Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Environment
Oliver Dirr

The first great energy transition: how humanity gave up whaling

A dead whale is lifted from the water in the bay of the northern Israeli city of Haifa.
A dead whale is lifted from the water in the bay of the northern Israeli city of Haifa. Photograph: Roni Schutzer/AFP/Getty Images

Humpback whales can rhyme. Their songs are made up of individual themes, phrases and sounds – many of them ending similarly. These are repeated in patterns that create rhythms and structures. To human ears, the songs are a series of grunts, groans, sighs, burps and squeaks. But they are arranged by the whale in a highly elaborate manner.

The songs change over time, too: themes develop and are replaced, and phrases shift until every few years a completely new song emerges. Whales also adopt the songs of other whales – like a pop hit that everyone starts singing.

What’s more, whale songs migrate. In Australia, researchers found that a particular song that was initially sung only on the west coast made its way to the east coast. In deep waters the songs can be heard over long distances, so the animals listen to each other. Over a few years, the Australian song was adapted over half the Pacific, from Fiji to Tonga, American Samoa, the Cook Islands and French Polynesia.

It is the same in the Atlantic. The songs spread over months and years. And while the hits of the previous years are still being sung in the east, the whales in the west are already working on new ones. The songs always travel from west to east, never in the opposite direction. No one knows why.

A man views a lifelike audiovisual installation of a bowhead whale at the Maritime Museum in Hull
An audiovisual installation brings a museum visitor up close to a bowhead whale. Many people today are fascinated by whales, but historically they were regarded as important only for their blubber. Photograph: Danny Lawson/PA

Whale song is just one of the reasons why public curiosity and affection for whales has soared. But it was not always the case. For centuries before, whales were hunted mercilessly. Whaling was a voracious industry on which half the world’s economy was built. Blubber became an essential natural resource, and whaling ramped up in step with technological advances.

Then, in 1986, a moratorium was announced, driven by newfound awareness of the glories of whale song – and, through that, an interest in their behaviour, intelligence and culture. In mere decades, the global economy performed an incredible about-turn, and weaned itself off blubber – and on to crude oil. Could this first great energy transition offer us clues, as the climate crisis forces us to grapple with giving up oil, in turn?

***

Small rowing boat in foreground, dwarfed by whale. Whaling ship in background
An engraving from 1835 shows the capture of a sperm whale in the Pacific Ocean. Photograph: Hulton Archive/Getty Images

The Basques were first to commercially hunt whales in the early middle ages. Their target was the right whale – an easy-going, 60-tonne mammal with a mouth the size of a garage. It got its name because it was the “right” whale to hunt, thanks to it being slow-moving and having the thickest layer of blubber. The blubber was cooked into oil, which supplied the many lamps that lit up fast-growing cities. While there were plant-based alternatives, the Basques supplied whales in such quantities and at such low prices that blubber products were more practical.

After 100 years, there were hardly any right whales left, so hunters moved to the sperm whale.

This was the era of “Yankee whaling” when the fledgling United States became the centre of global whaling. The industry was hopelessly romanticised: when Moby-Dick was published in 1851, it was at its peak in the US, attracting thousands of men, particularly the young, who wanted to find their fortune at sea.

But the stories bear no resemblance to the harsh reality. Hunting the sperm whale, which was considered the largest and most dangerous predator on the planet, was a face-to-face fight. Whalers would take out small rowing boats and throw heavy harpoons by hand.

Book cover
Moby-Dick by Herman Melville, published in 1851, presented a romanticised view of the brutal whaling industry Photograph: Ben Molyneux/Alamy

Once the whale was hit, death was certain. With each surfacing, it became weaker, and the whalers closed in, stabbing it with long lances. It was a terrible slaughter – blood would pour from the breathing hole in a sign that the heart or lungs were pierced. The whale was then rowed to the ship, tied up on the side and peeled like a giant orange. The blubber was cooked and packed into barrels.

As demand for blubber soared, whales became rarer. Edwin Drake was hunting for a solution when he discovered oil on a little farm in Titusville, Pennsylvania, on 27 August 1859. This could have marked the end of whaling: the thirst for oil at sea could be quenched on land, with drilling rigs. Crude provided many of the same products as blubber, including petroleum, paraffin, lubricants and solvents.

Four bottles of oil made by different manufacturers
Sperm oil on display in the New Bedford Whaling Museum in Massachusetts, US. Photograph: Philip Hoare

But whaling also offers an intriguing lesson in the concept of progress. On the other side of the Atlantic, progress did not benefit whales – it meant expanding the industry, instead of stopping it. As Drake worked on his drilling rigs, Norwegian whaler Svend Foyn developed a cannon to hunt the blue whale – which had always been safe from hunters because of its enormous size and speed – and a mechanical winch that could get this 200-tonne giant on to a ship.

With the help of steam propulsion, the ships grew bigger and travelled farther. New chemical processes allowed whale blubber to be used to make everything from margarine to paints, fertiliser and pet food.

The blue whale – the mightiest animal that has ever lived – suddenly became a trashy, low-cost product. Whalers moved at will from coast to coast, guided only by what was technically feasible.

A man dressed in oilskins stands on top of whale. In the background smoke pours from tall chimneys
Blubber is removed from a dead whale at a Norwegian whaling base in Labrador, Canada, circa 1930. Photograph: J Jay Hirz/Archive Photos/Getty Images

The technology was developing exponentially. Fleets of catching boats were used alongside factory ships, where the whales were processed. These were converted supertankers, with radar and aircraft support to locate the animals. Whalers would neatly map each area and plough through pods, pumping the dead with compressed air to keep them from sinking while they caught the rest.

At the stern were huge ramps, over which the whales were pulled on deck with a gigantic claw. Once there, it took less than 15 minutes to cut them into pieces, cook them in high-pressure stoves, and pack them off to cold storage.

In the days of Yankee whaling, the whales at least had a chance of survival; with industrialisation, they were not so much hunted as harvested. Even penguins suffered; occasionally on whaling stations, these mostly friendly creatures would waddle up out of curiosity, only to be burned alive to fuel the stoves that cooked the whales.

Man peels off whale’s skin with long-handled blade
Butchering a whale for oil and meat, around 1950. Photograph: Richard Harrington/Getty Images

In the 20th century, whales became vital to warfare. Blubber could be used to make glycerine, an important raw material for nitroglycerine, which was used to make bombs. By the end of the second world war, whale meat fed starving nations, with Japan and the Soviet Union, in particular, ramping up operations well into the 1970s.

The official figures were breathtaking in themselves, but the true horror was only revealed later. When commercial whaling all but ended in 1986, after the International Whaling Commission (IWC) issued a worldwide moratorium, estimates suggested less than 1% of Antarctic blue whales remained. They survived only because it was not viable to kill them: so few were left that finding and hunting them in the vast ocean would have been too costly.

Whaler on deck of ship, silhouetted by sinking sun
A US whaler takes aim with a harpoon gun on a commercial whaling ship, 1971. Photograph: Bettmann Archive

Over the years, the industry had tried to regulate itself with quotas, bans and protected areas. It was an abject failure: whalers would use the highest stock estimates they could find to set quotas; when species were placed under protection, unknown subspecies were invented; when seasons were cut in half, more ships were sent in the remaining time; and when protection zones were established, they were areas without any whales to protect.

The 1986 ban is not perfect – Norway and Iceland do not recognise it, while Japan withdrew from the IWC in 2018 and resumed commercial whaling in 2019 – but otherwise it holds. For the first time in more than 1,000 years, the whales got a breather.

Whale, harpooned and bleeding, is lifted from water between ship and Greenpeace inflatable craft
Greenpeace activists clash with a Japanese whaling ship as they try to shop the shooting of a minke whale in 2005. Photograph: Kate Davison/AP

Today, the moratorium is often cited as an example of how humans can change. But it is worth remembering that whaling did not end because the industry found its conscience or progress made everything better. Whaling ended because there were no longer enough whales to turn a profit – and because people started standing up for them. When the young activists Bob Hunter and Paul Watson manoeuvred an inflatable boat into a Soviet whaler’s field of fire to protect a group of sperm whales off the coast of California in 1975, this was not only the birth of Greenpeace, but a major moment for the ecological movement.

Understanding and compassion grew. People became interested in the songs of humpbacks, the lives of sperm whales and blue whales, the worlds of orcas and dolphins. Cetaceans were no longer seen as a natural resource, but as intelligent and sentient beings that needed protection. “Save the whales” became a global symbol for a better and fairer future.

For generations, the whale was an indispensable resource. Yet within just a few decades, half the global economy was restructured. Rarely in history has there been such a complete and radical reversal in the use of a natural resource. And, while humanity threw everything it had at the whale, most populations have now recovered to some extent.

It may be helpful to remember that what was needed, above all else, was for people to take an interest and get involved. The end of industrial whaling was an epochal change but, in retrospect, it came almost overnight. That is a song worth repeating.

  • Oliver Dirr is a German journalist and author of Walfahrt: Über den Wal, die Welt und das Staunen (The Whale, the World and the Wonder). A version of this piece originally appeared in Der Freitag

The jaw bone of a bowhead whale on Kekerten Island in the Qikiqtaaluk region of Nunavut, Canada.
The jaw bone of a bowhead whale on Kekerten Island in the Qikiqtaaluk region of Nunavut, northern Canada. Photograph: Danita Delimont/Alamy
Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.