HBO's upcoming Harry Potter series has sparked widespread speculation after reports indicated that auditions for the role of Lord Voldemort are open to actors of any gender. The move represents a departure from the original films, where Ralph Fiennes portrayed the Dark Lord as male. The announcement has prompted discussion among fans and industry observers about the implications of gender blind casting for an iconic character.
Among those highlighted in fan discussions, actress Cynthia Erivo has emerged as a potential candidate. Known for her stage and screen work, Erivo has earned praise for her commanding presence and dramatic range, qualities that some believe could suit a reimagined Voldemort. Online fan boards and AI-generated mockups have further amplified speculation about a female casting choice.
Speculation intensified after a fan-made image surfaced online late Tuesday. Posted by user Dom Lucre with a 'breaking' caption, it depicted Erivo as a 'Lady Voldemort' and quickly went viral, drawing memes such as 'Harriet Potter and Lady Voldemort.' The image drew backlash from some fans who criticised it as overreach. HBO has not linked Erivo to the role, which remains unannounced, and the poster appears satirical, similar to past unconfirmed rumours.
Casting Shake-Up
Entertainment insider Daniel Richtman reported that HBO is auditioning both men and women for Voldemort. Proponents argue this approach could offer a fresh take on the character while reflecting modern casting norms. Critics, however, have expressed concern that changing the character's gender could challenge established canon and alienate long-standing fans.
The series has already confirmed several principal roles, including Dumbledore, McGonagall, Hagrid and Snape. Industry sources suggest that the role of Voldemort may not be filled until later seasons, and early appearances could include visual effects or voice work rather than full casting.
They’re auditioning both men and women for Voldemort so it’s possible we could see a female Voldemort in the Harry Potter series! pic.twitter.com/3Wbr7DsrWY
— Daniel Richtman (@DanielRPK) September 21, 2025
Fan Reactions and Cynthia Erivo Speculation
Since news of gender-neutral auditions emerged, social media and fan forums have speculated about potential actors. Erivo has been highlighted for her intensity in performances such as Wicked and Genius, with supporters suggesting her skill set aligns with the qualities needed for Voldemort.
Reactions among fans have been mixed. Some welcome the opportunity to explore gender and villainy in new ways, while others prefer adherence to the original films. Many commentators emphasise that an actor's performance and interpretation should take precedence over gender when casting. No official statements regarding the role have been made by HBO.
🔥🚨BREAKING: Hollywood actress Cynthia Erivo is allegedly in the talks of playing as Lord Voldemort in a HBO Harry Potter original series. pic.twitter.com/9zNzGuQJ9R
— Dom Lucre | Breaker of Narratives (@dom_lucre) December 3, 2025
this is BS cause HBO wouldn't dare to make a black person as evil as Voldemort 🤣 https://t.co/j8aN5j67HE
— CryptoPunkish (@CryptoPunk_ish) December 3, 2025
There’s a reason why the name ain’t Lordette though
— Dr.K🇰🇷🇺🇸 (@DrCrypto911) December 3, 2025
I would like to submit my own script for this movie.
— Chasiopeya (@chasiopeya) December 3, 2025
Voldemort was once an ordinary wizard. Someone who just wanted to live a peaceful life.
One day he met a wicked witch und fell under her spell. She was jealous about everyone else around him. She slowly morphed into his handler… pic.twitter.com/fuDsIOWjvr
I see it https://t.co/xX5g2JVPqI pic.twitter.com/ULUROpCuiY
— Mr Melancholy (@chakravartiiin) December 4, 2025
Implications of a Gender-Blind Casting
If a female actor were cast as Voldemort, it could challenge traditional perceptions of the character and broaden inclusivity within the franchise. Gender-neutral casting may allow a reinterpretation of villainy while reflecting wider industry trends toward diversity and representation. At the same time, it is likely to provoke debate among purist fans who value fidelity to the original material.
With auditions open to all genders, the portrayal of Lord Voldemort could see a significant departure from previous depictions. Until HBO releases official announcements, speculation continues, and conversations about inclusivity, canon, and the future of the wizarding world remain active among fans worldwide.
The inclusion of the viral fan-made image highlights how quickly rumours can circulate online, shaping public perception even in the absence of official confirmation. HBO's adaptation, confirmed to feature Dominic McLaughlin as Harry and John Lithgow as Dumbledore, is set for a late 2026 or 2027 debut, leaving fans eagerly awaiting further casting news.
