Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
ABC News
ABC News
Sport
Andrew McGarry

Why Geelong and Collingwood are the form teams of the AFL going into round 20

Ladder-leaders Geelong have not lost a game from round 10 until now, but the Magpies have matched them with nine wins in a row. (AAP: Joel Carrett)

As we brace for the last month before finals, things have certainly changed in the AFL, not least with the two teams who have all the momentum as we approach September: Geelong and Collingwood.

The Cats and the Magpies have both got nine-game winning streaks on the go, and they have the clear momentum with four rounds left in the home and away season.

Just to emphasise the point, if you look at the AFL form ladder for those nine weeks, Geelong and Collingwood are head and shoulders above any other team in the league.

The next most successful teams in that period are the Sydney Swans and Western Bulldogs with 6-3 records.

So, what have they doing right in the last nine games, what are they doing differently — from each other — and can they keep it going?

Clearly the Cats and the Magpies are not clones of each other: Geelong under Chris Scott looks different to Collingwood under Craig McRae.

Even though both teams have identical records in the past nine games, it is probably true to say that Geelong are the dominant team in the AFL right now — and a look at the Cats's stats tells us why.

It's true that they have had some tight matches, including the thrilling win over Port Adelaide at Adelaide Oval last Saturday, where they had to kick two late goals in time-on to seal victory.

However, taken as a whole, Geelong is 9-0 with a percentage of 151.9. They have been scoring an average of 95.3 points per game, and conceding an average of 62.8.

In comparison, Collingwood is 9-0 with a percentage of 116.3. The Pies have scored an average of 80.8 points per game, and conceded an average of 69.4.

Geelong is the second-highest-scoring team for the season behind Brisbane, and the leading scoring team in the past nine games.

Defensively, they are the third-best defence (on points conceded) for the season behind Melbourne and leaders Fremantle — but in their last nine games they are the best, ahead of Collingwood, Carlton and Port Adelaide.

Tom Hawkins and Jeremy Cameron have kicked nearly 40 per cent of Geelong's goals from round 10 onwards, with 49 majors combined. (Getty Images: AFL Photos/Dylan Burns)

The most obvious element to Geelong in attack is the one-two punch of Jeremy Cameron and Tom Hawkins.

* Turnover differential figure is a team's average number of turnovers committed minus the figure for the opposition

In the nine-game window, the Geelong pair have combined for 49 goals — 27 for Cameron and 22 for Hawkins.

But it's not just about the goals. It's the way Geelong are doing it. 

It starts with the clearances. The Cats have an advantage in clearance differential, winning an average of 3.6 more clearances than their opponents in the middle each week.

This translates to a lot of go-forward. The Cats are the second-highest in the league for inside-50s this season, at 57.1 entries per game, behind Richmond.

During their winning streak, Geelong has an identical return, but the key is their differential — they have racked up an average of 12.7 more entries than their opponents — putting more pressure on defences. 

The leader in this area is veteran former Hawk Isaac Smith. Smith averages 4.8 inside-50s a game.

Tyson Stengle is an important contributor up forward for Geelong, taking 12 inside-50 marks from round 10 onwards. (AAP: Rob Prezioso)

One benefit of the flood of inside-50s is that the Cats get a lot of marks inside the arc.

As might be expected, the lion's share of those go to Hawkins (29) and Cameron (25). But they aren't the only ones.

There have been 22 individual mark-takers inside-50 for Geelong from round 10 onwards. Aside from the main forward duo, players such as Tyson Stengle (12), Max Holmes (7), Cameron Guthrie (5), Joel Selwood, Brad Close, Gary Rohan, Mark Blicavs and Mitch Duncan (4 each) have all contributed.   

Pies on the rise

For the Magpies, the key indicators are a little different.

Although McRae has emphasised a playing style built around being entertaining and going forward, Collingwood is only the eighth-highest scoring side for the season, and also the eighth-highest scoring side in the past nine games.

Collingwood was leading the league in metres gained mid-season, but the team has now slipped to fifth.

Defensively, the Pies are ninth for the season, but second for the past nine games.

Why the change? Collingwood was already the number one intercept team in the league, with the quartet of Darcy Moore, Isaac Quaynor, Brayden Maynard and Jeremy Howe.

Darcy Moore is the leader of Collingwood's league-leading group of interceptors, averaging seven a game this season. (Getty Images: Daniel Pockett)

However, recently the Pies have got even better. Their season average is 75.3 intercepts a game but, in recent weeks, the team has averaged 79.1 a game, with a peak of 92 intercepts against Hawthorn in round 12. 

One of the big elements in their run of successes has been turnover differential, with the Magpies making 6.3 fewer turnovers per game than their opponents.

More importantly, the teams Collingwood have faced in the past nine rounds have made an average of 9.8 more turnovers than their season average when they play the Magpies, so McRae's men are subjecting opponents to unfamiliar pressure and forcing errors.

Another side of that equation is inside-50 tackles.

Collingwood is number six in the AFL this season for inside-50 tackles, averaging 11 a game — the leaders in that category, the Crows, average 11.2 per game.

In the past nine games, however, the Magpies as a team have averaged a whopping 12.7 tackles inside forward 50.

Leading the way is the man who brought the house down at the MCG against Essendon on Sunday evening, Jamie Elliott.

When he's not kicking match-winning goals from the boundary, Jamie Elliott is the AFL's top inside-50 tackler. (Getty Images: AFL Photos/James Elsby)

Elliott is the number one player in the AFL for inside-50 tackles. Unsurprisingly, he has led his team in the past nine games — of which he has played eight — with 16.

However, it's not just a one-man show, with people like Beau McCreery (13), Patrick Lipinski (11) and Brodie Mihocek also doing their bit to lock the ball inside 50.

Can they keep it up?

In their current form, if Geelong can get past the Bulldogs at Kardinia Park on Saturday night, they should be hot favourites to finish the home-and-away season with their win-streak extended to 13. 

On the other hand, with every passing game the Magpies seem to meet another challenge from opposition teams that takes them to the edge.

Of Collingwood's nine consecutive wins, seven have been by two goals or less, including their past five in a row. 

The issue will be holding their spot in the top four, with games against Port Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney and Carlton remaining.

On the plus side, they will soon get Jordan De Goey back from a quad injury, and will also have the question of what to do with Brodie Grundy with the star ruckman up for a possible return in the next few weeks.

One thing seems clear: The Cats and the Pies are going to have a big say in the finals series. 

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.