What are your best tips for judging food freshness using your senses? Share your thoughts on food waste below!
Read More
12 Coupon Myths That Are Still Fooling Shoppers
Can Food Shops Near Me Actually Make You Rich? 8 Myths Debunked
The post The Myth of Expiry Dates—and What Grocers Don’t Want You to Know appeared first on Grocery Coupon Guide.
