Summary
Here is a summary of the key points from the Putin press conference:
-
Putin admitted for the first time the presence of Russian military specialists in east Ukraine. Asked by a Ukrainian reporter an hour into the briefing about two Russian military intelligence officers captured by Kiev and currently on trial in Ukraine, Putin said: “We never said there were not people there who carried out certain tasks including in the military sphere.” He insisted this was not the same as regular Russian troops.
- Putin said the Russian military operation in Syria will continue until a political process starts and that he was unsure whether Russia needs a permanent military base in the country. He added that Moscow supports a US draft of a UN Security Council resolution on Syria. A new constitution for Syria must be drafted, and a new election prepared in which the Syrians themselves will determine its leadership, he said.
- Putin said he doesn’t see any prospect for reviving relations with Turkey, and that Ataturk would be rolling in his grave over Islamization in modern Turkey. He was angry that Ankara called Brussels, not Moscow, when it downed a Russian jet.
- Putin said the killing of opposition leader Nemtsov must be investigated and punished.
- Putin said said FIFA’s Sepp Blatter deserves a Nobel peace prize.
- Putin said it was not possible to say Russian officers in captivity would be exchanged for Ukrainian helicopter pilot Nadezhda Savchenko because of the criminal case against them.
- Putin did not confirm or deny whether Ekaterina Tikhonva is his daughter, stating that he did not discuss his daughters “due to security matters”.
- He said it was not yet clear whether the children of Prosecutor-General Yuri Chaika had actually committed any crimes, an allegation recently made by the opposition.
- And he said Russia has passed the peak of the economic crisis.
Putin upshot: Turkey is licking America's butt; people like Blatter should get Nobel; 'people' in Donbass carried out certain military tasks
— Paul Sonne (@PaulSonne) December 17, 2015
That’s it from me. Thanks for reading.
Updated
Before he left - Putin said Russia doesn’t see a new anti-terror coalition led by Saudi Arabia as hostile to its interests, but he called for pooling global efforts to fight against terrorism. He said that he doesn’t quite understand the purpose of creating the new coalition, because many of its members are part of the U.S.-led coalition. At the same time, he added that Russia has cooperated with Saudi Arabia despite their differences on the Syrian crisis.
That’s it, the marathon is over: 3 hours 10 mins.
Updated
Putin says Russia needs to work together with Kiev to resolve Ukraine conflict as soon as possible:
Putin says the killing of opposition leader Nemtsov must be investigated and punished.
Putin says hasn't discussed Nemtsov murder investigation with Chechnya's Kadyrov & won't discuss.1st need to prove culprits are hiding there
— Alec Luhn (@ASLuhn) December 17, 2015
Putin vows there won't be a cover-up in Nemtsov murder investigation.
— Paul Sonne (@PaulSonne) December 17, 2015
Updated
Putin says Russia will not impose sanctions on Ukraine:
Putin said Russia is working with Egypt to restore air links that Moscow cut following the crash of a Russian airliner on the Sinai Peninsula. Moscow has said the plane was downed by an explosive device.
He said Russia decided to suspend air travel with Egypt because its agencies aren’t immediately capable of guaranteeing safety of Russian citizens. He said that the move wasn’t political and he praised the Egyptian president for his “great personal courage” in fighting terror.
Putin added that the air links will be restored after Russian and Egyptian officials work out a set of measures to ensure safety, including the presence of Russian representatives at Egyptian airports.
I mean we’ve been going for three hours now.
We haven't had many laughs during this #Putin presser. Now he's poking fun at Kalingras journalist whose site is named after a German dish
— Alec Luhn (@ASLuhn) December 17, 2015
Kaliningrad Q about military guy who ran over a journalist and escaped punishment. Putin says it's awful. Expect him jailed by dinner time.
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Updated
Vladimir Putin has for the first time admitted the presence of Russian military specialists in east Ukraine.
Russia has repeatedly denied a military presence in the conflict, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary. But the Russian president conceded there were military intelligence officers operating in the country in a marathon press conference on Thursday.
Asked by a Ukrainian reporter an hour into the briefing about two Russian military intelligence officers captured by Kiev and currently on trial in Ukraine, Putin said: “We never said there were not people there who carried out certain tasks including in the military sphere.” He insisted this was not the same as regular Russian troops.
There was no opportunity for a follow-up question to examine how many military specialists Putin believes were in Ukraine and what exact tasks they were carrying out. At key moments in the conflict in east Ukraine there has been much evidence of regular Russian army involvement.
Putin also initially denied the “little green men” present during the annexation of Crimea were Russian soldiers but afterwards admitted they were.
In the first part of his press conference, Putin also dealt with questions about the Russian economy, corruption, Syria and the recent crisis in relations with Turkey.
He struck an uncompromising note on Turkey, saying if the shooting down of a Russian jet had been an accident, officials could have called Moscow, but instead they called Nato first.
“Someone in the Turkish leadership tried to lick the Americans in a particular place, I don’t know whether the Americans needed that,” said Putin.
Peaks and troughs. Anyone have any snacks?
Two hours and 40 minutes so far and we have a question from the "Red North" a newspaper in the Yamal republic about road building delays.
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Updated
Putin admits to Russian personnel in Ukraine from “military field”:
Who’s claiming to be Putin’s rose? ‘fess up.
NTV has a question on unreliable Ukrainians, behind him someone has the intriguing poster "Putin's rose" pic.twitter.com/lMUB3jYgMi
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Putin on Sepp Blatter and the Nobel prize:
Mikhail Rubin from RBC asks: Is Ekaterina Tikhonva your daughter? Putin doesn’t deny nor confirm - “due to security matters”. He adds: “Every person has the right to decide his own future. My daughters were never star children, they’re just living their lives, in a very dignified way.”
My daughters live in Russia and never left to go live anywhere/ They only studied in Russia
— Andrew Roth (@ARothWP) December 17, 2015
Putin says they speak three languages fluently. “They’re not active in business and they don’t do politics”.
Putin now saying his daughters are in Russia, just as he said, and speak other languages and use them at work.
— Paul Sonne (@PaulSonne) December 17, 2015
Putin not denying that his daughter runs organization at Moscow State University in response to question about her. Also not confirming.
— Paul Sonne (@PaulSonne) December 17, 2015
Putin said Russia is ready to work to improve ties with the United States, and to work with anyone who is elected its next president.
He said his talks with US Secretary of State John Kerry earlier this week have shown that Washington is ready to “move toward settling the issues that can only be settled through joint efforts.”
Here’s what Putin said about the doping scandal and FIFA:
Putin again suggesting US justice department's actions in FIFA scandal "unacceptable."
— Paul Sonne (@PaulSonne) December 17, 2015
Putin: Blatter is a "very respected person. He has done a lot for the growth of football."
— Paul Sonne (@PaulSonne) December 17, 2015
Putin: We received our right to hold the World Cup "in a completely honest competition."
— Paul Sonne (@PaulSonne) December 17, 2015
Putin on FIFA: Let's wait for the results of the investigation.
— Paul Sonne (@PaulSonne) December 17, 2015
Someone just told Putin he looks “fit”.
Putin just said FIFA’s Sepp Blatter should get a Nobel peace prize. Because why not...
Putin "Sepp Blatter is a very respected person. He has done a lot to develop world football. We should give him the Nobel peace prize" (!!!)
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Putin on Assad and a political solution in Syria:
... and on a Russian base in Syria:
Updated
Putin says Ukraine is ruled by foreign overlords who have appointed Mikheil Saakashvili.
Ah and there's the sarcastic reference to Saakashvili. Appointing him was "spitting in the face of the Ukrainian people"
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
"We're not only going to run you from outside but we're going to put foreigners in all the key positions." Putin, paraphrasing the State Dep
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Surprisingly missed the opportunity to call Saakashvili appointment "a glass of water in the face of the Ukrainian people"
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Putin just referred to “the territorial integrity of Ukraine... I mean, Georgia”. Oops.
Here’s a clip of Putin on Turkey:
Putin is now defending the Platon tax that has sparked truckers’ protests in Russia.
More details regarding Putin’s admission that Russia had personnel in Ukraine, from AFP:
Russian President Vladimir Putin said on Thursday that Russia did have personnel in eastern Ukraine who were carrying out certain military tasks but denied Moscow had deployed regular troops there.
“We never said there were no people there who were carrying out certain tasks including in the military sphere,” Putin told an annual news conference.
“But that does not mean there are Russian (regular) troops there, feel the difference.”
Putin said Russia was ready to persuade separatists in eastern Ukraine that a compromise was needed in order to achieve a political settlement of the conflict there.
He also said he expected trade relations with Ukraine to worsen, but that Moscow would not impose any sanctions on Kiev related to its trade deal with the European Union.
Putin has dodged questions about Turchak, Chaika, and Rotenberg. He’s made a joke about fur coats instead.
As for Chaika and Turchak, Putin talks about a joke where people mistakenly accuse people for stealing a fur coat, says need to investigate.
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
He said it was not yet clear whether the children of Prosecutor-General Yuri Chaika had actually committed any crimes, an allegation recently made by the opposition.
A fund run by opposition activist Alexei Navalny has said that Chaika and his family had been involved in crimes, including corruption schemes.
Updated
Some points from Putin on Ukraine:
- Putin for the first time admits Russians were in Ukraine in the ‘military sphere’
- Says Russia does not plan to introduce any sanctions against Ukraine
- Russia will not give Ukraine any trade preferences from Jan 2016
- Russia has no interest in worsening of Ukraine conflict
- Russia wants a solution to the conflict but not at the cost of people in eastern Ukraine
- Russia wants to fulfill the Minsk peace agreement
- Kiev is not completely fulfilling aspects of the Minsk deal relating to special status for eastern regions
- Russia is ready to persuade people in south-east Ukraine that a solution is needed
Updated
Here’s some copy from the Associated Press about Putin’s comments on Syria.
President Vladimir Putin says that Russian military operation in Syria will continue until a political process starts. Putin said at a televised news conference that once the Syrians decide it’s time to stop fighting and launch talks, “we aren’t going to be more Syrian than the Syrians themselves,” and Moscow will wrap up its military action.
He says that he was unsure whether Russia needs a permanent military base in Syria. He said new Russian weapons, such as sea- and air-launched cruise missiles, give Moscow enough punch to strike an enemy and there may be no need for a permanent base in Syria.
Putin also said the Syrian people themselves must determine who rules the country.
Putin, who met U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry earlier this week, said Moscow supports a U.S. draft of a U.N. Security Council resolution on Syria. He says a new constitution for Syria must be drafted, and a new election prepared in which the Syrians themselves will determine its leadership.
He adds that Russia believes that a political settlement is the only way to end the Syrian crisis.
Putin says Russia and the U.S. agree on the need to ensure work on a new constitution and create mechanisms of control over future elections.
Updated
Putin referred to Ukraine as “our brotherly republic, as I never get tired of saying.”
A Ukrainian journalist asked if captured Russian officers would be exchanged for Ukrainian helicopter pilot Nadezhda Savchenko. Putin says the criminal case against them has excluded this possibility.
Face of Ukrainian journalist as #Putin again says no Russian soldiers are in Ukraine, Savchenko exchange impossible pic.twitter.com/f7CqhpNkYK
— Alec Luhn (@ASLuhn) December 17, 2015
Updated
Putin on Ukraine: “We never said there were not people there who carried out certain tasks including in the military sphere”. But this is different to the regular Russian army, he adds.
Putin: We have never denied that we have people in Ukraine, including those working in the military sphere, but not regular troops
— Leonid Ragozin (@leonidragozin) December 17, 2015
Updated
Kremlin pool reporter has a big scoop. Putin has a new cup.
У Путина в этом году новая чашка. В прошлом году была другая - необычная pic.twitter.com/gXw3mxyccM
— Дмитрий Смирнов (@dimsmirnov175) December 17, 2015
Updated
Russia doesn’t necessarily need a permanent base in Syria, Putin says.
"Why do we need a permanent base in Syria? If we need to get somebody, we'll get 'em". Applause again.
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Updated
Time for a coffee tbh.
So basically there is no clear plan in Syria. #PutinPresser
— Natalia Antonova (@NataliaAntonova) December 17, 2015
Putin says Russia has partially succeeded in uniting Syrian government and opposition forces in their fight against ISIS. He says Russia will continue air strikes in Syria for as long as Syrian army continues its own military operations.
Putin says the Russian plan on Syria generally overlaps with the US one.
Putin: Our plan on Syria generally overlaps with the American vision.
— Leonid Ragozin (@leonidragozin) December 17, 2015
#Putin says Kerry came to Moscow with project for UN resolution. Good step but Syrian government should also approve pic.twitter.com/NE5IyR3qcO
— Alec Luhn (@ASLuhn) December 17, 2015
Updated
State run Channel One asks: “Do we have a clear plan on Syria? Or are we being impulsive?”
Putin says ISIS is a threat to everyone. “The quicker we can deal with it. The better. Nothing other than political solution [in Syria]”.
Updated
Putin says he doesn’t see any prospect for reviving relations with Turkey.
#Putin says sees no possibility to mend ties with Turkey on world stage after shooting down of Russian warplane
— Andrew Osborn (@A_Osborn) December 17, 2015
If it was an accident, pick up the phone & explain. Instead Turkey hid behind NATO, #Putin says pic.twitter.com/yJ8eg3OL7R
— Alec Luhn (@ASLuhn) December 17, 2015
#Putin says ISIS arose to fill power vacuum made by US invasion of Iraq. Uses Islamic slogans to keep oil flowing pic.twitter.com/SIIlkK01YI
— Alec Luhn (@ASLuhn) December 17, 2015
Putin says Ataturk would be rolling in his grave over Islamization in modern Turkey.
— Andrew Roth (@ARothWP) December 17, 2015
Putin uses his classic line when he clashes with foreign countries: argument with Turkey is with leadership, not people
— James Marson (@marson_jr) December 17, 2015
Putin on Russia's Turkish-speaking people: You are part of Russia so don't rock the boat. Turkey's leadership "stabbed us in the back"
— Jason Corcoran (@jason_corcoran) December 17, 2015
Wow, Putin completely ignores part of Q about Turkish students deported etc, sticks with v tough line on relations being ruined. Signal.
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Also... what?
Putin says the Islamist government in Turkey tried to sell itself to the West is "our son of a bitch"
— Leonid Ragozin (@leonidragozin) December 17, 2015
Putin on Turkey shooting down Russian bomber: "Did they think we'd run away? No, we're not that kind of country." pic.twitter.com/4tyFnQuE5l
— Steve Rosenberg (@BBCSteveR) December 17, 2015
Oh boy...
"Someone in the Turkish leadership tried to lick the Americans in a particular place". *laughter, applause*
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Putin is angry that Ankara called Brussels, not Moscow, when the Russian jet was downed.
Good question from Tatarstan about Tatarstan's ties to Turkey. Shows up stupid comments abt Turkey by Culture Minister Medinsky too. #Putin
— Natalia Antonova (@NataliaAntonova) December 17, 2015
And here comes Anadolou, talking about post-#russianjet harassment of Turks in Russia. Because yes, goddamit, it is happening. #Putin
— Natalia Antonova (@NataliaAntonova) December 17, 2015
#Putin angry that Ankara called Brussels, not Moscow, when #russianjet downed. Think he saw it as personal slight on top of everything else.
— Natalia Antonova (@NataliaAntonova) December 17, 2015
Putin says the downing of the Russian jet by Turkey was a hostile act.
Putin: Downing of Russian military aircraft by Turkey was ``a hostile act." People were killed.. no accident. They tried to cover it up
— Jason Corcoran (@jason_corcoran) December 17, 2015
Updated
We’ve gone to two more Turkey questions. The Guardian’s Shaun Walker says it looks like a planned opportunity for Putin to give the signal to officials to stop harrassing Turks in Russia.
Updated
Putin interrupted Peskov to take a question from a Tatar business journalist because she had “such a big sign”. She asked whether Russia should break off investment ties with Turkey.
She's also telling Putin that if the President of Tatarstan has to stop calling himself a President, it could hurt feelings of all Tatars
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Putin asked about severing ties to the Turk world comes by Tatar journo. Turks are big investors in Muslim-dominated Tatarstan
— Jason Corcoran (@jason_corcoran) December 17, 2015
Updated
The map of Russia behind Putin’s head includes the annexed Crimea.
Putin speaking with background of Crimea-included map of Russia pic.twitter.com/H57CvMPlIn
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
WHOSE IS IT?!
This is how you have to try to get a question. One of these signs says "I'm pregnant". Really. pic.twitter.com/BglhK5xkOF
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Updated
Here’s a video of Putin’s “old joke”. I have a feeling the punchline got lost in translation.
And how would you attempt to draw Putin’s attention?
She wants to get Putin's attention thanks to this doll. Let's wish her luck. #PutinPresser #oF24 pic.twitter.com/gEogH1W5qp
— Julien Pain (@JulienPain) December 17, 2015
Putin just called for a round of applause for a RIA Novosti journalist who asked a question about why central bank should lower rates.
Meanwhile on Red Square a man has apparently tried to set himself on fire.
В Москве мужчина попытался совершить самосожжение на Красной площади https://t.co/CbWW6QWZGL pic.twitter.com/NeciP967ed
— Уютная редакция (@znak_com) December 17, 2015
AP reports:
President Vladimir Putin says that Russia’s economy is showing signs of stabilization despite plummeting oil prices.
He said that despite a GDP drop caused by a drop in global oil prices, Russia’s main commodity, the nation’s industries have started to rebound.
He said the nation’s currencyy reserves stand at $364 billion and a capital outflow has slowed.
He’s still going.... the gist is: economic forecasts will have to be reviewed due to falling oil prices. But Russia’s economy has already turned the corner.
First question gets a 10-minute answer about the economy, which is still going. It's not exactly Paxman out here.
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Updated
Putin is coughing a lot. It’s cold in Moscow this time of year.
He says Russia has passed the peak of the economic crisis. Uses weird anecdote about life not always being black and white.
Putin starts with anecdote: What looked black last year now looks white. Even $50/barrel of oil now looks optimistic pic.twitter.com/6A3h1fkoAh
— Alec Luhn (@ASLuhn) December 17, 2015
Putin laments that the government has had to recalculate budget twice already and now is even "too optimistic''' factoring in oil at $50
— Jason Corcoran (@jason_corcoran) December 17, 2015
Putin: Russian economy has passed the peak of the crisis, stabilization under way.
— Leonid Ragozin (@leonidragozin) December 17, 2015
Updated
The first question has been about the Russian economy.
First Q about tough economy situation. Putin tells joke about changing perceptions; says Russian economic predictions were based on $100 oil
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Putin opened his speech by saying he’s already made all his key points in his address to parliament, but there must be questions that need additional clarification. That’s it, we’re off to questions already.
Waiting for Putin.... it’s tense.
The conference hasn’t even started yet and we’re already talking about a bear with an axe.
Screen currently has flags of Russian regions up, one of which is A BEAR WITH AN AXE. How cool is that? pic.twitter.com/8KkViyJxzQ
— Shaun Walker (@shaunwalker7) December 17, 2015
Here’s a photo of a fresher faced Putin at his first big press conference in 2001. They say politics can age a man. Thoughts?
Photo of Putin at 1st big press conference in 2001. It's got a certain Sovietesque je ne sais quois. @dimsmirnov175 pic.twitter.com/DKzpRYuQEg
— Alec Luhn (@ASLuhn) December 17, 2015
An actual legitimate question that a lot of people were asking yesterday was whether Vladimir Putin is immortal? A photograph from 1920 that began circulating showed a Russian soldier who bears an uncanny resemblance to the country’s current leader. Another photo, taken of a Russian soldier in 1941, also looks very much like Putin. Edward Cullen eat your heart out.
Conspiracy theorists suggest Vladimir Putin could be immortal https://t.co/ketDN6MP7j pic.twitter.com/DZE8nE2h81
— Daily Mail Online (@MailOnline) December 15, 2015
Updated
Welcome to our live coverage of Vladimir Putin’s annual press conference. It will be the 11th press conference Putin will have with Russian and international journalists during the three terms he has been head of state. These events have been known to go on for hours. Given that you could say there’s quite a lot for him to talk about this year, best get yourself settled in a comfy seat with a cup of your favourite brew.
Almost 1,400 journalists have received accreditation for this year’s event, according to the Kremlin website. Our Moscow correspondent Shaun Walker will be filing and tweeting from the scene throughout the morning. Here is his introduction:
I’m in the hall waiting for the press conference to start, it’s a huge venue and there are 1400 journalists accredited this year, making it pretty hard to actually get a question in. everyone from world media to the smallest local Russian publication is here.
The usual drill is that Putin’s press secretary Dmitry Peskov will ask some selected journalists for the first hour and a half, a mix of Russian state outlets and a few more independent or foreign journalists, who will ask questions loosely agreed in advance. After that, Putin tends to go for a pick and mix approach, calling on those who take his fancy. Many regional journalists have made signs or brought props to try to catch the leader’s attention.
The format is advantageous to Putin – he does normally take a few awkward questions, but the format allows for no follow-up or cross examination, so he can usually bat any tricky questions away with little effort. He normally gives the impression of enjoying the session and in previous years has gone for nearly five hours without a break, though last year’s session was more modest, ending shortly after the allotted three hour mark.
The questions are likely to range over a wide range of issues, from the economy and local issues to the war in Syria. In previous years Putin has been asked to intervene in the building of a local kindergarten and asked how he manages to look so good.
It will be interesting to see whether Putin takes a question on the extraordinary allegations aired recently by anti-corruption campaigner Alexei Navalny over the business and criminal links of the family of Russia’s prosecutor general. Sitting two rows in front of me is Georgy Alburov, who works for Navalny’s foundation and has somehow managed to get accredited.
Updated