Everton's win over Arsenal has led to an interesting debate over one man in particular.
Phil Jagielka proved to be the match winner as his 10th minute strike was enough to secure a 1-0 victory for Marco Silva's side on Sunday - although the hosts really could have won by more goals.
But what made his display so intriguing was the fact that he wasn't even meant to be starting the game.
Michael Keane was named in the Everton side when the teams were announced an hour before kick off, but was ruled out after the warm-up with a virus.
Andre Gomes' passion, heartwarming gestures and other moments missed from Everton's win over Arsenal
That led to the club captain stepping in for his first match at Goodison Park since the previous May and putting in a brilliant performance in the process.
But, with the 36-year-old's contract set to run out at the end of the season, should he be given an extension to his current deal?
The ECHO put the question to Everton fans on Monday - and the results were decisive.
83% of those who took part wanted to see the experienced defender given an extension on his Goodison Park career, with only 17% believing he should be let go.
And supporters also took to social media to explain exactly why Jagielka should be kept on at Everton.
What you said on Facebook
Daniel Roderick: "To lose Jags and Baines in the summer would be really negative for the dressing room. They are the core experienced players behind the scene. I would definitely be keeping one of them on for a bit part role, but key dressing room influence."
John Fleet: "As a squad player yeah. Him and Baines, if we get rid of them then that's two more players we need to buy this summer whereas if they stay and are happy with the bit part role then we can replace them next summer. It would be stupid for anyone to say get rid of either of them this summer."
Phil Jagielka's Everton future may hinge on Kurt Zouma and why Calvert-Lewin reminds me of Sharp
Marty Slimming: "Yes I’d give him another year contract! He deserves it."
Peter Vernon: " Deserves to remain. Can still do a quality job."
Joe Blackler: "Not really, at the most a year extension because of his leadership & to supplement the back line. But for the most part, he’s on the verge of hanging his boots up & should move into coaching really. Could be a real asset as a defensive coach. Good to see him get the goal & clean sheet though. A great performance for a man who’s days are numbered."
Mike Donnan: " I said it last season and I've said it a few times this, he is superb to have around and he is still good for 5/10 games a season."
What you said on Twitter
If we qualify for Europe most defiantly him and Baines should be given another year, the quality still is priceless and would help us with the extra games. But if Sheff U come up could see him going back to finish off his career.
— Phill Hayward (@Haywaphi17) April 9, 2019
He should join the staff. He’s an excellent face for the club, but would he be happy with the odd game out of 30? If he wants to continue regular game time he will need to face dropping to a lesser side
— Dave (@SeahawkBlue81) April 8, 2019
Whilst he's still capable of performances like yesterday's, yes. No brainer, top professional.
— David Ireland (@thenewmatador) April 8, 2019
12 month contract just to fill in as he did in the weekend
— MattyEFC (@Mattifoster) April 8, 2019
Yes he’s amazing and a credit to the club
— jules (@julesefc) April 8, 2019
He is certainly a ‘super-sub’ even at 36. Depends upon whether he would prefer to play more football elsewhere for if we do lose Zouma then we could well need his services.
— Roger Williams (@RogerWi33581994) April 8, 2019
