Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Newcastle Herald
Newcastle Herald
National
Sam Rigney

The bus crash, a mysterious disappearance and answers in high-profile murder cases

Clockwise from left, Brett Button leaves Cessnock police station; missing Hunter man Zac Barnes; Sayle Newson; Police arrest Dalton Trent Oliver in 2022.

WHAT happened to Zac Barnes? What led to the horrific Hunter Valley bus crash that claimed the lives of 10 wedding guests?

And who murdered David King at Salt Ash, Graham Cameron at Stockton and Wesley Prentice at Cooks Hill?

These cases, and a number of other high-profile murders, will likely reach resolution in 2024.

After years of searching for answers, of waiting out the judicial process, there will be lengthy trials, verdicts, inquest findings or appeal judgments and the community, and most importantly the families of those killed, will get definitive answers.

These are the biggest cases of 2024.

The case: R v Brett Andrew Button

Brett Button leaves Cessnock police station after he was granted bail in June. He has been charged with 10 counts of dangerous driving occasioning death.

When a bus full of wedding guests lost control and overturned in the Hunter Valley in June the crash claimed the lives of 10 people and injured 25 others in one of the country's worst road accidents.

And the question on everyone's mind was how did this tragedy happen.

Bus driver Brett Andrew Button, 59, was later charged with 10 counts of dangerous driving occasioning death, but was released on bail with a magistrate saying he "suffers along with the rest of the community".

But details started to emerge about what happened in the moments before the crash, including survivors telling police Mr Button had allegedly taken the roundabout too quickly, had told passengers "fasten your seat belts" and "if you think that was fast ... watch this" before he lost control and the bus tipped over on Wine Country Drive near the Hunter Expressway off ramp at Greta.

Mr Button's charges later ballooned to 63, with police laying more charges relating to the injuries suffered by the surviving victims.

Since then Mr Button's case has been mentioned almost weekly in Newcastle Local Court as prosecutors seek to subpoena his medical and employment records and defence solicitors applied to extend an order banning publication of his address due to safety concerns.

Mr Button has been excused from attending on each of those occasions, but at some point in 2024, after the charges are finalised and negotiations have taken place, he will have to come to court and enter pleas of guilty or not guilty.

Regardless of his plea, the matter will be finalised in NSW District Court, likely sometime in 2025.

The scene of the tragic bus crash near Greta, which killed 10 people when it rolled on the night of June 11, 2023. Picture by Peter Lorimer

The case: Inquest into the disappearance and suspected death of Zac Barnes

Zac Barnes was last seen getting out of a friend's car near the intersection of Haussman Drive and Tripp Close at Thornton about 8pm on November 13, 2016.

After more than seven years of waiting, it's hoped 2024 could bring some answers for the family of missing man Zac Barnes.

The apprentice bricklayer was last seen getting out of a friend's car near the intersection of Haussman Drive and Tripp Close at Thornton about 8pm on November 13, 2016.

A three-day coronial inquest was held in Sydney in July and focused on Zac's movements and behaviour that day, what was happening in his life around that time and the police response to his disappearance.

Deputy State Coroner Carmel Forbes has heard evidence and submissions but is yet to make formal findings about whether Zac is dead and, if so, how he died, as well as offer any recommendations.

The case: R v Elijah Cage, R v Max Vincent Lowcock, R v Tyson George Stamp

Drug dealer David King was shot in the head at close range in a car in Hideaway Drive at Salt Ash in August, 2021. Three men will face trial charged with his murder.

Tanilba Bay drug dealer David King drove to Salt Ash on the afternoon of August 29, 2021 to supply someone with half an ounce of methamphetamine.

But when the man who organised the drug deal allegedly tried to rob the 45-year-old, King sped away and was shot in the neck and head with a shotgun, his car careering into a tree.

Detectives say the men in the car during the failed drug transaction were Elijah Cage and Max Vincent Lowcock, while another associate, Tyson George Stamp, was waiting nearby in a rented Hyundai Santa Fe.

The alleged getaway car, a hired Santa Fe, was found burnt out in Masonite Road, Heatherbrae after the shooting.

The two men then got out of Mr King's car and allegedly kidnapped a woman who witnessed the shooting, dragging her into the Santa Fe.

The group drove to a house at Raymond Terrace and changed vehicles, while Mr Stamp allegedly drove the hire car to Heatherbrae where it was set alight.

All three men have pleaded not guilty to murder and a trial beginning in Newcastle Supreme Court in late January is expected to focus on what happened in the car in those few moments before King was shot and who knew of the plot to rob him.

The case: R v Michael Thomas Rae

Detectives investigating the shooting murder of Wesley Prentice at a unit in Darby Street, Cooks Hill in 2021. Michael Thomas Rae will face trial charged with murder.

An argument over a drug debt inside a Cooks Hill unit full of people is alleged to be the catalyst for the murder of Wesley Prentice.

It was a bit after midday on July 22, 2021 when Mr Prentice, a 40-year-old from Rutherford, walked into the unit in Darby Street and was allegedly confronted about a drug debt he owed to 38-year-old Michael Thomas Rae.

Detectives allege Mr Prentice and Mr Rae were in a bedroom of the house, but moved into the loungeroom where they got into a "physical scuffle" and Mr Rae shot Mr Prentice once in the chest at close range.

Mr Rae and a woman then allegedly fled the unit and were seen getting into a car.

Mr Rae was arrested 10 days later at a coastal town 20 kilometres north of Port Macquarie and charged with murder.

He has pleaded not guilty and will face a trial in Newcastle Supreme Court in April.

The case: R v Dalton Trent Oliver

Police arrest Dalton Trent Oliver in 2022 over the alleged murder of Stockton man Graham Cameron.

What started as a house fire evolved into a murder investigation after the body of Stockton man Graham Cameron was found suffering a number of stab wounds.

It was about 5am on July 26, 2021 when emergency services were called to Mr Cameron's one-bedroom unit in Fullerton Street after reports of a fire.

Firefighters arrived to find the unit was well alight and later determined the blaze had been deliberately lit.

Stockton "larrikin" Graham Cameron was fatally stabbed before his unit was set on fire in October, 2022. Dalton Trent Oliver has been charged with his murder.

Mr Cameron's body was found in the burnt out remains and when an autopsy confirmed he had been stabbed prior to the fire a homicide investigation was launched.

After a 15-month investigation, police arrested Dalton Trent Oliver, 23, and charged him with murder and intentionally damaging property by fire in company.

Mr Oliver pleaded not guilty to both charges last year and will face a trial in Newcastle Supreme Court in June.

The case: Sayle Kenneth Newson v R

Sayle Kenneth Newson was in 2021 convicted of murdering Carly McBride and jailed for a maximum of 27 years. He has appealed against his conviction, with a decision coming in 2024.

Convicted of murdering Carly McBride and jailed for a maximum of 27 years, Sayle Kenneth Newson's last hope of being exonerated lies in the hands of three judges on the Court of Criminal Appeal.

During the conviction appeal in Newcastle in December, lawyers for Newson said the jury should have been allowed to consider an alternative verdict of manslaughter and argued the trial judge failed to give an important direction to jurors as part of their push to have his conviction overturned or a new trial ordered.

At the conclusion of the hearing, the three-judge panel reserved their decision until the new year and a ruling could be handed down as early as next month.

It was a circumstantial case, but the jury were ultimately left with no doubt that Newson was the person who intercepted Ms McBride, 31, after she left a house at Muswellbrook on September 30, 2014, and inflicted a number of blows to her head and back before dumping her body near the side of a lonely stretch of road outside Scone.

Ms McBride's skeletal remains were not found until August, 2016.

The CCA could either dismiss the appeal, leaving Newson to serve the rest of his maximum 27-year jail term, quash the conviction or order a re-trial.

Newson's mate, James Anthony Cunneen, who was found guilty of covering up her murder, has also appealed against his conviction and is awaiting a decision.

Carly Dawn McBride was murdered by her boyfriend Sayle Newson on September 30, 2014. Her body was not discovered until 2016.

The case: Jordan Brodie Miller v R

Emerald Wardle was killed at a home at Metford in June, 2020. Her boyfriend, Jordan Miller, was found guilty of murder in Newcastle Supreme Court last year, a jury finding the psychosis he was suffering was caused solely by using drugs.

It was a tragic case that made no sense; a young man with no criminal record or history of domestic violence strangles his girlfriend to death.

Jordan Brodie Miller was in 2022 found guilty of murder after a jury found the psychosis he was suffering at the time of killing 18-year-old Emerald Wardle was caused solely by using LSD and cannabis.

There was no dispute it was Miller who killed Ms Wardle; he confessed that night, telling police he thought his girlfriend was a "demon" who was "sucking the life out of him."

But Miller pleaded not guilty to murder and raised a defence of mental health impairment, with the trial focusing on his mental state around the time of the killing and what caused him to be in a "psychotic state".

Miller's lawyers have since lodged an appeal against his conviction and plan to call fresh psychiatric evidence during a hearing in the Court of Criminal Appeal in April.

Emerald Wardle and Jordan Brodie Miller during happier times. Miller will in 2024 appeal against his conviction for murdering his girlfriend.

A crucial issue during the trial was whether Miller's psychotic episode was "temporary" and related to his use of drugs.

But by the time the appeal is heard in April, nearly four years will have passed since Ms Wardle's death and an assessment of Miller's ongoing mental health could play a role in determining the cause of his psychosis on the night of the killing.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.