Gone are the days when store brands were the knockoffs no one wanted to admit buying. In 2024, store brands are not only competing with big-name products—they’re outselling them in several categories. Thanks to rising food costs, better quality, and smart packaging, shoppers are flocking to these budget-friendly alternatives. Retailers are doubling down on their private-label lines, often offering the same or better quality at a lower price. If you haven’t taken a closer look at the store brand aisle lately, you might be missing out on big savings and even better taste.
1. Costco’s Kirkland Signature vs. Tide Detergent
Kirkland Signature’s Ultra Clean Laundry Detergent has become a household staple—and it’s giving Tide a serious run for its money. Many customers report comparable stain-fighting power, with fewer harsh chemicals and a significantly lower price per load. In fact, Kirkland’s detergent is often manufactured by the same companies that make the name-brand products. Costco members consistently rank Kirkland among the best store brands for quality and value. When buying in bulk, Kirkland is often the smarter pick.
2. Trader Joe’s Peanut Butter vs. Jif
Trader Joe’s creamy and crunchy peanut butters have become a fan favorite among health-conscious snackers. Made with minimal ingredients—just peanuts and salt—they’re a cleaner alternative to Jif and other legacy brands that contain added sugars and oils. Despite the simple recipe, the flavor is rich, and the price is consistently lower. Shoppers looking for natural products with a shorter ingredient list are making the switch. It’s one of the most successful store brands on Trader Joe’s shelves.
3. Aldi’s Millville Cereals vs. General Mills
Aldi’s Millville cereals are doing more than just mimicking General Mills—they’re dominating the breakfast aisle with affordability and taste. From Frosted Flakes to Honey Nut O’s, the flavors are shockingly similar, and the prices are sometimes half that of the national brands. Parents especially appreciate the savings on bulk breakfast options without sacrificing quality. Aldi’s focus on private labels helps keep prices down across the board. For many families, Millville is the new morning routine.
4. Walmart’s Great Value Cheese vs. Kraft
When it comes to shredded cheddar or sliced American, Walmart’s Great Value brand has seen strong sales that often rival Kraft. The taste and melt quality are nearly identical, and the price difference adds up quickly for families shopping in volume. Great Value has expanded its cheese selection to include organic and specialty options, giving even more incentive to skip the name brand. For those on a budget, this store brand easily becomes the default. It proves you don’t need a big name to deliver flavor.
5. Target’s Good & Gather Snacks vs. Nabisco
Target’s Good & Gather line has gained loyal fans thanks to its elevated packaging and surprisingly tasty snacks. Items like cheese crisps, peanut butter pretzels, and trail mixes are often placed directly next to Nabisco products—and they’re outselling them in many stores. Customers praise the brand for its transparency, clean ingredients, and bold flavors. Plus, the price savings are hard to ignore when you’re shopping for kids or party snacks. This Target-exclusive store brand continues to expand, and shoppers are here for it.
6. Amazon’s Happy Belly Coffee vs. Starbucks K-Cups
Amazon’s private label, Happy Belly, has stepped into the coffee aisle with bold brews at bargain prices. Compared to Starbucks-branded K-cups or grounds, Happy Belly offers similar roasts at nearly half the cost. Reviews highlight smooth flavors and good variety, from medium roast to dark espresso blends. With Amazon Prime’s fast delivery and auto-ship options, many coffee lovers are ditching the big names altogether. Happy Belly is quickly brewing its place as a go-to store brand for caffeine lovers.
7. Sam’s Club Member’s Mark Paper Towels vs. Bounty
Bounty may have the branding, but Sam’s Club’s Member’s Mark paper towels are catching up fast in both performance and popularity. Known for durability and absorbency, these towels often outperform national competitors in consumer tests. Bulk shoppers appreciate the value per roll and consistent availability. For households with kids or messy kitchens, quality paper towels matter—and Member’s Mark delivers. It’s one of the most trusted store brands in Sam’s Club’s arsenal.
8. Whole Foods 365 Pasta Sauce vs. Prego
Whole Foods’ 365 Everyday Value line offers simple, organic options at competitive prices. Their pasta sauces, especially marinara and tomato basil, have been praised for clean flavor and minimal sugar compared to brands like Prego or Ragu. Health-focused shoppers love the short ingredient list and non-GMO labels. Though Whole Foods once had a high-cost reputation, 365 proves it can compete in both taste and price. For many, it’s now the sauce of choice in the pantry.
The Shift Is Real—Store Brands Are Winning
For years, name brands held the upper hand in consumer trust—but that gap is closing fast. Whether driven by rising prices or a desire for cleaner labels, shoppers are discovering that many store brands offer the same (or better) experience without the premium price tag. As these private labels continue to innovate and deliver consistent quality, loyalty is shifting where it matters most—at the register. Next time you shop, don’t overlook the house brand. It might just be your new favorite.
Have you switched from a name brand to a store brand that was just as good—or even better? Share your favorites in the comments and let others know where to save big without sacrificing quality!
Read More
9 Store Brands That Outsold the Originals in 2025
10 Brand Names That Are Actually Owned By the Same Company
The post 8 Store Brands Outselling the Big Names at the Register appeared first on Grocery Coupon Guide.
