Granit Xhaka's reaction
We lost two points in the first 20-25 minutes: sloppy with the ball, too many easy mistakes. At this level you get punished. But in the second half we were very, very good and with more luck we could ahve won the game.
Yesterday was not our best training session and we started the game the same way. We had a conversation and said that at this level we need to reach our standards every day. In my opinion, the first 20 minutes was not good enough. After this we were much better.
I didn’t expect to come back to the Premier League. But in football you never know and to be back makes me happy.
Updated
A fair result in the end. Both teams will feel they could have won; deep down both will know they could have lost. This is what it does to the Premier League table.
| Pos | Team | P | GD | Pts |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Arsenal | 10 | 15 | 25 |
| 2 | Man City | 10 | 12 | 19 |
| 3 | Liverpool | 10 | 4 | 18 |
| 4 | Sunderland | 10 | 4 | 18 |
| 5 | AFC Bournemouth | 10 | 3 | 18 |
| 6 | Tottenham Hotspur | 10 | 9 | 17 |
| 7 | Chelsea | 10 | 7 | 17 |
| 8 | Man Utd | 10 | 1 | 17 |
| 9 | Crystal Palace | 10 | 5 | 16 |
| 10 | Brighton | 10 | 2 | 15 |
| 11 | Aston Villa | 10 | -1 | 15 |
| 12 | Brentford | 10 | -2 | 13 |
| 13 | Newcastle | 10 | -1 | 12 |
| 14 | Everton | 10 | -3 | 12 |
| 15 | Fulham | 10 | -2 | 11 |
| 16 | Leeds | 10 | -8 | 11 |
| 17 | Burnley | 10 | -7 | 10 |
| 18 | West Ham | 10 | -11 | 7 |
| 19 | Nottm Forest | 10 | -12 | 6 |
| 20 | Wolverhampton | 10 | -15 | 2 |
Full time: Sunderland 1-1 Everton
Peep peep!
90+5 min Alcaraz is booked for a foul on someone. He’d had a helluva couple of minutes.
90+4 min: Great chance for Everton! With almost all his teammates ahead of the ball, Xhaka plays a casual pass that intercepted by Grealish, who releases Alcaraz on the far side. Everton have a two-on-one break, with Gueye to the left, but Alcaraz farts around inexplicably and loses the ball. He had to play it through to Gueye.
Updated
90+2 min Niall Mullen has saved the email of the night for injury time. “I do hope,” he writes, “that Brian Brobbery’s nickname is ‘daylight’.”
Edit: Niall wrote in again to point his surname is Brobbey, not Brobbery. My fault, I’ve offered my resignation.
Updated
90 min Ballard and Gueye start wrestling as Mukiele lines up another long throw. It’s like watching a different sport, a couple of them in fact.
Eventually the throw is headed down and lumped clear. There are six minutes of added time.
87 min Grealish beats Talbi through sleight of hip but crosses too close to Roefs.
85 min A loose pass from Xhaka is picked up by Mykolenko, who swishes a shot at goal from 25 yards. Roefs dives to his right to push it away, a fairly comfortably save.
Apparently that was Everton’s first attempt at goal since Barry’s miss after 28 minutes.
85 min “Maybe the next innovation in set pieces will be for players to be ‘lifted’ to reach the throws or corners?” says Andy Flintoff.
Oh lordy. I think/hope/pray that’s illegal.
84 min: Double substitution for Everton Carlos Alcaraz and Tim Iroegbunam come on for Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall and Jake O’Brien.
83 min: Double substitution for Sunderland Chemsdine Talbi and Brian Brobbery, the heroes at Chelsea last weekend, replace Wilson Isidor and Bertrand Traore.
81 min: Chance for Sunderland The corner is taken by Xhaka, then returned to him on the right. He whips a glorious first-time ball that is headed over by the stooping Mukiele, six yards out. That’s a pretty good chancee.
Keane’s boot caught him as he maded contact with the ball – Mukiele thought it was in the face, apparently VAR has said it was the shoulder.
81 min Xhaka finds Sadiki on the left. He coaxes a nice inswinging cross that is headed towards goal by Hume and funbled behind for a corner by Pickford. The stop was routine but the ball slipped out of his grasp.
79 min Everton’s first long throw of the half – anyone else getting a bit bored by all these lineouts – leads to a corner on the right. McNeil swings it deep, Tarkowski heads it back and it doesn’t matter because the referee has given a free-kick to Sunderland.
77 min Mukiele’s early low cross from the right reaches Isidor, 12 yards out at the near post. He misses his kick and the ball hits hit standing leg. It was a tough chance anyway.
74 min Everton haven’t had a touch in the Sunderland box since half-time. The first half hour, when Everton were in complete control, seems a while ago.
73 min Sunderland are well on top now. Le Fee flicks the beat neatly to Reinildo, who beats McNeil and stands up a cross that is headed away. Moments later Sunderland have a stronger penalty appeal when Sadiki’s cross hits the hand of Keane. His arm was away from his body, but he was trying to pull it back in and he was only a couple of yards from Sadiki. VAR sticks with the on-field decision.
Updated
71 min A determined run from Isidor ends with an optimistic shot from a tight angle. Over the bar.
69 min Another long throw from Mukiele doesn’t beat the man at the near post.
67 min Everton repel a series of long throws from Sunderland. There are a couple of appeals for handball/a penalty; neither is worth a damn.
Updated
63 min Traore’s off-target snapshot hits Tarkowski and flies behind for a Sunderland corner. Nothing comes of it.
62 min: Everton substitution Dwight McNeil replaces theinjured goalscorer Iliman Ndiaye, who is able to walk off the field but has tweaked something.
60 min Sunderland are still on top but Everton are doing less defending on the seat of their pants. And they are starting to threaten on the break; as I type, the last man Ballard does well to stop a through ball reaching Beto.
58 min “By his standards, Enzo Le Fée had a quiet half, but that little pass to Isidor at the 39th minute was the kind of instinctive creativity that’s his hallmark,” writes Kári Tulinius. “There aren’t many like him in Premier League. Rayan Cherki’s assists for Haaland at the weekend were like that too. And to think that France were worried that the national side lacked creativity. They might have a good team next summer.”
Their C team would have a puncher’s chance of making the semi-finals.
57 min: Everton substitution Beto replaces Thierno Barry, who shakes his head in disappointment as he runs off the field. He missed a glorious chance to put Everton 2-0 ahead.
55 min Grealish protects the ball from Hume and is fouled by Xhaka. Grealish bounces to his feet and he and Xhaka put their arms round each other’s shoulders in a gesture of mutual respect; that was rather sweet.
54 min Grealish isn’t impressed and has words with Hume when he gets to his feet. Granit Xhaka tries to play peacemaker.
53 min Hume is booked for an, ahem, agricultural tackle on Grealish.
52 min “Isn’t it nice after the past couple of seasons to see a promoted team thriving?” says Richard Warwick. “Even after the three-up-three-down of last season, any talk of Sunderland being involved in a relegation scrap was all finished by early September. A win today and after 10 games, they’ll be second on their own. Now just don’t do a Forest...”
It’s dead refreshing, probably even more so because it’s such a big club. That said, I don’t think they are safe just yet – Phil Brown’s Hull team of 2008-09 had a similar start and were nearly relegated. Nearly.
49 min Almost another one for Sunderland! Le Fee belts a long-range drive that is going off target until it hits the back of Isidor and ricochets towards goal. Pickford, who had started to dive to his right, does well to slow his body down and slap the ball away.
Le Fee’s low ball across the area was cleared as far as Xhaka, who swept a low shot from 20 yards that deflected in off Tarkowski. Pickford probably had it covered, but Tarkowski stuck out a leg and diverted it into the net via the underside of the crossbar..
GOAL! Sunderland 1-1 Everton (Xhaka 46)
Granit Xhaka equalises after 46 seconds of the second half!
Updated
46 min The second half is under way. And…
Updated
Half-time reading
Gary O’Neil was expected to return to Wolves after the sacking of Vitor Pereira, but an afternoon is a long time in football.
Half time: Sunderland 0-1 Everton
Iliman Ndiaye’s thrilling solo goal separates the sides at the Stadium of Light. Everton were much the better team for half an hour – Jack Grealish hit the post, Thierno Barry missed a sitter – but Sunderland came on strong as half-time approached and are still in this game.
45 min Two minutes of added time.
44 min A big, swirling cross from the right is met at the far post by Ballard. His header hits the outstretched leg of his teammate Isidor, I think, and bounces up dangerously in front of goal. Keane sticks his head in first and gets the ball away. That was close.
Everton need half-time, a phrase I didn’t think I’d be typing when they were in complete control earlier in the half.
Updated
43 min “If Xhaka doesn’t inspire the team to a win, then they’re taking a trip to the glue factory,” writes Matt Dony. “And he won’t get to come.”
42 min The lively Traore zig-zags superbly between two Everton defenders on the edge of the area, forcing Keane to step out and make another terrific block tackle.
39 min Le Fee slips an imaginative short pass between two Everton defenders to find Isidor in the area. He takes a touch and is about to shoot when Keane comes across to make a fine block tackle.
38 min This is Sunderland’s best spell of the game. Traore sends Mykolenko for a hot dog and mustard, scoots down the right and drives a low cross that is booted away by Keane.
36 min Xhaka’s ball into the box is headed up in the and loops towards Traore, whose volley is blocked. Moments later, after an excellent clearance at the far post by O’Brien, Geertruida shins over from the edge of the D.
35 min Sunderland have improved on the ball in the last five minutes. Baby steps but you do wonder whether Everton will regret those near misses.
Updated
32 min Barry is booked for an inept sliding tackle on Sadiki.
30 min Le Fee’s cross finds Traore in a bit space on the edge of the area. He has time to control but instead tries a first-time shot with his left foot. Traore swings at fresh air, the ball hits his standing foot and bounces away from goal.
28 min: Great chance for Barry! Everton will want a second goal while they are so far on top. It should have come a moment ago when Grealish’s delicious, borderline erotic cross was sliced over from four yards by Barry. The only partial defence is that the ball bounced fractionally in front of him; even so, it was a sitter.
Updated
27 min “I’m not entirely sure with what term fits players of the Xhaka and Gueye ilk, but in rugby ‘glue player’ is quite often used,” writes Geoff Wignall. “It might sound a little condescending but is invariably approbative – and often it’s the captain so described.”
I like that description – but are we sure we know what happens to these players when they retire?
26 min Garner’s long free-kick is confidently claimed by Roefs, prompting the home fans to pay tribute to England cricket genius Joe Root.
24 min “I confess to feeling grumpy about the new On The Ball puzzle,” writes Charles Antaki. “There’s no way of deducing the right answer from the first clue, and even with the second, all you’re doing is trying to read the mind of the setter, rather than working the answer out rationally. Admittedly I’ve been doing very badly on it but, taking advice from the self-help books I’ve been reading, I Refuse To Blame Myself.”
With that attitude, you’ve got a beautiful life ahead. A big, beautiful life.
22 min: Grealish hits the post!
Gueye plays a short square pass to Grealish 22 yards from goal. He moves the ball onto his right foot, then reverses a daisy-cutter through the legs of Xhaka. It beats the sprawling Roefs and swerves onto the face near post.
21 min Sunderland need to take a beat and compose themselves; they’re not really at the races.
18 min Mukiele is booked, presumably for dissent. He’s fuming and is being dragged away by his teammates.
17 min Sadiki, still angry about the goal, is booked for an old-fashioned reducer on Garner, steam coming out of his ears.
Sadiki fell over under a challenge from Barry near the touchline, allowing Ndiaye to collect the loose ball 40 yards from goal. He made straight for the Sunderland area, only one thing in his mind. He zipped between two defenders before veering to the left, away from two more.. That created the space for Ndiaye to screw a left-foot shot into the net from the edge of the area. A brilliant goal, all his own work.
There’s VAR check for a foul by Barry on Sadiki but the goal is given.
Updated
GOAL! Sunderland 0-1 Everton (Ndiaye 15)
A majestic solo goal from Iliman Ndiaye gives Everton the lead!
Updated
13 min Roefs’ long goalkick bounces a couple of times on the edge of the Everton area. Traore tries his luck but is off balance and shoots well wide.
12 min A rare mistake from Xhaka, who telegraphs a square pass that is read and intercepted by Ndiaye. He runs from halfway to the edge of the area and tries to play a one-two with Barry. Geertruida cuts out the return pass; good job for Sunderland he did.
9 min “On The Ball - 90 points, top eight per cent. It’s not for me to throw around words like ‘genius’ or ‘prodigy’ or ‘brilliant’,” writes David Brent Matt Dony. “That’s for others to say. Anyway, a few months ago, I did not expect to be hoping Sunderland lose so they don’t overtake Liverpool in November. Odd season so far.”
7 min Dewsbury-Hall gets to the byline in the area and screws the ball back towards Ndiaye at the near post. His shot is blocked, as is Barry’s follow-up.
6 min Now Sunderland are enjoying their first decent spell of possession. A sinuous run from Traroe gets the crowd excited before the move breaks down. Everton counter and Dewsbury-Hall’s long through pass towards Barry is cut out by the last defender, Mukiele I think.
4 min A fair bit of early possession for Everton early doors. There’s nothing much to relate, though, apart from that Garner effort and the innate futility of existence.
1 min James Garner kicks off for Everton – and almost scores himself after 11 seconds! He played it all the way back to Pickford, who tromboned a long ball to the edge of the Sunderland area. Barry headed it down to Garner, who whistled a half-volley just wide from 25 yards.
Updated
The players are in the tunnel and ready for action. And so is Gary Naylor!
“Just the 261 caps between Granit Xhaka and Idrissa Gana Gueye in the centre of the pitch today,” writes Our Gary. “What would you call them? ‘Star players’ seems a bit too glittery for the kind of work they do, but ‘Super-domestiques’ (as they say in cycling) feels a bit condescending to a pair of seasoned, clever footballers who make the most of what they have.
“I suspect fads and tactics may come and go, but their kind are always needed and they will never go short of a contract until the legs give out.”
Not sure what I’d call them, but every overachieving team needs one.
Updated
Everton manager David Moyes didn’t get the warmest welcome on his return to the Stadium of Light.
The secrets of Sunderland’s success
The defenders Nordi Mukiele and Trai Hume and the midfielder Enzo Le Fée have been three of Sunderland’s best players this season, but have readily agreed to operate out of positions at times. “We have conversations about it,” says Le Bris. “In modern football, it’s very important to be adaptable.” The ‘side before self’ principle extends to the manager. “As a coach I don’t want to be the main man,” he says. “That’s not my purpose. I want to give knowledge and power to the players. I want them to be able to control situations and fix problems on the pitch.”
Team news
Sunderland are unchanged from their dramatic victory at Chelsea. Thierno Barry replaces Beto in attack for Everton.
Sunderland (3-4-2-1) Roefs; Mukiele, Ballard, Geertruida; Hume, Xhaka, Sadiki, Reinildo; Traore, Le Fee; Isidor.
Substitutes: Patterson, Neil, Talbi, Brobbey, Rigg, Mayenda, O’Nien, Adingra, Masuaku.
Everton (4-2-3-1) Pickford; O’Brien, Tarkowski, Keane, Mykolenko; Gueye, Garner; Ndiaye, Dewsbury-Hall, Grealish; Barry.
Substitutes: Travers, McNeil, Beto, Dibling, Coleman, Alcaraz, Rohl, Aznou, Iroegbunam.
Referee Tom Bramall.
On the ball – guess the footballer
The Guardian has kicked off a new chapter in puzzles with the launch of its first daily football game, On the ball. It is now live in the app for both iOS and Android … so what are you waiting for?
Preamble
Oh well, it was fun while it lasted. The Premier League table has been a table of the unexpected for the last couple of months, but now the usual top three – Arsenal, Manchester City and Liverpool – are in place and that’s the end of the that.
Wrong!
Okay, possibly wrong! Sunderland, the team of the season so far, will jump back up to second if they beat Everton at the Stadium of Light. More importantly, in the grand scheme, a win would take them to 20 points – halfway to reaching 40, though you don’t need that many to avoid relegation any more. In the last two seasons, 27 points would have been enough.
Everton’s relegation battles feel like a thing of the past, even if they are only four points above 18th-placed West Ham. Their away form – a win at Wolves and three defeats – has yet to hit the dizzy heights achieved earlier in the year when David Moyes returned to the club. But two of those defeats were at Anfield and the Etihad, so we shouldn’t read too much into it. At least not yet.
Kick off 8pm.
