Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
World
Sam Kiley

Why talk of the fall of Pokrovsk – and Ukraine – is premature

Not a word of what the Russian defence ministry says is credible. Its claims that Russian troops have surrounded Ukrainian forces in Pokrovsk, Kostyantynivka and Kupiansk, in eastern Ukraine, are agitprop.

But Volodymyr Zelensky’s statement from the front line that his country’s fighters are “under pressure” is something of an understatement.

Dozens, perhaps hundreds, of Russian troops may have successfully infiltrated the three tactically important towns.

Kupiansk is on Russia’s route towards Kharkiv. The other two control the eastern and southern routes to the last remaining Ukrainian redoubts in Donetsk – Kramatorsk and Slaviansk.

Vladimir Putin has thrown a massive effort into the fight for Donetsk, which Moscow has already illegally “annexed”. Ukraine’s commanders believe there are about 100,000 Russian troops in this sector alone.

They have paid a gigantic price in blood for tiny territorial gains. If Pokrovsk falls, eventually, there will be nothing left of this former garrison town.

Just as there is nothing left of nearby Bakhmut or Avdiivka, which fell almost two years ago in what was the last significant Russian gain in this grinding war.

An artilleryman fires a howitzer towards Russian troops near the frontline town of Pokrovsk in Ukraine’s Donetsk region in October (Reuters)

These Russian-speaking towns, like Mariupol before them, are the scenes of atrocities against Russian-speaking civilians committed by a Russian army deployed, the Russian leader says, to protect Russian-speaking people from Ukrainian abuses.

Moscow says Ukrainian troops are now trapped in three “cauldrons”. It is offering the troops “encircled” there the opportunity to surrender. They are not encircled. They do not need to, and will not, surrender.

Russia has stretched Ukraine’s ability to defend a front line that’s about 1,300km long. It has launched feint attacks from Zaporizhzhia in the south to Sumy in the far north. But its main effort has been Putin’s passion to take all of Donetsk before any kind of a future ceasefire “freezes” the front lines.

In the new field of drone warfare, Russia has moved as quickly to adapt as Ukraine’s techno-savvy volunteers. Kyiv’s forces up and down that front line speak with fearful admiration of the Rubicon unit of Moscow’s forces, who are highly trained specialist drone operators.

“We can tell when they’re in our area because their skills go up. They train people well and when they leave, they leave those skills behind,” said Grey, a lieutenant in a Ukrainian frontline drone unit close to Zaporizhzhia.

Ukrainians store bombs in garages ahead of use on bomber drones controlled from underground bunkers (Sam Kiley/The Independent)

The Rubicon Centre for Advanced Unmanned Technologies – Russia’s response to Ukraine’s establishment of a separate drone force alongside the army, navy and air forces – has been combined with Russian special forces to focus on Kyiv’s frontline drone operators.

Scattered along the front, the Ukrainians have been able to hold Russian assaults back with relatively low numbers of troops in danger. Operating from hidden bunkers, their First Person View (FPV) attack drones, bombers, and interceptors, have enabled Ukraine to rebalance the battlefield where Russian weight of numbers had dominated.

But by using Spetsnaz special forces units and drone swarms, Russian commanders have focused their efforts on overwhelming Ukrainian pilots in their hideouts.

These tactics appear to be paying off. But they also exact a massive cost on Russia’s regular army, which is ordered into towns like Pokrovsk and are vulnerable to Ukrainian drones flying from deeper into the country.

Ukraine is reported to have sent its own special forces into the fight for Pokrovsk. If the pattern of previous battles for eastern towns and cities is repeated, it could be a year at least and many tens of thousands of Russian dead, before they fall. If they fall.

The landscape behind the Ukrainian front lines has been prepared for a fighting retreat by Kyiv forces. Thousands of miles of trenches, barriers, tank traps and barbed wire mazes have been laid. No doubt, secret mine fields, stay-behind-bunkers for behind-the-lines operations and meticulously calibrated targeting will make Russia’s next phase another session in the “meat grinder” of Ukraine’s eastern front.

Volodymyr Zelensky meets servicemen during his visit to the frontline in the Donetsk region, eastern Ukraine, 04 November 2025 (Ukrainian Presidential Press Service)

Russia’s calculation is that it can outlast Ukraine. The Kremlin can feed an unlimited number of troops into the cauldron.

Ukraine’s calculation is that since Moscow already has to motivate soldiers with $3,000 a month salaries, the pool of willing troops is drying up while Ukraine targets the Russian industrial machine by bombing its oil infrastructure.

Moscow is hanging on and Kyiv is buying time. The latter is hoping for a strategic boost from the US or Europe to supply it with the long-range weapons that can reach deep into Russian territory and smash the Kremlin’s morale and supply lines to Ukraine.

As a senior Nato intelligence officer pointed out recently: “This is the mid-point of a long war.”

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.