Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
Sam Kiley

Why Trump’s boast of ‘total ceasefire’ in Israel and Iran is premature

Israel was attacked with several waves of Iranian missiles hours after a messy ceasefire deal was announced by Donald Trump, prompting its foreign minister to accuse Tehran of violating the deal. Not quite the triumphant ceasefire the US president had touted overnight.

The Iranian salvos killed three Israelis in the southern desert city of Beer Sheva and while Israel has successfully eroded much of Iran’s nuclear capabilities - helped by the US and its bunker buster bombs attacking its most sensitive site in Fordow - Iran’s government remains intact.

Iranian state TV said it would observe the ceasefire, which could take a day to set in as both Israel and Iran wound down their operations.

It all seemed so promising on Tuesday morning when Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu confirmed that Israel had agreed to the cessation of hostilities. Yet within hours, his defence minister Israel Katz had vowed a forceful response on the heart of Tehran.

Iran’s foreign minister had said his country would stop firing missiles at 4am local time if Israel also stopped its attacks, but that statement was followed by Tehran launching up to five waves of attacks in the subsequent four hours.

"On the assumption that everything works as it should, which it will, I would like to congratulate both Countries, Israel and Iran, on having the Stamina, Courage, and Intelligence to end, what should be called, 'THE 12 DAY WAR'," Trump wrote on his Truth Social site.

"The final decision on the cessation of our military operations will be made later," Iranian foreign minister Abbas Araqchi said in a post on X.

Top White House officials were apparently caught off guard by Trump’s sudden ceasefire announcement following Iranian retaliatory attacks against the vast US air base in el-Udeid, Qatar.

The attacks on US targets were telegraphed in diplomatic communications to the US and Qatar ahead of time and were entirely symbolic. All but one of the incoming missiles from Iran were shot down and no significant damage was done.

The Israeli military issued two evacuation warnings in less than two hours to residents of areas in Tehran, one late on Monday and one early on Tuesday in a sign that Israel intended to continue its offensive against Iran at least until the official ceasefire was supposed to begin.

Given how badly shaken Israelis have been by the 12 days of Iranian missile and drone attacks it is not surprising that Netanyahu announced a pause Israel’s campaign, no matter how brief. Israel has been paralysed throughout the last 12 days and military officials estimate that Iran could keep up the current levels of attack with up to 20 missiles a day, almost indefinitely.

In return, the Israelis have attacked Iran’s nuclear capacity, missiles programme, military leadership and had recently targeted the institutions of internal oppression, most notably the Basij militia.

Netanyahu has repeatedly said that the campaign was, in part, intended to cause regime change by calling on Iranians to rise against the theocracy that rules them. Early in Israel’s unilateral attacks, he said: “There's one thing Khamenei’s regime fears more than Israel. You know what it is? It’s you – the people of Iran.

“That’s why they spend so much time and money trying to crush your hopes and curb your dreams. Well, I say to you this: don’t let your dreams die. I hear the whispers: Women, Life, Freedom.”

Any lasting truce now would stop well short of his longer term strategic intent to enact regime change in Iran.

Iran is clearly intent on preserving the Islamic Republic, but will next face demands for highly intrusive inspections by the IAEA nuclear watchdog as part of any longer deal. Conversely, the Israeli attacks have also demonstrated that the best guarantee of Iranian security might be to develop a nuclear weapon.

It is still not clear where Trump stands on the issue of regime change. At the start of the Israeli campaign he boasted that the US knew where Iran’s supreme leader Aliu Khamenei was sheltering and said the US had not decided, yet, to eliminate him.

Now the US president has praise for all concerned on his social media.

“This is a War that could have gone on for years, and destroyed the entire Middle East, but it didn’t, and never will! God bless Israel, God bless Iran, God bless the Middle East, God bless the United States of America, and GOD BLESS THE WORLD!”

His excitement may be premature. Iran will now be sure that it will need a nuclear weapon to defend against future Israeli attacks while the shaky ceasefire looks set to be depressingly short-lived.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.