Costco has long enjoyed a reputation as one of America’s most beloved retailers—known for its bulk savings, generous return policy, and that iconic $1.50 hot dog combo. But even the most trusted brands occasionally make decisions that leave loyal customers scratching their heads or even threatening to cut ties.
From policy changes to unexpected product removals, Costco isn’t immune to controversy. In fact, some of its boldest business moves have sparked heated debates across social media and in-store aisles.
Ending the Unlimited Return Policy on Electronics
For years, Costco’s famously liberal return policy was one of its biggest draws. Shoppers loved the ability to return almost anything, anytime, no questions asked—including big-ticket electronics like TVs and laptops. But in 2007, Costco cracked down on electronics returns, limiting them to just 90 days from the date of purchase.
While the company cited abuse of the policy and the rapid pace of tech innovation as reasons for the change, some customers felt betrayed by what they viewed as a rollback of a core Costco benefit. Despite the backlash, the decision ultimately stuck, though it signaled a shift in how the company would handle certain high-risk product categories moving forward.
Removing Beloved Products Without Warning
Costco fans tend to be fiercely loyal to their favorite items, whether it’s the Kirkland Signature peanut butter or the surprisingly delicious chicken bake from the food court. So when products suddenly vanish from shelves, customers often feel blindsided. Over the years, Costco has quietly discontinued many cult-favorite items, including the Polish hot dog, the combo pizza, and even the popular half-sheet cakes.
While some removals are due to supply chain constraints or changing consumer habits, many members complain that they’re left in the dark without proper explanations. Online petitions and passionate Reddit threads have sprung up in protest, but Costco rarely offers detailed reasoning—and rarely reverses course.
Cracking Down on Membership Sharing
In 2023, Costco followed the lead of streaming giants like Netflix and began cracking down on membership sharing at self-checkout stations. While the practice of using a family member’s card had been quietly tolerated for years, Costco signaled a change by requiring ID verification more frequently.
Many customers were frustrated, especially those who had shared memberships informally with partners, roommates, or adult children. The company defended the move by emphasizing the value of paid memberships and the need to protect the integrity of its model. Although it alienated some shoppers, Costco ultimately reinforced that its business is built on trust and exclusivity, not casual access.
Raising the Price of the Food Court Chicken Bake
Few things are as synonymous with the Costco experience as the warehouse food court—and among its most loyal fans, the chicken bake holds a near-mythical status. So when Costco raised the price of the chicken bake from $2.99 to $3.99 in 2022, members voiced their discontent almost immediately. Social media lit up with frustrated comments, memes, and laments over “the end of an era.”
While inflation and rising ingredient costs likely justified the increase, many felt the price hike chipped away at Costco’s image as the ultimate value haven. Though not a dealbreaker for most, the backlash reflected just how emotionally invested customers are in the company’s offerings.
Limiting Access to the Food Court for Non-Members
Historically, one of Costco’s unspoken perks was that even non-members could enjoy the food court—offering a low-barrier taste of the brand’s appeal. But that changed in 2020 when some locations began enforcing a strict members-only rule for food court access. The decision, which gained wider traction by 2023, upset many who had long viewed the food court as a casual neighborhood stop. Costco stated that the move was to uphold member value and reduce congestion during peak hours. While some shoppers accepted the change as part of a tightening business model, others saw it as a disappointing loss of community charm.
A Balancing Act Between Value and Vision
Each of these decisions reflects a growing tension Costco face: how to maintain its famously member-focused, low-cost model while adapting to new economic realities and operational demands. The company’s core values remain largely intact, but as these controversies show, even slight shifts in policy or pricing can ripple through its deeply invested customer base.
Costco members often see themselves as more than just shoppers—they’re part of a shared culture of savings, convenience, and trust. So when the rules change, the reaction is swift and deeply felt. Still, Costco’s ability to weather these storms speaks to the strength of its brand and the loyalty it continues to command.
What Do You Think?
Costco may not always make popular decisions, but every choice has a purpose—even if that purpose doesn’t sit well with everyone. Have you been affected by any of these changes?
Do you think Costco is staying true to its roots, or starting to drift? Add your thoughts in the comments and join the conversation. Your perspective matters just as much as the deals on the shelves.
Read More
How to Save Money on Groceries Without Clipping a Single Coupon
7 Brands That People Keep Buying Even Though The Cheaper Versions Are Better
The post Costco’s 5 Most Controversial Decisions—And How Customers Reacted appeared first on Everybody Loves Your Money.
