Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
ABC News
ABC News
National

Cooma locals say tasering of elderly woman 'disgusting', as police review footage

The next few days for a 95-year-old woman who was tasered by a New South Wales police officer will be "critical," the state's police commissioner said. 

New South Wales Police Commissioner Karen Webb said she had visited Clare Nowland's family at Cooma Base Hospital, and was "concerned" by what had happened.

"We all want to know and understand what happened, but also why it happened," she told reporters on Saturday. 

"She remains stable at this stage, but certainly, the next few days will be critical, and is likely going to be very difficult for the family."

The police commissioner wouldn't confirm whether the officer involved had been officially stood down, but said he was no longer in the office.

"The officer is being supported by his command and others. He is not coping in the workplace, so his welfare is being monitored," she said.

She described the mother of eight children, who also has 24 grandchildren, and 31 great-grandchildren, as a keen golfer and "very community-minded".

The police commissioner said speculation would not afford procedural fairness for the officer.

"In the meantime, we will deal with the facts."

Locals have labelled the tasering at the Yallambee Lodge residential aged care "disgusting", saying other means should have been used to subdue her.

Ms Nowland remains in a critical condition in hospital after the incident on Wednesday, when she fell and hit her head after being tasered by police.

Police are reviewing body-camera footage of the incident, which they have described as "confronting".

Christian Wood from the nearby town of Dalgety said it should never have escalated to the point a taser was needed. 

"A 95-year-old woman being tasered is a bit hard to swallow, to be honest," he said.

"No matter the circumstances, it probably should never have got to that stage where she had to be tasered."

The incident took place on Wednesday at the Cooma nursing home, Yallambee Lodge.  (ABC News)

He also questioned the police investigation.

"Police are not likely to put their hand up and claim fault and obviously we have just got to wait and see what comes out of it.

"They will run their investigations and something will come out of it, but it is disgusting, it is disgusting."

The senior constable who tasered her has 12 years' experience and was with a fellow officer when they went to the aged care home at Binalong Street in Cooma, responding to reports a patient had a knife.

On Friday, NSW Deputy Commissioner Peter Cotter said the elderly woman was carrying a serrated steak knife.

"Negotiations commenced with Clare to essentially drop the knife. For whatever reason, she did not do that," he said.

Police confirmed the great-grandmother was using a walking frame as she approached the two officers slowly.

Assistant Commissioner Cotter said homicide squad detectives attached to State Crime Command had been called into the inquiry.

The Law Enforcement Conduct Commission (LECC) is also conducting a critical incident review.

A LECC spokesman said the commission was independently monitoring the investigation under Part 8 of the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission Act 2016 to ensure "public confidence in the investigation".

Cooma resident Robert Finch said the use of a taser against someone so elderly was unnecessary.

"Police should not have tasered her," Mr Finch said.

"She has dementia and she could not control herself. They could have arrested her without it. There was no need for a taser.

Mr Wood said his thoughts were with Ms Nowland and her family.

"I just hope for Clare's sake, I hope the truth comes out and I hope it is all sorted out. All the best to her family and I hope she gets through it."

President of the National Older Women's Network, Beverley Baker, said she was shocked a taser was used against an elderly and frail woman.

"Words fail me. I think the police need better training on the use of tasers and more emphasis on the history of the person," Ms Baker said.

"I mean this lady has a fabulous history of community engagement, generosity, kindness — but to taser her to stop a 'violent' crime is just completely and utterly over the top."

Ms Baker from the Older Women's Network says the police need better training. (ABC News)

She said there needed to be a greater understanding of dementia.

"There really does need to be a lot more understanding of the way dementia works," Ms Baker said.

"What are the triggers, what are the things that can be used to walk people back — a more gentle, a more generous approach to people having an episode."

NSW Police said the duties of the senior constable who tasered Ms Nowland were under review.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.