Love a good deal? You’ll be surprised how often budget brands outsell premium labels when tested blind. Consumer studies show time and time again that less expensive store-brand products often win over pricier rivals in taste tests. In this article, we explore 7 budget brands that outsell premium labels in blind taste tests, revealing real-world examples and insights you can use. You’ll learn how perception shapes choice—and how you can save without sacrificing flavor. Keep reading if you’re skeptical of premium price tags, because taste doesn’t always match the label.
1. Supermarket Private Label vs. National Cookies, Yogurt, Ice Cream
Researchers conducting in-store blind taste tests found that private-label products in categories like cookies, Greek yogurt, and ice cream consistently beat national brands such as Oreos, Chobani, and Breyers. Most participants underestimated their likelihood of choosing private labels before tasting, but once blind sampled, the majority preferred the budget option. Sales data showed private labels gained 15 percentage points share the week after tasting, with sustained effects over months. That kind of data shows budget brands outsell premium labels when taste is the only criterion. The findings held across multiple categories and locations.
2. Lidl Deluxe Pork Sausages vs Premium Brands in the UK
Which? UK ran a blind taste test comparing 12 sausage brands, including premium labels like M&S Collection. Lidl’s Deluxe Pork Sausages came out on top with a 77 % score, beating M&S’s 75 % while costing roughly half the price. Testers praised Lidl’s juicy texture and seasoning balance, making it a standout value pick. Participants rated it favorably on flavor, texture, and affordability. That’s a clear example of budget brands outselling premium even in meat categories.
3. Store-Band vs Name-Brand Across 29 Food Categories
Consumer Reports conducted blind testing in 29 food categories, comparing national brands versus cheaper store brands. They found store brands tied or won in 19 of those cases, while name brands only won in 6. Despite the perception that premium brands must taste better, store-label alternatives delivered comparable or better flavor—often at a 27 % lower average price. That broad success across categories underlines how budget brands outsell premium brands under blind conditions. These tests confirm that price doesn’t always equate to quality in taste.
4. Aldi Nordpak Spreadable Butter vs Lurpak
In a blind spread test, Aldi’s own-brand Nordpak Slightly Salted Spread scored 75 %, while premium brand Lurpak scored 72 %. Aldi’s butter was significantly cheaper—about 44p per 100 g versus Lurpak’s £1.19 per 100 g. Taste testers found Aldi’s butter creamier and well-seasoned. Many felt the budget spread was actually superior, despite the lower price tag. Another instance where budget brands outsell premium brands on flavor and value.
5. Private-Label Beanies vs Major Brands in Bean Taste Tests
In the U.K., blind taste tests of baked beans compared big names like Heinz and Branston to supermarket own labels from Lidl and Morrisons. Usurping expectations, the bean brands from Lidl and Morrisons tied for top taste scores—even though they cost well under half the price of Heinz. Consumers noted flavor and texture parity or even preference for budget versions. It shows that blind evaluation often favors store labels over premium. That’s another case where budget brands outsell premium.
6. Generic vs. Premium Ingredients on Blind Showdowns
In various viral blind taste battles (often shared on YouTube or Reddit), budget ingredients like basic chocolate or vinegar repeatedly outscore expensive gourmet versions. In one popular test, tasters were asked to distinguish high-end versus budget ingredients—and frequently misidentified or preferred cheaper options. The results showed many faux premium items fell flat compared to simple alternatives. These informal but telling experiments reinforce that budget brands outsell premium when price labels are stripped away. People often prefer taste when bias is removed.
7. Blind Tests Reveal Preconceptions Trump Taste—Until You Sample
Babson College researchers and other psychologists have found that preconceptions about price or prestige strongly shape sensory ratings. When participants believed they were tasting an expensive product, its rating improved—but after putting down the packaging and retesting blind, they often preferred the cheaper item. In these cases, price expectation did more to elevate perceived quality than actual sensory experience. This psychological effect shows why budget brands outsell premium labels in blind settings. Many value-conscious shoppers are their own best taste-testers.
How to Choose Smart When Taste Is Your Priority
Next time you’re shopping, don’t rely solely on flashy packaging or high price tags. Try a blind comparison at home—pouring similar products side-by-side to see which you prefer. Use store brands as your starting point—they often deliver high quality for less. Check reviews or taste-test results from trusted sources like consumer groups to guide purchases. Ultimately, trust your palate more than the premium labels—they don’t always guarantee superior flavor.
Have you tried a budget product that surprised you in a taste test? Which product won you over, and how did it compare? Share your stories or favorite finds in the comments!
Read More
9 Budget Foods That Aren’t Actually Budget-Friendly Anymore
10 Things Middle-Class Families Are Cutting From the Weekly Budget
The post 7 Budget Brands That Outsell Premium Labels in Blind Taste Tests appeared first on Grocery Coupon Guide.
