Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Manchester Evening News
Manchester Evening News
Sport
Tyrone Marshall

Manchester United debate over Romelu Lukaku transfer is unfair on Anthony Martial

The night after Anthony Martial showed his predatory instincts in the penalty box remain a work in progress, it was inevitable that Romelu Lukaku would show his are finely honed for his new club.

While Martial's misses in a United blitz just after half-time against Sevilla were just one reason that the La Liga side booked their spot in Friday's Europa League final, Lukaku simply added the gloss to a dominant Inter Milan display, scoring the final two goals in a 5-0 win against Shakhtar Donetsk.

Lukaku's late double took him to 33 for his first season in Milan and they were both brilliantly taken. He will be looking to secure in an 11th successive Europa League game in Friday's final and giving the gnashing of teeth that has come from some quarters about United's decision to sell him a year ago, it might be for the best that the Belgian striker isn't sizing up his former club in Cologne.

It's the way of modern football that players can see the stock rise and fall in the time it takes to miss a chance and having been one of United's stars during the season restart, Martial came back down to earth when he failed to find the back of the net when his side were on top against Sevilla.

But there's no reason to throw the baby out with the bathwater here. For a start, the debate over whether United were right to sell Lukaku is irrelevant because the striker wanted to leave Old Trafford, and let's be honest it's a move that has been good for all parties.

Antonio Conte is almost the perfect manager to get the best out of Lukaku, building a system that gets the best out of the forward, and that's been proven in Italy. Lukaku has been unplayable at times. But had he stayed at United, in a side clearly not built to play to his strengths, then he wouldn't be producing the same output now.

The substantial fee United got for Lukaku, in the region of £70million, also helped them to build a squad that does fit the profile for Solskjaer. Lukaku was not the ideal No. 9 for Solskjaer's United, the real debate is whether Martial is.

When talkSPORT pundit Jamie O'Hara suggested Lukaku's name as the type of striker that should lead the line for United on Tuesday morning, he sounded like somebody who hadn't actually watched them play all season or seen Lukaku's struggles in his final season at Old Trafford.

Lukaku has 33 goals in 50 games for Inter Milan, but he failed to score in 14 of his final 17 games for United. That the three games he did score in came in the space of eight days and produced six goals only summed up the exasperation that he could cause at Old Trafford, going from blowing hot to cold quicker than a budget hotel hairdryer.

In his absence, Martial has been trusted to lead the line and he has grown into that role this season, scoring 23 times in all competitions.

A comparison between Lukaku and Martial would suggest there's been little difference, either. Take penalties out of the equation and both have scored 17 league goals this season, only Lukaku has achieved that tally by playing 355 more minutes, the equivalent of almost four more matches than his replacement in United's system.

In all competitions this season Lukaku's differential between his non-penalty expected goals and his actual goals is +2.8, according to StatsBomb, while Martial's is +6.8.

That might suggest Martial's outperformance of his expected tally will level off, but it also shows how good his finishing has been on the whole this season, dismissing those complaints that he misses big chances too often.

To continue the comparison, Lukaku has hit the target with 46.5 per cent of shots this season, while Martial has been on target 47.2pc of the time.

But the eye test alone will tell us that Martial is a far better fit for this United side than Lukaku ever was. While the latter is ideal for Conte, who wants his striker to stay fairly central and play in the confines of the box, the strength of United's front three has been the movement between Martial, Marcus Rashford and Mason Greenwood.

So whatever happens in Friday's Europa League final, United fans should be watching Lukaku and admiring what he does well for Conte, while realising that Martial is the best No. 9 for Old Trafford. It's been an ideal move for everyone involved

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.