More than two-thirds of Harvard University faculty voted to cap the proportion of A-grades in undergraduate courses, instituting one of the strongest policies against grade inflation in US higher education in decades.
Starting in the fall of 2027, no more than 20% of a class, plus four additional students, can receive an A. Just under 70% of the votes were in favor of the policy in a week-long electronic vote that concluded Tuesday.
Read more: Students rush to join Ivy League even in uncertain season
The vote represents a “large mandate for change,” said Alisha Holland, co-chair of the faculty panel that proposed the policy. She said the margin was more lopsided than she expected, adding that the vast majority of eligible faculty cast a vote.
Holland urged faculty to start revisiting their assignments and grading systems ahead of implementation of the new initiative. “The hope is that the work will begin now, so that when the policy goes into effect faculty and students are prepared for the transition.”
The proposal has rocked the Ivy League school, where roughly 60% of undergraduate grades were an A in the academic year that ended in mid-2025. The proposed cap emerged in February, with advocates arguing that the current system failed to adequately measure student performance.
Read more: France says ‘Bonjour’ to more Indian students but with a higher price tag
Students overwhelmingly opposed the change, contending it would lead to unnecessary stress and discourage them from pursuing the most challenging majors. Nearly 85% of Harvard undergraduate respondents to a survey conducted by the student government in February opposed the limits to A-grades, according to the Harvard Crimson.
“Students are disappointed,” said Eli Johnson-Visio, a senior at Harvard pursuing a double major in neuroscience and archaeology. The cap will hurt morale and increase competitiveness on campus, he said. “This will only add to the stress and the excessive amount of time that we already spend on academics.”
