100s of titles, one news app for just $10 a month.
Dive Deeper:
Tory minister fails to show evidence Rwanda scheme will cut Channel crossings
A HOME Office minister has failed to provide any evidence that the Government’s controversial Rwanda scheme would reduce the number of…
Home Office minister admits he can't show if Rwanda scheme will curb Channel crossings
It comes after the British Red Cross and the Refugee Council warned of some asylum seekers in Britain going into…
Ukraine refugees who enter UK via Ireland may be sent to Rwanda, MPs told
Minister also refuses to say whether Ukrainians who cross Channel in small boats could be sent to Africa
Minister refuses to rule out that Ukrainian refugees could be deported to Rwanda
Tom Pursglove also indicates Afghans who served with British Army could face removal under policy
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Home Office admits LGBTQI+ refugees could be persecuted if sent to Rwanda
Report on policy to send gay and lesbian asylum seekers to country raises concerns over possible treatment
Asylum seekers could be sent to Rwanda for ‘spending a couple of weeks in Brussels’ on way to Britain
Foreign shop receipts and tickets can also be used to declare people ‘inadmissible’ for asylum in the UK
Get all your news in one place
Latest National news:
Australia news live update: China breaks diplomatic freeze with message to Albanese; Bragg blames Liberal loss on ‘confected culture war’
Follow all the day’s developments
Read news from The Economist, FT, Bloomberg and more, with one subscription
Learn More
Jets coach Ash Wilson keen to strengthen A-League Women's side in all areas
She is searching locally and abroad.
Bungendore divided over high school as NSW govt takes ownership of land
Bungendore High School is a step closer to reality, but residents are split on the location the NSW government has…
'Our fair share': ACT to push Labor for light rail support
ACT Labor is banking on a quicker Commonwealth Park to Woden rollout under federal Labor.
Can't sow, can't grow: 'Relentless' rain hurting Hunter farmers
Matthew Dennis runs Nebo farm in East Maitland and said he is down a minimum of 70 per cent in…
From analysis to good news, read the world’s best news in one place
Australians woke up to Scott Morrison and didn’t just move the goalposts – they dragged them off the paddock
Voters wanted more action on climate change, having seen first hand the impact of fire, drought, flood and ocean surges…
Zero evidence to back Clive Palmer’s claim of staff taking ballots home, AEC says
United Australia party prepares legal challenge in one seat after candidate allegedly follows and records electoral officers

Home Office unable to show evidence Rwanda policy will cut Channel crossings

By Patrick Daly
PA Wire

A Home Office minister was unable to point to any calculations that the Government’s Rwanda relocation policy will reduce the number of people arriving in the UK via small boats.

Tom Pursglove, minister for justice and tackling illegal migration, told MPs it was “logical” that by striking at the business model of people traffickers, the amount of people crossing the Channel would decline.

When asked by the Home Affairs Committee what modelling was used to give the “evidence base for this decision”, the minister replied: “This is a new and untested policy at this point in time.

I think it is only logical to assert that if you cut off the business model of these evil criminal gangs, then that will materially make a difference in terms of people making these crossings

Home Office minister Tom Pursglove

“I do think that in the fullness of time we will see this policy, as part of a wider package that we are introducing, really shift the dynamic.

“What is absolutely clear is we cannot continue with the status quo.”

Meanwhile charities the British Red Cross and the Refugee Council warned they were hearing accounts of some asylum seekers in Britain going into hiding because they fear being sent to Rwanda, as well as deciding not to claim health support amid concerns the NHS could pass their details to the Home Office.

The scheme announced last month by Home Secretary Priti Patel will see the UK pay for asylum seekers who are deemed to have arrived on its shores “illegally” to be sent to Rwanda, where their claims will be processed.

If successful, they will be granted asylum or given refugee status in the country.

Dan Hobbs, director of asylum, protection and enforcement at the Home Office, pointed to a similar policy being utilised successfully by Australia.

He told the committee on Wednesday: “We did look at where other countries have done this.

“Australia, as part of their wider package of their sovereign borders programme, did it.

“They have had no illegal maritime crossings since 2014, so there is evidence out there.”

Home Secretary Priti Patel travelled to east Africa last month to sign a deal for Rwanda to take unlawful migrants from the UK (Flora Thompson/PA) (PA Wire)

Pressed on whether his answer meant there was UK Government modelling the committee could read, Mr Hobbs replied: “No, you can do some assumption modelling as part of evidence and to assess numbers.

“But defining the individual impact and the individual decisions of migrants is extremely complicated.”

Stepping in, Mr Pursglove added: “I think it is only logical to assert that if you cut off the business model of these evil criminal gangs, then that will materially make a difference in terms of people making these crossings.”

Told by chair Dame Diana Johnson that it sounded like modelling had not been carried out, Mr Pursglove replied: “I would be delighted to hear an alternative.”

He said the cost of processing people to be sent to Rwanda would be “akin” to the current case rate of £12,000 per individual in the UK.

Mr Pursglove has previously said he expects the scheme to save Britain money in the longer term, with the UK currently spending £5 million per day on domestic asylum accommodation.

The committee later heard that Israel sent 4,000 refugees to Rwanda between 2014 and 2017 but that, as of 2018, only nine of those remained in the country.

During the session, the joint Home Office and Ministry of Justice minister was challenged on human rights concerns surrounding the move to stem the number of unlawful entrants into the UK.

The SNP’s Joanna Cherry, who was attending the session as a guest from the Joint Committee on Human Rights, asked Mr Pursglove if he accepted reports by the US State Department, Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch documenting “unlawful or arbitrary killings”, along with forced disappearances and torture by the Rwandan government.

Mr Pursglove said that “overall Rwanda is a safe and secure country” to use for resettlement, arguing that there were “no systematic breaches” of human rights obligations in the east African country.

Ms Cherry QC pressed the minister about Foreign Office travel advice for Rwanda, which states that individuals can “experience discrimination and abuse, including from local authorities” and that there are “no specific anti-discrimination laws that protect LGBT individuals”.

In response, Mr Pursglove said there “is an anti-discrimination law that runs through the constitution of Rwanda like a stick of rock”.

He stressed that decisions to relocate people to Kigali would be taken on a “case by case basis” to ensure it was safe and appropriate for them to be sent there, with legal advice to be made available during the process.

Lone child migrants who have arrived in the UK will be exempt from the policy, the Home Office has already confirmed.

Officials this week were unable to say when exactly removals could begin and how many people the Government is initially seeking to deport, with Mr Pursglove saying only that the scheme was “uncapped”.

What is inkl?
The world’s most important news, from 100+ trusted global sources, in one place.
Morning Edition
Your daily
news overview

Morning Edition ensures you start your day well informed.

No paywalls, no clickbait, no ads
Enjoy beautiful reading

Content is only half the story. The world's best news experience is free from distraction: ad-free, clickbait-free, and beautifully designed.

Expert Curation
The news you need to know

Stories are ranked by proprietary algorithms based on importance and curated by real news journalists to ensure that you receive the most important stories as they break.

Dive Deeper:
Tory minister fails to show evidence Rwanda scheme will cut Channel crossings
A HOME Office minister has failed to provide any evidence that the Government’s controversial Rwanda scheme would reduce the number of…
Home Office minister admits he can't show if Rwanda scheme will curb Channel crossings
It comes after the British Red Cross and the Refugee Council warned of some asylum seekers in Britain going into…
Ukraine refugees who enter UK via Ireland may be sent to Rwanda, MPs told
Minister also refuses to say whether Ukrainians who cross Channel in small boats could be sent to Africa
Minister refuses to rule out that Ukrainian refugees could be deported to Rwanda
Tom Pursglove also indicates Afghans who served with British Army could face removal under policy
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Home Office admits LGBTQI+ refugees could be persecuted if sent to Rwanda
Report on policy to send gay and lesbian asylum seekers to country raises concerns over possible treatment
Asylum seekers could be sent to Rwanda for ‘spending a couple of weeks in Brussels’ on way to Britain
Foreign shop receipts and tickets can also be used to declare people ‘inadmissible’ for asylum in the UK
Get all your news in one place