Everyone loves a discount - I'm no exception. When it comes to investing, it is not every day that you can get a quality stock at a lower-than-usual price. As an investor who’s always been attracted to income, dividend stocks are my go-to choice. The question is, which one do I choose?
I prefer consistency, reliability, and consistent growth. That is precisely the reason why I often start my searches with stocks in the Dividend Aristocrats index. These S&P 500-listed companies have consistently increased their dividends for over 25 years, highlighting their ability to thrive amidst any market conditions.
But, as they say, only death and taxes are guaranteed. For Dividend Aristocrats, a single sentence in a report, article, or on social media could send the stock crashing - making it oversold, regardless of the fundamentals - no matter how strong they are.
This is exactly where I find opportunities.
When a stock hits oversold levels and Wall Street calls it a “Buy”, that gets my attention.
In my experience, it could mean that the price action is driven by short-term sentiment rather than the underlying fundamentals. These events often precede a trend reversal, and that's exactly where I want to be positioned before it happens.
How I Came Up With The Following Dividend Stocks
To come up with today’s list, I used Barchart’s Stock Screener. I screened for oversold stocks on the Dividend Aristocrats list. We can find oversold stocks using a technical indicator, the 14-day RSI. A reading of under 30 suggests the stock may be oversold, and a reading of over 70 suggests it’s overbought. If we combine RSI with analyst ratings, we will get a stronger confirmation in our results.
Spoiler: There are no Dividend Aristocrats currently trading in oversold territory. But, stay with me…
- Annual Dividend Yield: Left Blank
- 14-Day Relative Strength Index: Less than 40. There were no stocks under 30.
- Current Analyst Rating: Wall Street’s analysts' rating of Moderate to Strong Buy complements RSI, which strengthens the potential bullish direction of the stock.
- Number of Analysts: 12 or more. A higher number of analysts indicates a stronger consensus and greater confidence.
- Watchlist: Dividend Aristocrats.
I ran the screen and sorted the results according to the lowest Relative Strength Index:
While technically none of these Dividend Aristocrats are oversold, these are the most oversold, buy-rated Dividend Aristocrats today.
Chubb Ltd (CB)
You may not have heard of this company, but Chubb Ltd is the world’s largest publicly traded insurance company. Originally known as ACE Limited, Chubb’s services encompass everything from auto, home, and travel insurance to specialized coverage, including cyber, marine, aviation, and political risk. The company operates in six segments, including property and casualty, life, health, and crop insurance for individuals and businesses.
In its second quarter of 2025 earnings release, Chubb reported sales of 14.8 billion, up 7.2% from the same quarter last year. Net income also rose 35.3% to almost $3 billion.
The company pays a forward annual dividend of $3.88, which translates to a yield of roughly 1.46%.
CB's 14-day Relative Strength Index is at 32.16%, indicating that it is approaching oversold territory, has weak momentum, and is nearing undervalued territory.
CB stock currently has a “Moderate Buy” rating consensus from 21 Wall Street analysts. Combined with a low RSI, we may be looking at an excellent buying opportunity before it gains momentum.
International Business Machines (IBM)
International Business Machines, better known as IBM, is a global leader in integrated solutions. The company has strategic partnerships with several tech giants, including Adobe, Microsoft, and Samsung, among others.
IBM operates through four segments: Software, Consulting, Infrastructure, and Financing.
The company’s second-quarter results reported sales of $17 billion, up 8% year-over-year. Its net income also jumped by 20% to $2.2 billion, and it pays a forward annual dividend of $6.72 per share, which translates to a yield of roughly 2.55%.
IBM’s 14-day Relative Strength Index is at 32.49%. Similar to CB, it is also nearing the oversold territory (which is <30%), which suggests the stock may be undervalued, and a reversal is just around the corner.
IBM has a consensus “Moderate Buy” rating from 21 analysts, suggesting as much as 32.9% upside in the stock over the next year.
Brown & Brown (BRO)
The last oversold Dividend Aristocrat in this list is Brown & Brown, an insurance products and services company. The company acts as an intermediary between providers and clients, helping them secure insurance coverage through its four segments: retail insurance, national programs, wholesale brokerage, and services segment.
Brown & Brown has just released its second-quarter financials, which reported sales of $1.3 billion, representing a 9.1% year-over-year increase. Net income, however, decreased 10.1% to $231 million, which could be attributed to expenses such as employee compensation and benefits, as well as operating expenses.
The company pays a forward annual dividend of $0.60, translating to a yield of approximately 0.58%.
BRO’s 14-day Relative Strength Index is 34.99%, which is still close to being oversold. Let’s say it’s the least undersold on this list; however, current momentum still indicates pressure on the stock price.
Still, the stock has a consensus “Moderate Buy” among 16 Wall Street analysts with a high target price of $130. This hints at a potential reversal from its current bearish phase, making today a possible entry point for investors looking for a bullish rally.
Final Thoughts
As they say, buy low and sell high. With that in mind, these are the three most oversold Dividend Aristocrats today. They’re also the same companies that have consistently increased their dividends over the past 25 years, highlighting their resilience and ability to overcome short-term market fears.
If you’re like me, who likes to bottom-pick stable companies, these Dividend Aristocrats are potentially trading at discounted prices and come with reasonable yields.
