Rory Burns
Three Tests, 145 runs @ 24.16, three catches
Looked calm, busy and mildly reassuring without scoring many runs. In St Lucia took two excellent gully catches, which is a handy attribute, then dropped a sitter at mid-off. Still learning. Rating: 4/10
Keaton Jennings
Two Tests, 62 runs @ 15.50, two catches
Conscientious, enthusiastic but runless. He may resurface another day after scoring a stash of runs for Lancashire but that is unlikely to happen in 2019. He’s had too many chances for a quick return. 2
Joe Denly
Two Tests, 112 runs @ 28.00
He is now an England Test player and he could play again after an impressive 69 in St Lucia punctuated by elegant cover drives. Is he a poor or rich man’s James Vince? 5
Joe Root
Three Tests, 177 runs @ 29.50, six catches
Finished the tour rather better than he started. He may have tormented himself over the selection of that first Test team for which he has to take ultimate responsibility. But he can still bat. 4
Jos Buttler
Three Tests, 178 runs @ 29.66, five catches
Is diligently learning on the job, which is now to bat at No 5. He tried to do this in a restrained, responsible manner without managing to produce the major innings. 5
Ben Stokes
Three Tests, 186 runs @ 37.20, 10 wickets @ 22.80, six catches
Was back to being the hub of the side, bowling more than expected in the first two Tests and scoring runs in the final one when we glimpsed the dominant batsman of two years ago. 7
Jonny Bairstow
Three Tests, 110 runs @ 22.00, three catches, two stumpings
Few have taken a demotion so cheerfully. He is back at seven after a short-lived experiment at three, where he actually did OK despite being bowled through the gate too often. 4
Moeen Ali
Three Tests, 77 runs @ 15.40, 14 wickets @ 23.85, 1 catch
England’s leading wicket-taker who bowled better and better as the series progressed and after 58 Tests he suddenly found himself in the slip cordon where he took one stunning catch. 7
Stuart Broad
Two Tests, 0 runs, 4 wickets @ 30.75
Short of run-up and short of luck. He beat the bat frequently, suffered more than the others from dropped chances … and never threatened to score a run. And took the catch of the series. 5
Jimmy Anderson
Three Tests, five runs @ 1.66, 10 wickets @ 24.50, four catches
His wickets came in streaks, which means there were barren spells as well though never inaccurate ones. Only in the final Test were the West Indian openers dispatched early. 7
Ben Foakes
Two Tests, 55 runs @ 13.75, two catches
A victim of England’s agonies at the top of the order. Dropped because they decided to shift Bairstow. Had he scored more runs this would not have been possible. 4
Twitter: follow us at @guardian_sport
Facebook: like our football and sport pages
Instagram: our favourite photos, films and stories
Sam Curran
Two Tests, 50 runs @ 16.66, one wicket @ 161.00
His lucky charm status was rapidly lost. He was elevated by being given the new ball in the expectation of sharp swing, which never materialised, and condemned to batting in hopeless situations. 3
Mark Wood
One Test, six runs @ 6.00, six wickets @ 15.50
Bowled 50 balls last Sunday, which excited everyone. The longer run-up seems to improve his rhythm. He has never bowled as quickly for England. 8
Adil Rashid
One Test, 13 runs @ 6.50, no wickets
Ineffective in Bridgetown and then dropped. Now his England career is likely to be restricted to white-ball cricket, hopefully without his confidence being dented. 2
Did not play: Jack Leach, Chris Woakes
