Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Daily Mirror
Daily Mirror
National
Martin Bagot

Woman, 94, bled to death waiting for NHS to treat golf-ball sized varicose vein

A great-grandmother bled to death because NHS rationing meant she could not have an emergency ­operation on a varicose vein.

Cynthia Butcher, 94, had a golf ball-size lump on her left leg and was referred by her GP to A&E last April with an urgent note that said it “may bleed catastrophically imminently”.

When she arrived in A&E at Basildon Hospital, Essex, medics said they could not do a routine op to remove it because she was “over 70”. She was sent home to be visited by a community nurse.

On the evening of May 27, while waiting to get a date for the procedure, the lump burst.

Cynthia pressed a panic button but a warden was not on duty at her ­sheltered flats, so paramedics were locked out until one arrived.

Cynthia Butcher died after being denied an NHS operation (Phil Harris/Daily Mirror)
Lynda says her mum lost at least four pints of blood when the lump burst (Phil Harris/Daily Mirror)

Agony of mum whose three-year-old daughter is allergic to hot and cold  

Her daughter Lynda Clements said: “My mother died alone in her flat waiting for help, desperately trying to stem the blood. She lost at least four pints.

“Paramedics resuscitated her, but she had suffered massive brain damage.

“She died in hospital where, this time, they did everything to keep her alive. This must have cost thousands yet all she originally needed was a minor operation. It would have taken 10 minutes to lance the lump under local anaesthetic.”

Lynda added: “My mother was the matriarch of a large dynasty. There is just a numbness. Our family has been blown apart. We will never be the same again.

“My mother didn’t need any assistance and was a young 94-year-old. Her heart was still strong. We have been robbed of precious months or years with her.”

The week before Cynthia died a specialist had agreed with her GP that the operation had to be done. However she was still not given a date.

Cynthia with her grandchildren and great-grandchildren (Phil Harris/Daily Mirror)
Cynthia was 'the matriarch of a large dynasty' (Phil Harris/Daily Mirror)

Mum 'had to argue to get to GP' before daughter died from rare lung cancer  

Basildon Hospital told the Mirror that by the time of her death Cynthia had been placed on a waiting list. The family say it was only after her death that Cynthia got a letter confirming she could have the operation, set for June 13.

Ops ­previously routine are now being rationed by the NHS across much of the country because of a funding squeeze.

Recent analysis revealed around half of Clinical Commissioning Groups are rationing procedures such as cataract surgery, and hip and knee replacements.

Cynthia Butcher was on a waiting list at the time of her death (Phil Harris/Daily Mirror)
Daughter Lynda says the letter confirming her mum's operation only arrived after she died (Phil Harris/Daily Mirror)

Plea for eye donors as Brits reveal they are 'too personal' for transplant  

Many patients are refused treatments due to factors such as age or weight.

Widow Cynthia had four children, 11 grandchildren and one great-grandchild. Most lived near her in Aveley, Essex.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.