Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
Ellie Ng

Daughter of Holocaust survivor among those arrested for holding Palestine Action signs

Carolyn Gelenter being carried by police officers -

Carolyn Gelenter, daughter of a Holocaust survivor, was arrested in central London on Saturday during a protest against the proposed banning of Palestine Action as a terror group.

Among 100 demonstrators in Tavistock Square Gardens, she declared she "can't be a bystander."

Police officers methodically arrested protesters who were sitting in silence, holding signs that read: "I oppose genocide, I support Palestine Action."

In contrast, a similar demonstration held in Belfast’s city centre saw police observe the rally from a short distance, without intervening.

Ms Gelenter, who is from Australia but lives in London, was arrested on Saturday for a second time over supporting proscribed Palestine Action.

Campaigners at the Defend Our Juries protest in support of Palestine Action at The Peace Garden, Tavistock Square, central London

The 67-year-old, who also wore a sign around her neck which said she was the daughter of a Holocaust survivor, told the PA news agency before her arrest: “I wasn’t sure I wanted to get arrested again.

“I thought I’d made my point, and it got lots of media attention, but I just was worried there weren’t enough people and I’m really worried about the erosion of our democratic rights.

“Right to free speech, peaceful protest and free assembly is all being eroded.

“As a Jew, and the daughter of a Holocaust survivor, I just feel I cannot stand by and watch this happening.

“It feels really worrying what’s going on in this country, let alone what’s going on in Gaza and the West Bank. I can’t be a bystander.”

She was later carried off by officers.

Gil Murray, from Norwich, was arrested on Saturday for the sixth time over supporting Palestine Action.

Gil Murray being carried by police officers

The 68-year-old told PA before he was carried off: “People are now increasingly in politics calling other people traitors or terrorists but for the Government to call people terrorists when they’re not, and we all know that holding a placard is not terrorism, is quite another matter.

“We all know genocide is wrong.

“In the Second World War, we fought a war against this sort of thing and the guys who were invading other countries and committing genocide were the bad guys and now they seem to be the good guys.

“I just cannot believe how attitudes have changed.

“I think we are losing the peace. We are losing what we fought for in the Second World War.”

Police officers appeared to outnumber protesters at the London demonstration, and there were at least 15 police vans in the surrounding streets.

Police remove people from the Defend Our Juries protest in support of Palestine Action at The Peace Garden, Tavistock Square, central London

Most protesters who were arrested in the hour-and-a-half-long rally, many of whom were elderly, were carried out of the square – with one young woman’s feet dragging on the ground as two officers carried her away.

Surrounding demonstrators clapped for and thanked those being arrested, with some shouting: “Shame on the police.”

A spokesperson for organisers Defend Our Juries said: “We are taking action today in the Peace Garden because it is a reminder that people acting in the name of Palestine Action only ever acted to save lives, never to take lives.”

They said police failed to arrest 95 people at a similar protest last week, adding that this “demonstrates that the proscription is unenforceable”.

“The ban has been widely condemned as an act of authoritarian overreach,” the spokesperson continued.

Protest is not terrorism.”

In Belfast, a crowd of around 60 to 80 activists and supporters gathered on a pedestrianised area close to the city’s main court buildings at 1pm, with between 15-20 of them holding placards carrying the statement “I oppose genocide, I support Palestine Action.”

Protesters sitting and holding signs in Belfast

Four Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) officers maintained a low-key presence as they observed the hour-long demonstration from a short distance away.

The officers did not intervene during the event and the crowd dispersed shortly after 2pm.

Another similar demonstration is planned in Londonderry on Saturday.

Palestine Action was banned after alleged attacks on an Israel-based defence firm’s UK site and two planes at RAF Brize Norton.

Man holding a sign at the London protest

The ban on Palestine Action, which began on July 5, made membership of, or support for, the direct action group a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison.

Co-founder Huda Ammori is taking legal action against former home secretary Yvette Cooper’s decision to proscribe the group under anti-terror laws.

A further court hearing is due to take place next week.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.