Enter your email to read this article
Read news on any topic, in one place, from publishers like The Economist, FT, Bloomberg and more.

Welfare chief Law Chi-kwong under fire over lack of timetable for boosting childcare services in Hong Kong

Critics have long complained about a severe shortage of childcare places in Hong Kong. Photo: Edmond So

Legislators slammed the Hong Kong government on Monday for not drawing up a timetable for delivering an adviser’s recommendation to boost childcare places amid an acute shortage.

A University of Hong Kong team led by Professor Paul Yip Siu-fai had advised the Labour and Welfare Bureau to formulate a planning ratio of 103 childcare places per 20,000 general population for children aged below three.

The figure would be reviewed continuously as household composition changed in the city.

The ratio was derived from a study the bureau commissioned in 2016 on the long-term development of childcare services.

Law Chi-kwong (centre) said his bureau would fight for land to open childcare centres. Photo: David Wong

The HKU report recommended 82 of the 103 places be for children aged under two, and the remainder for those aged two to three, given that the private sector showed relatively less interest in providing such services for the younger group.

That would mean 30,247 places for those under two, and 7,557 for the older group, across Hong Kong.

Welfare chief pledges to add 300 childcare places to tackle inadequate services

Based on 2016 by-census data, there were 111,240 children aged under two in Hong Kong, but only 1,831 places available for them.

While not all required childcare services, critics have long complained about the severe shortage of places.

A team lead by Professor Paul Yip came up with the recommendations. Photo: David Wong

Although the bureau accepted the recommendation last week, welfare minister Law Chi-kwong did not say when the government could deliver the near 38,000 recommended places.

At a Legislative Council welfare services panel meeting on Monday, the Labour Party’s Fernando Cheung Chiu-hung asked Law how the government would be able to meet the target given the large disparity with the current supply.

“The number of places in subsidised stand-alone childcare centres for those aged under two has dropped [over 20 years] to around 700,” Cheung said. “Besides just putting the figures out, do you have a specific plan on how you will implement the planning standard?”

Law said the ratio would be incorporated into the Hong Kong Planning Standards and Guidelines in 2019-20.

Fernando Cheung criticised Law for setting a target without a timeline. Photo: Dickson Lee

“In the future, any planning works, such as the building of public housing estates, can follow these standards but these will take more than 10 years,” he said.

Law said the bureau would fight for land to open childcare centres and engage NGOs to redevelop or extend some of their sites through a funding scheme.

Hong Kong ‘should learn from Singapore’ on childcare, minister says

These would take three to four years at the earliest, he said.

“We will try to fight for this, but it is not within our control,” Law said.

Cheung criticised Law for setting a target without a timeline.

The report also suggested improving the ratio of childcare workers to children for those under age two from 1:8 to at least 1:6, and for those aged two to three from 1:14 to 1:11.

Leung Che-cheung said the government should not set such a low target. Photo: SCMP

Pro-establishment lawmaker Leung Che-cheung said the government should not set such a low target of just meeting 1:6 for the younger group, which was the standard back in 1976.

He also pointed to how South Korea and Finland had better ratios of 1:3 and 1:4 respectively.

But Law said it was not easy to hire people and that 1:6 was more feasible.

“Actually, I am not very confident that centres can really hire enough qualified childcare workers even after we provide them with the resources,” he admitted.

Top stories on inkl right now
Related Stories
Many challenges to increasing foreign workers under new law / Help needed for social adaptation
The system reforms in newly passed legislation are aimed at opening the door wider to foreign workers. There are many issues remaining to be resolved. The government must take necessary measures and strive to smoothly introduce the new system while alleviating the anxiety felt by the public.
From analysis to the latest developments in health, read the most diverse news in one place.
TAT pivots to niche markets across Asia
The Tourism Authority of Thailand (TAT) has a new scheme to micro-target niche tourist markets like Indonesian women and Japanese students.
No change to law protecting children despite coroner's urging to close 'loophole'
Politicians have snubbed closing a legal loophole said to put children at risk despite the urging of the coroner who investigated the suicide of a teenage girl and the intense relationship she had with a former teacher.Coroner Carla...
Exclusive: Dutch hospitals to drop U.S. body brokers, cite ethical concerns
AMSTERDAM - Two major Dutch hospitals say they will stop importing human body parts from American firms, which they have been doing without any regulation for a decade.
Soon, parents’ corner in all UP govt primary schools
MULTI-PURPOSE: The counter will be used to disseminate information on welfare schemes and create awareness on social causes
One place to find news on any topic, from hundreds of sites.
After Discovery Bay: Hong Kong's Cha Family Is Ramping Up Other Business Interests
The Cha family is recognized for developing a signature variation on Hong Kong living. Now it's ramping up other business interests.