A New York City man says a woman he met on a first date asked him to meet her at Magnolia Bakery. Then she asks him to do something bizarre with a slice of cake.
In a video with over 1 million views, TikToker Sammy (@sammyfilming) stands in front of Magnolia Bakery, a popular baked goods chain. He says he just finished a first date with a woman named Cecelia.
Just before they order, his date reveals that she doesn’t eat sugar.
“What do you mean you don’t eat sugar?” he asks, questioning why she wanted to meet at the bakery with the slogan “Proudly passionate sugar people.”
His date explains that she has a condition that makes her unable to digest sugar. Sammy asks her what she plans to do during the date if she can’t eat any of the sweets.
Her request shocks him.
What did she ask her date to do at Magnolia Bakery?
“She says, ‘I really love it if I can watch other people eat the cakes and cupcakes,'” he recounts.
Sammy enthusiastically agrees and orders a slice of cake and a cupcake.
“We sat down, and I was just going at it,” he says. “And she was making these very loud, very vocal kind of ‘yummy’ sounds.”
Other people in the cafe started to take notice, and a man sitting near them turned to see who was making the noise. Then, the interaction takes an even weirder turn.
“He goes, ‘Cecelia?'” Sammy continues. “He goes, ‘My name’s Jerry, we met a couple weeks ago and ate cake here.'”
In that moment, Sammy realizes that he isn’t on a casual first date. Instead, Cecelia has roped him into engaging in her cake “kink.” While there are no solid stats on the number of people who have a similar food fetish, the Sexual Health Alliance suggests it may be relatively common.
How did viewers react to his bizarre date?
In the comments, viewers defend Cecelia’s method of scouting men to eat cake in front of her.
“God forbid a girl has a hobby,” one writes.
“At least she was honest! ‘I like watching other people eat it’ That was your first clue,” another says.
Others suggest how Cecelia can find more people to participate.
“Cecilia. You gotta take them to different bakeries Hun. This is how I got caught getting 3 different people to buy me Maggie Moos on a weekend,” a commenter suggests.
“Cecilia should start her own bakery so she can watch people eat her cake every day,” another jokes.
“She should have had both you at the same table eating cake so she could watch y’all at the same time,” a third writes.
@sammyfilming But man was that cake good❤️ @Magnolia Bakery ❤️ #storytime #story #storytelling #love #foodlover ♬ original sound – sammyfilming
The Mary Sue reached out to Sammy via TikTok direct message and to Magnolia Bakery via email.
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]
