100s of titles, one news app for just $10 a month.
Dive Deeper:
Faithful to celebrate canonisation of Devasahayam
Devasahayam Pillai had converted to Christianity in the 18th century
Former Oxford college dean and senior cleric to leave Church of England
Martyn Percy cited a ‘parlous state of safeguarding’ and ‘culture of bullying and harassment’ in the church
We need our politicians to do better: Anglican Bishop of Newcastle
It's time to tell candidates what you expect regarding social justice and community improvement.
Religious beliefs give strength to the anti-abortion movement – but not all religions agree
The leaked draft of Justice Samuel Alito’s opinion in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which has sent shock waves…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Morrison and Houston have 1950s values — and women aren’t having it
The prime minister and his Hillsong mentor are defined by their religious conviction that women serve while men lead. They’re…
Queensland shows what happens when liberals desert the Liberal party
The state Liberal National party’s pursuit of conservative causes has contributed to it being all but banished from Brisbane
Get all your news in one place
Latest Politics news:
Robodebt Royal Commission to be launched this year
A Royal Commission into the robodebt scandal will be launched by the end of the year following Labor’s election win…
Read news from The Economist, FT, Bloomberg and more, with one subscription
Learn More
Ideology matters in unravelling Russia's invasion of Ukraine
In explaining the war on Ukraine, ideology matters as much as interests. This means that we need to factor ideology…
Facebook should be designated under media bargaining code: Sims
The architect of Australia’s Big Tech media bargaining code says that Facebook “likely” should be designated under it due to…
China’s No.2 surprises Anthony Albanese with congratulations before PM’s first big test
China has ended a block on communicating with Australia after Premier Li Keqiang – second to President Xi Jinping –…
The urgent need for a ‘coherent industry portfolio’
A first-order priority for the incoming Labor government of Anthony Albanese will be to construct a coherent and “joined-up” industry…
From analysis to good news, read the world’s best news in one place
Putin's key mistake? Not understanding Ukraine's blossoming national identity - even in the Russian-friendly southeast
Russian President Vladimir Putin’s decision to invade Ukraine in February 2022 has, thus far, produced the opposite of what he…
Conflicts over language stretch far beyond Russia and Ukraine
One key element of the war between Russia and Ukraine is Russian President Vladimir Putin’s claim that the two countries…

Anglican disunity on same-sex marriage threatens to tear the church apart

By Muriel Porter, Honorary Research Fellow, Trinity College Theological School, University of Divinity
Shutterstock

When same-sex marriage was legislated by the Commonwealth in 2017, it quickly became a potential flashpoint in the Anglican Church of Australia.

For the conservative Diocese of Sydney, which contributed $1 million to the “no” campaign in the national same-sex marriage plebiscite, it became the line in the sand that could open up a major rift in the national church.

This week was the first opportunity for the diocese to prosecute its anti same-sex marriage agenda nationally, after COVID stopped the scheduled 2020-21 meetings of the triennial General Synod.

The national church now stands on the brink of that rift, with General Synod – the church’s “federal parliament” – this week refusing to endorse the Sydney position against same-sex marriage.

Sydney Diocese holds that the Bible sanctions marriage between a man and a woman only, and that this traditional position is a central doctrine of the Anglican Church.

What will happen next is up in the air. As an Anglican layperson who was a member of General Synod for 30 years, and as a reporter for the UK weekly newspaper Church Times, I have been following the General Synod meeting via live stream.

The Sydney contingent at the synod is clearly unhappy. The Sydney archbishop, Kanishka Raffel, told the synod the church was “in a perilous position, and no one should be mistaken about that”.

The issue of same-sex marriage was, he said, a “tipping point”, adding that “we ought to stop wasting each other’s time by gathering this way and supporting these structures”.


Read more: Talk of same-sex marriage impinging on religious freedom is misconceived: here's why


Quite what he was suggesting was not clear, but it sounded like a potential move away from the national church structure – in other words, a breakup of the national church. If that happened, each of the 23 dioceses across the country would be on its own. It would be less a schism, and more a return to the situation before the national church was formed in 1961.

However, given Sydney Diocese’s huge representation on the synod following a couple of decades of what is often referred to as “branch stacking” within church circles, most observers do not expect that to happen.

The results of the elections to the standing committee of the General Synod, held yesterday, reveal the conservatives are now in almost complete control of the national church.

Progressive Anglican clergy and laity from around the country who had long been members of the committee have been cast aside. From here on, the national church’s central structures will prosecute a virtual carbon copy of Sydney’s conservative position on same-sex marriage and other issues as well.

Same-sex marriage is not the first flashpoint within the church. Most of the other 22 dioceses are celebrating 30 years since women were first ordained priests. Women clergy are now a quarter of the total number, and there are also seven women bishops across five dioceses. One diocese, Perth, has a woman archbishop, Kay Goldsworthy.

Women clergy and bishops are not only not ordained in Sydney Diocese, they are not even recognised there. In Sydney Diocese, where women are not permitted to lead in either the church or the home, Goldsworthy would not be recognised as a priest, let alone an archbishop.

Kay Goldsworthy was Australia’s first female Anglican bishop. She is now archbishop of Perth. AAP/Warwick Stanley

During the ordination of women debates in the 1980s and ‘90s, there were threats of schism. They came to nothing. Instead, Sydney Diocese has systematically taken over the national church by increasing its representation on the General Synod through a loophole in its constitution. Now it holds a third of the clergy and laity members, as well as members from other dioceses where it has been planting like-minded churches and clergy.

That is why conservatives have now taken over the standing committee, and why they gained large majorities among the clergy and lay members for their move at General Synod against same-sex marriage.

It was the diocesan bishops who thwarted the move. A little more than half of the diocesan bishops could still be identified as progressives. In direct contrast to the Sydney position, they see the blessing of same-sex marriages as a means of offering acceptance and God’s grace to same-sex people in loving, committed relationships.

Moves are afoot in the General Synod as it approaches its conclusion on Friday to call on the progressive bishops to “repent” of their “sinful” position. Those moves might well be successful, but they won’t affect the decision made in what might well be the progressives’ last stand in the national Anglican church.


Read more: Talk of same-sex marriage impinging on religious freedom is misconceived: here's why


However, all is not lost for the progressive position. The General Synod is a limited federal structure that gives the individual dioceses great autonomy. Until now, the progressive dioceses have held back on same-sex marriage blessings to maintain national church unity.

Only two public blessings of same-sex marriages have occurred since the church’s highest court, the Appellate Tribunal, ruled in 2020 that these services were acceptable in terms of the church constitution. It’s hardly been a tsunami, as the bishop of Ballarat, Garry Weatherill, told this week’s General Synod.

Now that real unity is clearly a dead letter, some dioceses will perhaps step out confidently to embrace same-sex blessings and other progressive causes, just as they embraced women clergy 30 years ago. The Anglican Church of Australia might present many different faces in the future.

The Conversation

Muriel Porter is an Anglican layperson who was a member of General Synod for 30 years.

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

What is inkl?
The world’s most important news, from 100+ trusted global sources, in one place.
Morning Edition
Your daily
news overview

Morning Edition ensures you start your day well informed.

No paywalls, no clickbait, no ads
Enjoy beautiful reading

Content is only half the story. The world's best news experience is free from distraction: ad-free, clickbait-free, and beautifully designed.

Expert Curation
The news you need to know

Stories are ranked by proprietary algorithms based on importance and curated by real news journalists to ensure that you receive the most important stories as they break.

Dive Deeper:
Faithful to celebrate canonisation of Devasahayam
Devasahayam Pillai had converted to Christianity in the 18th century
Former Oxford college dean and senior cleric to leave Church of England
Martyn Percy cited a ‘parlous state of safeguarding’ and ‘culture of bullying and harassment’ in the church
We need our politicians to do better: Anglican Bishop of Newcastle
It's time to tell candidates what you expect regarding social justice and community improvement.
Religious beliefs give strength to the anti-abortion movement – but not all religions agree
The leaked draft of Justice Samuel Alito’s opinion in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which has sent shock waves…
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Morrison and Houston have 1950s values — and women aren’t having it
The prime minister and his Hillsong mentor are defined by their religious conviction that women serve while men lead. They’re…
Queensland shows what happens when liberals desert the Liberal party
The state Liberal National party’s pursuit of conservative causes has contributed to it being all but banished from Brisbane
Get all your news in one place