First dates are all about making a great first impression, and what you order to drink can say more than you think. While everyone should feel free to enjoy their evening, certain choices can unintentionally send the wrong signal—whether they come off as too strong, too messy, or just plain complicated. Understanding which drinks women should never order on a first date isn’t about following outdated rules; it’s about setting yourself up for a smooth, comfortable experience. Here are ten drinks that can quickly derail an otherwise great evening and why it’s smarter to skip them.
1. Anything with Strong Tequila Shots
Starting the night with tequila shots might sound fun, but it can set the wrong tone fast. Tequila is known for its wild-party reputation, and ordering it right away can make things feel less like a date and more like spring break. While it’s fine to enjoy one later in the night, multiple rounds can blur boundaries and lower inhibitions. First dates should focus on connection, not chaos. It’s one of the classic drinks women should never order on a first date if they want to stay classy and in control.
2. The Long Island Iced Tea Trap
It looks innocent, but a Long Island Iced Tea hides five different types of alcohol in one tall glass. It’s strong, unpredictable, and often hits harder than expected. Ordering one can come across as an attempt to get buzzed quickly rather than enjoy a light drink and good conversation. Plus, it’s tough to gauge your limits with something that tastes like sweet tea. When it comes to drinks, women should never order on a first date; this one tops the list for all the wrong reasons.
3. The Extra-Sugary Frozen Cocktail
Frozen margaritas, daiquiris, and piña coladas might look picture-perfect, but they’re loaded with sugar and syrup. Not only can they leave you feeling bloated, but they also melt fast, creating sticky chaos on the table. These overly sweet concoctions can also give off a “vacation mode” vibe rather than a confident, relaxed one. If you want something flavorful, try a classic cocktail with natural fruit notes instead. Avoiding these sugary drinks keeps you comfortable and composed throughout the night.
4. Super Complicated Custom Orders
Nothing kills a vibe faster than a ten-step drink order. Asking for half this, double that, or specific brands can make you seem high-maintenance or indecisive. A first date isn’t the time to show off mixology preferences—it’s about simplicity and flow. Bartenders appreciate easy orders, and your date will, too. Keeping it simple with a glass of wine or a basic cocktail sends a message of ease and confidence.
5. Overly Strong Whiskey or Scotch Neat
There’s nothing wrong with loving whiskey, but ordering it neat on a first date can sometimes send mixed signals. Strong spirits are associated with seasoned drinkers and can feel intimidating to someone who doesn’t share the same taste. It might also make conversation tricky if you’re sipping something that burns rather than refreshes. Save your bold liquor moments for later dates when your dynamic is more relaxed. Early on, opt for a cocktail that feels balanced and approachable.
6. The Ever-Messy Espresso Martini
While espresso martinis are trendy and delicious, they can be a logistical nightmare on a first date. Between the foam, coffee flavor, and caffeine kick, they often lead to jittery energy rather than calm conversation. Plus, they don’t always mix well with food, leaving you overstimulated before the evening’s even halfway through. While they’re great for nights out with friends, they’re less ideal for first impressions. Keep things smoother with a low-caffeine option that lets you unwind naturally.
7. Extremely Expensive or Rare Drinks
Ordering the priciest cocktail on the menu can unintentionally send a message of entitlement or lack of awareness. It puts pressure on your date, especially if they’re covering the bill. A first date should be about shared comfort, not financial posturing. You can appreciate quality without going overboard—save the rare champagne or top-shelf bourbon for a celebration. When in doubt, modesty goes further than extravagance in making a genuine impression.
8. Anything in a Giant Glass or Fishbowl
Oversized cocktails might be fun for parties, but on a date, they can look over-the-top and impractical. They’re hard to drink gracefully, impossible to pace, and can come off as novelty rather than sophistication. Giant drinks also tend to make conversation awkward as you focus more on logistics than connection. If you want something that lasts, choose a standard-sized cocktail or a wine glass instead. Staying elegant and intentional beats gimmicky every time.
9. Energy Drink Cocktails
Mixing alcohol with energy drinks might sound like a way to stay alert, but it’s a risky move. These combos can impact your heart rate, blur your judgment, and make you seem jittery instead of confident. They’re also often associated with college parties rather than mature dates. If you need energy, go for something hydrating like sparkling water alongside your cocktail. It keeps your focus sharp and your energy natural.
10. Anything You Don’t Actually Like
Perhaps the most underrated mistake is ordering something you think you should like rather than what you actually enjoy. Trying to impress your date with a fancy cocktail or obscure drink often backfires if it doesn’t suit your taste. You end up faking enjoyment instead of relaxing into the moment. The best drink is one that helps you feel comfortable and authentic. Confidence in your choices says far more than any trendy order ever could.
The Real First-Date Power Move
At the end of the day, first dates are about chemistry, not cocktails. Choosing something light, manageable, and true to your taste helps you stay confident and connected. Avoiding the drinks women should never order on a first date isn’t about judgment—it’s about setting yourself up for an evening that feels genuine and effortless. Whether you go for wine, a gin and tonic, or just sparkling water, the real win is showing up as your best, most comfortable self.
Have you ever had a first-date drink choice go wrong? What’s your go-to order for making a good impression? Share your experiences in the comments below!
What to Read Next…
- 12 DINK Date Nights That Cost Less Than $30 But Feel Like $300
- 10 Date Night Gift Ideas That Will Impress Your Partner
- Don’t Wear These 14 Items of Clothing On The First Date Unless You Don’t Want A Second
- 10 Cheap Ways To Have An Amazing Date Night
- 13 Mistakes No One Can Afford To Make On A First Date
