Saving for retirement is only half the battle; knowing how and when you can access that money is the other half. For years, the rules for withdrawing from retirement accounts were relatively stable. But recent legislation, like the SECURE Act and its sequel, SECURE 2.0, has introduced significant changes. At the same time, financial institutions and employers are modifying their plan rules. The result is a landscape where many accounts are becoming stricter with withdrawals, with shorter timelines, more complex rules, and stiffer penalties for missteps. Understanding these changes is critical to avoiding costly surprises when you need your money most.
Here are nine types of retirement accounts where the withdrawal rules are tightening.
1. Inherited IRAs (Post-SECURE Act)
This is one of the most significant changes. Before the SECURE Act, a non-spouse beneficiary who inherited an IRA could “stretch” the distributions over their own lifetime, allowing the account to grow tax-deferred for decades. Now, most non-spouse beneficiaries must withdraw the entire balance of the inherited IRA within 10 years of the original owner’s death. This greatly accelerates the tax burden and eliminates a powerful, long-term wealth-building strategy.
2. 401(k) Loan Provisions
While not a withdrawal, a 401(k) loan is a way to access your funds. In response to economic uncertainty, some employers are tightening the rules for these loans. They might reduce the number of loans an employee can have outstanding at one time or become more stringent in enforcing repayment terms. If you leave your job with an outstanding loan, the deadline to repay it before it’s considered a taxable distribution (with a 10% penalty) can be very short.
3. Hardship Withdrawals From 401(k)s
The rules for hardship withdrawals have always been strict, requiring an “immediate and heavy financial need.” While SECURE 2.0 made it slightly easier for employers to administer these, the documentation requirements can still be onerous. Plan administrators are often becoming more diligent in requiring proof of the hardship to avoid compliance issues. They may also enforce rules that require you to suspend your contributions to the plan for a period after taking a hardship withdrawal.
4. Roth IRA Contributions
One of the best features of a Roth IRA is that you can withdraw your direct contributions (not earnings) at any time, tax-free and penalty-free. However, the five-year rule adds a layer of complexity. For a withdrawal of *earnings* to be qualified (tax-free and penalty-free), the account must have been open for at least five tax years. This rule is becoming more of a trap as more people use Roth IRAs for short-term savings goals without fully understanding the distinction between contributions and earnings.
5. Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) for Non-Medical Expenses
HSAs are a powerful retirement tool because funds can be withdrawn tax-free for qualified medical expenses at any age. After age 65, you can withdraw money for any reason without a penalty, but you will have to pay ordinary income tax on the withdrawal, just like a traditional IRA. As HSAs become more popular, the IRS is paying closer attention to ensure that pre-65 withdrawals are being used for legitimate medical expenses, and the penalties for non-qualified withdrawals are steep (income tax plus a 20% penalty).
6. Pension Plan Lump-Sum Payouts
Traditional defined-benefit pension plans are becoming rarer, and many companies are looking to “de-risk” by offering current and former employees a one-time lump-sum payout instead of a lifelong monthly annuity. While this gives you control over the money, companies are often making these offers in very limited windows. If you miss the deadline to accept the offer, you lose the option forever, forcing you to stick with the annuity, which might not be the best choice for your financial situation.</p
7. Annuity Contracts with Surrender Charges
Annuities are insurance products often sold as part of a retirement plan. Many come with long and steep surrender charge periods. If you need to withdraw more than a small, specified amount (e.g., 10%) from your annuity in the first several years (sometimes as long as 10 years or more), you will be hit with a hefty surrender charge. These fees are not new, but as interest rates fluctuate, the terms of new annuity contracts can become more restrictive.
8. Employer Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs)
In an ESOP, employees are given shares of company stock in their retirement account. The rules for when you can take a distribution of your stock or cash out are governed by the plan document and can be complex. Companies can have strict rules about when and how you can diversify your holdings, and when you leave the company, you may have to wait a significant amount of time before you can receive your payout, especially in a privately held company.
9. 457(b) Plans After Separation from Service
457(b) plans are retirement accounts for state and local government employees. They have a unique feature: you can take penalty-free withdrawals of your money as soon as you leave your job, regardless of your age. However, there’s a catch. Once you roll that money over into a traditional IRA, you lose that special privilege and are once again subject to the 10% early withdrawal penalty for any distributions before age 59½. This makes the decision of what to do with your 457(b) upon retirement a critical one.
Accessing Your Nest Egg Isn’t Always Easy
The retirement savings landscape is constantly evolving. The days of simple, stable withdrawal rules are fading as new laws and plan designs add layers of complexity. Many accounts are becoming stricter with withdrawals, and it is your responsibility to keep up with the changes. Regularly reviewing your plan documents and consulting with a financial advisor can help you navigate these rules and ensure that you can access your money when you need it, without any costly surprises.
Have you ever been surprised by the rules or penalties for taking money out of a retirement account?
Read more:
Are You Making This Retirement Mistake That Voids State Tax Breaks?
8 Money Moves That Look Smart—But Will Backfire in Retirement
The post 9 Retirement Accounts That Are Getting Stricter With Withdrawals appeared first on Budget and the Bees.
