A user on Reddit has compiled a list of all of the legends in MLB The Show 25 that still don’t have a 99-rated card. While the game continues to add new endgame-level cards, several names remain capped well below the top tier.
According to the post, some players sit in the low 80s, including Bullet Rogan, Gary Carter, and Turkey Stearnes, while others like Frank Thomas, Tony Oliva, and Raul Ibanez top out at 97 overall. Even household names such as Nolan Ryan, Cal Ripken Jr, Warren Spahn, and Gary Sheffield remain just shy of the 99 mark.
All Legends Without A 99-Rated Card In MLB The Show 25
Here’s the full breakdown of the remaining legends and their highest overall rating so far:
- 78 OVR: Jerry Hairston Jr.
- 80 OVR: Bullet Rogan, Gary Carter, Turkey Stearnes
- 83 OVR: Buck Leonard
- 84 OVR: Orlando Cepeda, Leroy Matlock
- 85 OVR: Duke Snider, Monte Irvin, Hank Thompson
- 86 OVR: Andy Cooper, Bill Foster, José Méndez, Vida Blue, Buck O’Neil, Rap Dixon
- 87 OVR: Bruce Sutter, Harmon Killebrew, Leon Day, Hilton L. Smith, Jason Bay, Rube Foster
- 89 OVR: Larry Doby, Satchel Paige
- 90 OVR: Jim Palmer, Martín Dihigo, Ralph Kiner
- 91 OVR: Bert Blyleven, Catfish Hunter, Harold Baines, Lou Brock, Brian Roberts
- 92 OVR: Bob Feller, Dennis Eckersley, Hal Newhouser, Robin Roberts, Whitey Ford, Eric Gagne, Chili Davis, Fernando Valenzuela
- 93 OVR: Al Kaline, Eddie Murray, Adam Dunn, Mike Cameron, Ryan Ludwick
- 94 OVR: Jim Rice, Nolan Ryan, Tony Perez, Willie McCovey
- 95 OVR: Juan Marichal, Lee Smith, Ian Kinsler, Richie Sexson, Terry Pendleton
- 96 OVR: Billy Williams, Cal Ripken Jr., Andrew Miller
- 97 OVR: Frank Thomas, Tony Oliva, Raul Ibanez, Bobby Grich, Dontrelle Willis, Joe Nathan
- 98 OVR: Warren Spahn, Tony Clark, Gary Sheffield, Justin Morneau, Kyle Seager, Mark Davis, Matt Cain, Mike Lowell, Robb Nen
Now, many of these players may get a 99-rated card before the end of MLB The Show 25‘s cycle, and that San Diego Studio is simply spacing out the content. Still, for fans of theme teams or players who just want some more variety, it’s certainly a bummer to see a lot of these names on the list.
