It’s been a long time since Kim Kardashian and Taylor Swift have traded barbs. The reality TV mogul and the pop star have a long history of public beefing, going back to when Kardashian’s ex husband Kanye West stormed the stage at the 2009 MTV Video Music Awards.
With all the huffing and puffing about All’s Fair being, like, the worst show ever, critics have overlooked one thing. That there’s potentially an unflattering portrayal of Travis Kelce, Swift’s NFL star player fiancé, if you squint quite hard.
To borrow the lawyer metaphor, the evidence is as follows.
Kardashian plays the character of Allura Grant, a high powered lawyer at the top of her game married for five years to an NFL star player named Chase Munroe (Matthew Noszka) with five Superbowl rings.
Kelce has three Superbowl rings, not five. He won with the Kansas City Chiefs in 2020, 2023 and 2024 but lost in 2025 to the Philadelphia Eagles.
Chase’s character is from Philadelphia, not Kansas. But Kelce’s brother Jason Kelce did used to play for the Philly team, and both brothers and Swift are regularly papped around the east coast city.
We’re first introduced to Chase when he pretends to forget their engagement dinner, then presents Allura with a socking great diamond ring from Elizabeth Taylor’s personal collection. He knows Allura idolises Taylor, even though he claims to have no clue who one of the most famous women in 20th-century Hollywood was.
Swift, as any Swiftie knows, also loves Elizabeth Taylor. She even has a song named after her on her latest album, The Life of a Showgirl. But she did not manage to buy any of the actor’s pieces when they were auctioned off in 2016. Kardashian, however, is another big Taylor fan and managed to snag herself a set of jade bangles that belonged to the star, to the tune of $65,000. She also borrowed an incredible pair of diamond earrings that once belonged to Taylor for a Balenciaga show.
Chase is also dumb, very dumb. At one point, he complains he “can’t f***ing breathe in this f***ing house with these f***ing perfect paintings” while sitting in front of a framed illustration of a vintage Penguin Classic book cover. Hardly a Picasso. Other characters joke that Chase can’t read, but he does have a very big penis.
People have made fun of Kelce’s reading/writing ability in relation to some of his old posts on Twitter/X. "I just gave a squirle [sic] a peice [sic] of bread and it straight smashed all of it!!!!! I had no idea they ate bread like that!! Haha #crazy" is one such classic Kelce-ism.
As for being well-endowed, well, Swift wrote a whole song about Kelce’s, uh, natural talents: the infamous Wood.
However, this case would probably not stand up in court. Kardashian and at least one of her sisters have dated NFL stars in the past, and she obviously is also a massive Elizabeth Taylor fan. Murphy could simply have written Allura as a role that’s very easy for the aspiring lawyer to play.
Murphy has also cast Kelce before in his horror show Grotesquerie, and even included an Easter egg for Taylor Swift fans in the form of a red getaway car. Perhaps we’re all reading too much into a show that is, to its core, very fun and dumber than a bunch of NFL player rocks.
All’s Fair is streaming now on Disney+
