Why Italian restaurant Casanova is the most 'underrated gem' in Cardiff - and you won't find pizza on the menu

By Ed Gilbert

I’ve been a long-time fan of Cardiff city centre’s Casanova but it’s a place which flies under the radar compared to glitzier and trendier restaurants which sit nearby.

In fact, when it was described on social media by someone as “the underrated gem of Cardiff food”, there were chimes of agreement.

Opened in 2005 by three Italian friends, Casanova is a far cry from your typical pizza pasta joint. They import much of their own produce directly from Italy, their compact menu changes with the seasons, there’s no pizza and usually only a couple of pasta dishes on offer.

Casanova's dining room is spread over two floors (Ed Gilbert)

Read more: First review of small plates and wine bar that has opened in a former Cardiff brothel

They also have an excellent new chef who worked at the Hardwick in Abergavenny before spending the last eight years cooking around Tuscany. He certainly knows his onions when it comes to Italian cooking.

On the Saturday night we visited, it was a full house in the restaurant’s cosy two-floor dining room. Whilst we waited for the backlog of orders to clear through their tiny five-hob kitchen, we munched our way through a bowl of fiery black pepper rich taralli biscuits.

Fiery black pepper rich taralli biscuits (Ed Gilbert)

To start, a special of wild mushroom risotto (£9) was an absolute cracker. Neither too loose nor claggy, it delivered a huge hit of savoury and funky wild mushroom and a rich decadence of cheese.

A huge hit of savoury and funky wild mushroom (Ed Gilbert)

Caponata (£8), a sweet and zingy Sicilian stew made with soft long-cooked aubergines, was topped with a good wodge of creamy and tangy grilled goat cheese. A drizzle of truffle honey and a scattering of crunchy pine nuts made it a deliciously indulgent combination.

A deliciously indulgent caponata (Ed Gilbert)

Onto mains, and an excellent crisp skinned fillet of grey mullet (£22) tasted of the sea; it’s unsurprising as the chef selects the freshest fish from Cardiff market on a daily basis. It was accompanied by a mix of asparagus, new potatoes and broad beans bathed in a butter sauce fragranced with roast garlic and the punch of caper.

Crisp-skinned grey mullet tasted of the sea (Ed Gilbert)

Welsh lamb rump (£25) was treated with the respect it deserves. Pink fleshed, supremely tender, big in flavour and capped with well-rendered fat, it was served with soft caramelised courgette, a silky and delicate celeriac puree, well-crisped new potatoes and a glossy lamb sauce. But, it was a couple of blobs of intensely savoury anchovy puree which gave the dish an extra dimension - it's a classic pairing with lamb for a reason.

Welsh lamb rump was treated with the respect it deserves (Ed Gilbert)

Desserts maintained the meal’s very high standard. A properly creamy panna cotta (£8) with a textbook wobble was fragranced with the merest hint of liquorice. Accompanied by a rich chocolate crumb, a toasty sesame caramel crisp and an intense liquorice puree, it was a flavour-packed creative dessert.

A panna cotta had a textbook wobble (Ed Gilbert)

A cannolo (£6) was more traditional in its construction but every bit as delicious. A crisp pastry shell was loaded with smooth chocolate chip studded sweetened ricotta and capped at either end with whole pistachios and warming stemmed ginger.

A cannolo was loaded with chocolate chip studded ricotta (Ed Gilbert)

We had an absolutely belting meal at Casanova and their high end Italian cooking is certainly some of the best in the city. Handily, they're also open on Mondays when not too many other places in the city are. If you haven’t visited this underrated gem yet then you’re missing out...

The details

Casanova, 13 Quay Street, Cardiff CF10 1EA

Sign up to the WhatsOn newsletter for all our best stories every day here

What is inkl?

Important stories

See news based on value, not advertising potential. Get the latest news from around the world.

Trusted newsrooms

We bring you reliable news from the world’s most experienced journalists in the most trusted newsrooms.

Ad-free reading

Read without interruptions, distractions or intrusions of privacy.