Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Liverpool Echo
Liverpool Echo
Sport
Theo Squires

Jamie Carragher 'baffled' by Liverpool transfer and suggests reason for Michael Edwards and Julian Ward exits

Jamie Carragher has admitted he is ‘baffled’ after Liverpool signed Cody Gakpo in January rather than strengthen their midfield.

The Dutchman became the fourth forward to join the Reds over the past year, following on from Luis Diaz, Darwin Nunez, and Fabio Carvalho as Liverpool revamped their ageing attack. However, plans to overhaul their midfield remain on hold until the summer despite efforts to sign Aurelien Tchouameni last year.

With the Reds struggling in midfield this season, Klopp has been criticised for not already initiating that revamp with Liverpool instead seemingly deciding to wait in an effort to sign first-choice target Jude Bellingham from Borussia Dortmund.

READ MORE: Jurgen Klopp confirms Thiago blow and four more Liverpool injury updates

READ MORE: ‘My God what have we done?’ - Jurgen Klopp has repeated biggest transfer mistake despite Liverpool midfield crisis

Yet Carragher has questioned the wisdom behind such decisions, admitting he doesn’t understand why his former club opted to sign Gakpo instead of a midfielder in January.

“Since the summer of 2022, Liverpool have committed £180million on four attackers in Luis Diaz, Fabio Carvalho, Darwin Nunez and Cody Gakpo,” he wrote in his Telegraph column. “Liverpool’s owners did not fail to invest. They failed to invest in a midfielder. Now they need a new midfield.

“Liverpool wanted to sign one in Aurelien Tchouameni from Monaco, knowing his market value was £75million. When Tchouameni chose Real Madrid, the money was there if Klopp wanted an alternative, but he opted to wait until 2023, hoping he will lure Jude Bellingham. That was Klopp’s call, not owner John W. Henry’s.

“In attack, Diaz started his Liverpool career brilliantly but Nunez is a work in progress, and I am baffled watching Gakpo’s early performances. Gakpo is not a typical Klopp signing, lacking lightning pace and the capacity to lead a high press.

“Why commit up to £45million on someone who will be on the bench when Díaz and Diogo Jota are fit? Especially when another area of the team needed strengthening?”

Meanwhile, Carragher also voiced his concerns about Liverpool’s search for a third sporting director in two years, hinting that disagreements behind the scenes could have led to the departures of Michael Edwards, Julian Ward, and other members of the Reds’ recruitment team.

“Some contract renewals have also become contentious,” he said. “Everyone was thrilled when Klopp and Salah signed new deals last year. But rewind to the summer of 2021 and Liverpool rewarded 31-year-old captain Jordan Henderson with a four-year deal.

“Henderson has given Liverpool sterling service, but the length of that contract was a surprise, contradicting FSG’s policies on players in their 30s. There was an obvious change of tack after Klopp personally intervened following reports that Henderson might leave. 'We will sort it. No doubt about it,' Klopp said.

"Within 24 hours of an agreement, sporting director Michael Edwards was reported as considering his future, and has since left. The timing was probably coincidental, but there were strong suggestions – not contradicted – that there were internal disagreements about the length and value of Henderson’s extension.

"That worried me at the time and has worried me more when hearing the echoes whenever Klopp speaks about the future of Roberto Firmino and James Milner. Klopp has openly said Liverpool need to refresh and reset, but he seems unwilling to accept Firmino’s declining influence and increasing injury problems, while Milner has been a bit-part player for years.

“In the face of mounting evidence that the race is run for core members of a successful team, it is strange that Edwards’ successor, Julian Ward, will also leave this summer, as have other members of the data and analytics department.

“Whatever their reasons, the team behind the team is changing, and it is difficult for anyone connected to Liverpool to downplay the significance when there was such a concerted PR effort to praise and emphasise their influence over the previous seven years.

“The timing of Liverpool needing a new sporting director could not be worse heading into a massive summer for the club… The club recently envied across Europe for its excellent recruitment strategy now stands accused of bad planning, the only solution seeming to be a fresh surge of major investment in the squad. That is not how anyone saw or wanted it heading into this season.”

READ NEXT:

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.