Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Windows Central
Windows Central
Technology
Cale Hunt

I tested this superb gaming laptop, and it proves that NVIDIA's RTX 5090 is still a massive waste of money

ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 gaming laptop on a wooden table with pink RGB underglow and a "Recommended" award badge from Windows Central.

Gaming laptops featuring NVIDIA's most powerful mobile GPU, the RTX 5090 Max-Q, remain fairly rare, but the ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L) is in my office for testing.

I went hands-on with the ROG Strix SCAR 18 as soon as it arrived, and I've now had a few weeks to put it through a plethora of tests and benchmarks.

Compared to the previous version from 2024, the new G853L model has been redesigned throughout to accommodate the monster GPU and to bring it more into a modern design.

And modern it is, with a revamped internal cooling system, AniMe Vision LED display on the outside of the lid, halo RGB lighting, and much more.

It's still a massive slab of laptop — not much ASUS can do with an 18-inch chassis to slim it down — but it's more streamlined than ever and, for the most part, has been a pleasure to use.

While I'm reviewing the laptop's design and features, I'm also paying close attention to the NVIDIA RTX 5090 Laptop GPU inside to see how well it performs compared to its desktop counterpart.

ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L) review: Cheat sheet

  • What is it? A premium 18-inch gaming laptop with an NVIDIA RTX 5090 Laptop GPU inside.
  • Who is it for? PC gamers with deep pockets who want a potent NVIDIA GPU with access to all of DLSS 4's tools and features.
  • How much does it cost? Prices start at $2,700 for RTX 5070 Ti models, and climb to about $4,500 for a model similar to the one I'm reviewing here.
  • What did I like? It's hard to top the beautiful mini-LED display, and the laptop is set up to keep Intel and NVIDIA's most powerful hardware cool.
  • What did I not like? NVIDIA's RTX 5090 Laptop GPU is not worth the asking price when the mobile RTX 5080 is so close behind.

ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L): Pricing, availability, and specs

ASUS' store is currently the best place to check out listings for the ROG Strix SCAR 18, although availability is spotty.

The same holds true for third-party retailers like Best Buy and Newegg, where you'll find listings for the most expensive configuration.

The ROG Strix SCAR 18 is available with an Intel Core Ultra 9 275HX CPU, QHD+ mini-LED display, and your choice of NVIDIA RTX 50-series laptop GPU, RAM, and SSD.

The most expensive version, with an RTX 5090 Laptop GPU, costs $4,500. However, models with an RTX 5070 Ti start at a more modest $2,700.

The $3,400 RTX 5080 config is the one I recommend to anyone who wants high-performance gaming; the RTX 5090 is too expensive for such a small power bump.

Following is a look at the specs available in the ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L). Note that my review unit has the RTX 5090 Laptop GPU, 32GB of DDR5 RAM, and a 2TB M.2 PCIe 4.0 NVMe SSD.

The ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L) is all about providing the most power possible with its oversized chassis and robust cooling, and it doesn't pretend to be a laptop made for value-conscious shoppers.

ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L) review: Design and build quality

The ROG Strix SCAR 18 isn't like other 18-inch gaming laptops I've used in the past. Granted, it has been a few years, but it's still surprising to see how thin these RTX 50-series models are in person.

Sure, it's a laptop that weighs more than 7 pounds and measures more than an inch thick at the chunkiest point, but sizing is consistent across the PC.

Rounded edges, clean lines, and a forward-facing angle make it seem thinner than it is. The part I like least about the design is how quickly it picks up fingerprints and smudges.

The back edge of the laptop is dominated by the primary exhaust venting. (Image credit: Future)
A look at the ports on the left side, including dual Thunderbolt 5, 2.5GbE, and HDMI 2.1. (Image credit: Future)
The right side includes a bit more venting and two USB-A 3.2 (Gen 2) ports. (Image credit: Future)
The bottom of the laptop has a stylized ROG STRIX intake pattern. (Image credit: Future)

The rear edge, where the laptop is thickest, is dominated by exhaust venting for the overhauled cooling system. This leaves the sides to hold all ports, thus making for messier cable management.

On the left are dual Thunderbolt 5, one USB-A 3.2 (Gen 2), HDMI 2.1, 3.5mm audio, 2.5G LAN, and the proprietary charging port.

The right side is home to two more USB-A 3.2 (Gen 2) ports, with the rest dedicated to some added venting (which does not blow any hot air onto your right hand). This is one of the few laptops with Thunderbolt 5 on the market so far, which is the best port you can hope for on a laptop.

Not only is it great for data, but it also supports DisplayPort for video out and NVIDIA G-Sync.

The AniMe Vision panel on the lid can be customized with your own text, images, and GIFs. (Image credit: Future)

The lid is attached with two relatively small hinge arms. They have ample bite to keep the huge screen in place, and operation is smooth. They do, however, prevent the lid from tilting back further than about 130°.

I really like what ASUS has done with the lid panel, even if it's completely unnecessary. It's now home to an "AniMe Vision" display made up of 810 individual white LEDs.

They shine through 9,150+ pinholes drilled in the lid, and the design is entirely customizable. I mean entirely: you can upload your own images or GIFs, or create an image within the supporting software.

The bottom of the laptop is also ringed with a complete RGB halo. Like everything else, it's customizable for color, pattern, and brightness.

I appreciate ASUS including a one-press "Stealth Mode" that turns off all lighting and effects; they can quickly become distracting when gaming or otherwise.

The SCAR 18's quick-release bottom panel is something I want to see on all gaming laptops. (Image credit: Future)

One part of the design I specifically called out in my hands-on preview is a quick-release latch for the bottom panel.

Just slide it to the side, push the panel back, and it lifts off without requiring any tools. As someone who has stripped more than a few screws when getting inside a laptop, this is a feature I want to see on more PCs.

The inside of the laptop is just as orderly and streamlined as the outside. You have quick access to the dual RAM and M.2 SSD slots for easy upgrades, but the rest of the hardware is protected beneath a secondary metal sheet held in by screws.

Considering you'll hopefully never have to go much further than the RAM and SSD other than for cleaning, this is an ideal internal layout.

ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L) review: Display quality

The mini-LED display is outstanding. No complaints from me. (Image credit: Future)

The ROG Nebula HDR display in the Strix SCAR 18 is phenomenal. If all you need to know is that I have no complaints, you can skip to the next section.

It's an 18-inch mini-LED panel, which ASUS says has more than 2,000 independent dimming zones. This allows for much more precise backlighting to better compete with OLED.

In-game or out, the picture is outstanding. Part of the magic falls on what ASUS calls an Ambient Contrast Ratio (ACR) layer. It's designed to cut out glare and boost contrast, and it works quite well.

No matter what, the display remains clear and vivid.

At around 926 nits peak brightness without HDR enabled, you won't have to worry about much glare. However, lowering the brightness to where it's not searing your eyes doesn't add a lot of reflections in a well-lit room. No matter what, the display remains clear and vivid.

The display hits 100% sRGB and DCI-P3, falling to 91% AdobeRGB reproduction. (Image credit: Future)
This screen gets plenty bright even without HDR enabled. (Image credit: Future)

The screen is Pantone Validated for those who aim to tackle creative and design work, and it hit 100% sRGB and 100% DCI-P3 color reproduction in my testing. AdobeRGB fell to 91%.

At a 240Hz refresh rate, there's plenty of space to let the performance hardware hum, and NVIDIA G-Sync stops screen tearing. Dolby Vision certification is included to push quality even further.

ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L) review: Gaming performance and thermals

A massive vapor chamber and three fans keep the laptop running relatively cool. (Image credit: Future)

As the first RTX 5090 laptops arrived at review outlets, rumblings began surrounding the performance.

Notebookcheck was the first to publish its findings online, revealing an approximate 10% performance difference between the mobile RTX 5090 and its mobile 5080 sibling in the same Schenker XMG Neo 16 laptop.

This led me to explain why RTX 5090 laptops are a terrible value; the 5090 upcharge is generally anywhere from $800 to $1,000 (and beyond).

In the ROG Strix SCAR 18, the upcharge is a whopping $1,100, pushing the RTX 5080 config price from $3,400 to $4,500. Same CPU, same display, same memory, and storage.

Unfortunately, even the overhauled ROG Strix cooling system with three fans and a massive vapor chamber stretching to each side of the laptop doesn't boost the RTX 5090 mobile GPU's performance to a level where I could confidently recommend it.

I'm not placing the blame on ASUS; this is all on NVIDIA.

Viewing the RTX 5090 in a bubble keeps it looking impressive. Black Myth Wukong hit a 90 FPS average at 1600p with in-game Cinematic settings and ray tracing set to Very High.

Far Cry 6 managed a 112 FPS average at 1600p with in-game settings cranked all the way up and no DLSS enabled.

However, once the comparisons start, the RTX 5090's small performance gains are exposed.

I'm not placing the blame on ASUS; this is all on NVIDIA.

My colleague Zachary Boddy received Lenovo's 16-inch Legion Pro 7i (Gen 10) with an RTX 5080 mobile GPU for testing, allowing us to compare notes.

Both laptops use the same CPU and have the same amount of RAM. Both mobile GPUs have a 175W TGP.

Here's how real-world gaming benchmarks played out when using each laptop's full AC power profile. I added benchmarks from the Blade 16 (2025) with an RTX 5090 (160W) as well.

NVIDIA recommends testing its RTX 50-series laptops on the Balanced Windows power profile — the theory is that the CPU and GPU can better balance themselves to avoid throttling — so I re-ran the tests, bypassing ASUS' power settings.

Gears 5 took the smallest hit, dropping from 134.9 FPS to 130.3 FPS.

Forza Horizon 5 dropped from 165 FPS to 150 FPS with DLSS disabled. It dropped from 248 FPS to 233 FPS with DLSS enabled.

Cyberpunk 2077 dropped from 80.5 FPS to 76.5 FPS with Frame Gen disabled. It dropped from 186 FPS to 173.2 FPS with Frame Gen enabled.

In the case of the ROG Strix SCAR 18, which could have the most robust cooling system of any RTX 50-series laptop based on its sheer size, NVIDIA's Balanced Windows power profile recommendation isn't necessary ... at least as long as you don't care about fan noise.

I used Cyberpunk 2077 as a metric, as it's the game that best pushes the PC to its limits. My trusty decibel meter measured 53 dBa using the Windows Balanced override and again at 58 dBa with the ASUS Ultra profile.

Those 5 decibels do make a difference — it's akin to someone talking softly in an otherwise quiet office — but I'm not sure it's worth shaving off around 15 FPS.

The GPU hotspot hit about 43.5°C on the outside of the laptop. The rear exhaust vent hit about 51.4°C. The middle of the keyboard topped out at about 32.8°C, but the WASD keys remain cool. (Image credit: Future)

What about heat? I ran a 15-minute system stress test with the ASUS Ultra power profile enabled to push the laptop beyond what you'd normally see when gaming.

The exterior hotspot over the GPU reached about 43.5°C, but it's out of the way of the keyboard. The hottest spot on the keyboard, near the center, reached 30°C. The WASD keys remain cool.

The back of the laptop is where heat is expelled, and it understandably reached about 52°C. You'll definitely want to keep the laptop's rear venting clear, but ASUS engineered the laptop to keep any hot air from blowing out the sides.

Gaming performance from the mobile RTX 5090, at least compared to the mobile RTX 5080, isn't impressive.

On the other hand, the Intel Core Ultra 9 275HX "Arrow Lake" CPU put up impressive numbers in synthetic benchmarks.

The Core Ultra 9 275HX comes out well ahead of other mobile CPUs we've tested in Cinebench 2024. (Image credit: Future)
The PC falls behind a bit in CrossMark, which is a full-system test. (Image credit: Future)
The Intel Core Ultra 9 275HX dominated in Geekbench 6. (Image credit: Future)
Yes, the RTX 5090 is the most powerful mobile GPU out there, but the gains are too small for the asking price. (Image credit: Future)
The ROG Strix SCAR 18's SSD isn't the fastest we've tested, but it's still more than enough for gaming. (Image credit: Future)

The usual high-end NVIDIA features are here, including a MUX switch and Advanced Optimus for improved efficiency.

Bottom line? This is a laptop that can deliver the best possible performance from its included hardware.

Unfortunately, the RTX 5090 Laptop GPU doesn't make a strong case for itself when compared against the mobile RTX 5080.

If you're interested in this laptop, I strongly recommend saving yourself $1,000+ for similar performance from the 5080.

ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L) review: Battery life

The 90Wh battery hardly takes up any room inside the laptop. (Image credit: Future)

NVIDIA introduced a new version of Battery Boost on its RTX 50-series laptops. It's designed to intelligently lower frame rates when viewing maps, menus, and other low-action scenes.

Unfortunately, when attempting to play games with Battery Boost enabled, I couldn't actually get into any games before the system froze up, requiring a restart.

As with any laptop with this much power, you'll want to stick close to an AC outlet when gaming.

I tried using a couple of versions of NVIDIA's drivers, but to no avail. Add this to the list of broken NVIDIA features caused by shaky drivers.

Running the same games with the same drivers and Battery Boost disabled does not present the same crashing/freezing issues.

Using Forza Horizon 5 as an example, I ran an optimized battery gaming test: DLSS Super Resolution set to Balanced, Frame Gen on, Low Latency on, DLAA off, and High in-game settings. The power profile was set to Windows Balanced.

The 90Wh battery managed about 50 minutes of playtime with these settings. That's not awful considering the level of performance hardware inside, but it's certainly not great.

As with any laptop with this much power, you'll want to stick close to an AC outlet when gaming.

What about productivity work? I set the laptop to use the Windows Balanced power plan with 50% screen brightness, a 60Hz screen refresh rate, and NVIDIA Optimus.

In these circumstances, I saw about three to four hours of battery life before needing to plug back in.

ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L) review: Keyboard and touchpad

They keyboard is comfortable, geared for gaming, and infused with RGB lighting. (Image credit: Future)

The Strix SCAR 18's keyboard is set seamlessly into the deck, which definitely contributes to the streamlined appearance.

There's more than enough room on the chassis to fit a full board with a number pad, and ASUS has gone one step further by adding five additional macro keys along the top.

They're set up standard as hotkeys for speaker volume, mic mute, performance profile, and ASUS Armoury Crate quick-launch, but you can configure each one to your liking.

ASUS says this is an "esports-grade" keyboard; its switches, while not mechanical, have a 20-million-press durability rating, and the board includes n-key rollover to not interfere with your more frenetic games.

Each key can be customized individually for RGB lighting, and it can all be synced up with the rest of the laptop's RGB effects.

Key presses are firm, there's lots of travel, and I've had no issues using the keyboard in the tested games. The same goes for general productivity work, as the board remained comfy after thousands of words.

There's nothing special about the touchpad. It's large, it has moving parts instead of haptic feedback, and it does a good job of pointing.

ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L) review: Other hardware

Two of the speakers direct sound directly towards the user. (Image credit: Future)

I was expecting a laptop this expensive to have some sort of above-average camera; alas, that's not exactly the case.

ASUS went with a 1080p webcam in the top bezel, which is on the low end of resolution in 2025. Nevertheless, color and contrast are solid. I just wish it were a bit more crisp.

The good news is that the camera includes an IR sensor for Windows Hello, something that's not common on gaming PCs. While you get some added security through facial recognition, the lack of a privacy shutter will irk some.

The audio setup, on the other hand, is outstanding.

Testing stock sound out of the box, the laptop does a great job with highs and lows, whether you're listening to music or playing games.

There are four speakers here: two live on either side of the laptop, embedded into the wedge-shaped base to prevent muffling when the PC is on a desk.

Two other speakers are located between the display and keyboard on a raised section. They face directly out towards the user, so it always feels like you're in the middle of the sound when seated in front of the PC.

Sounds only got better when I started messing around with Dolby Atmos controls.

ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L) review: Also consider

ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L) review: Score card

ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L) review: My final thoughts

The Strix SCAR 18 has lots of little details like this throughout. (Image credit: Future)

✅ You should buy this if ...

  • You're a PC gamer who doesn't mind sticking close to an AC outlet.
  • You want premium features like halo RGB lighting, AniMe Vision display, full RGB keyboard, and stellar audio.
  • You want a gorgeous 240Hz mini-LED display with impressive color and contrast.

❌ You should not buy this if ...

  • You can only find RTX 5090 models for sale.
  • You prefer an AMD CPU paired with the NVIDIA RTX 50-series GPUs.
  • You want a smaller gaming laptop that's easier to carry.

I've thoroughly enjoyed my time with the ROG Strix SCAR 18 (G835L), and I don't want to give up the mini-LED display. Going back to my standard IPS monitor for gaming, the difference is huge.

The laptop is a bit big for my liking — I prefer a more mobile chassis to pair with my desktop gaming PC — but for others looking for a desktop replacement while shopping for the best gaming laptops, ASUS has done a great job slimming it down compared to previous generations.

Part of that redesign includes a new vapor chamber and three fans. It's enough to keep the system relatively cool when under full load, and ASUS power balancing keeps hardware from throttling.

The Intel Core Ultra 9 275HX CPU provides a ton of power for gaming, but the RTX 5090 is a different story. It just doesn't deliver enough of a performance difference compared to the RTX 5080 to warrant an $1,100 upcharge.

I strongly recommend saving yourself that money and opting for an RTX 5080 or RTX 5070 Ti model instead. Prices start at about $2,699, which is a lot more reasonable than the $4,500 asking price for the 5090 model.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.