Favourites – we use them for a myriad of reasons. Favouriting a tweet could mean “I like this tweet”, or “good point”, or “this is fun, but not enough to retweet”, or “I acknowledge your communication, but can’t be bothered to reply”, or “the conversation is ending now, but on a positive note!” Also, the favourite is a great bookmarking tool.
Now, however, Twitter has cruelly stripped away all of the above nuances of communication by replacing the favourite function with a “like” button. Unlike. How, now, is one supposed to bookmark an article on the refugee crisis without ‘liking’ it? I’m not ready to inaccurately look – ironically – heartless on social media.
In a press release, Twitter’s thinking is entirely wrongheaded. Hearts are, it says, “more expressive”. No, hearts aren’t, for reasons outlined above. Here is what they think a heart can mean …
You can say a lot with a heart. Introducing a new way to show how you feel on Twitter: https://t.co/WKBEmORXNW pic.twitter.com/G4ZGe0rDTP
— Twitter (@twitter) November 3, 2015
“ADORBS”. Bleurgh. Here’s how others have reacted …
Some users on Twitter have taken the change really well
WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO TWITTER???? WHY IS THERE A HEART INSTEAD OF THE FAVORITE STAR I DONT LIKE IT WTF
— ☾ (@ItsPenns) November 3, 2015
Twitter changed the favorite button from a star to a heart and I'm pissed about it
— Elif Akkaya (@elif_akkaya28) November 3, 2015
what the fuck is this heart shaped button for
— lina misses 1d:( (@lucidreamnjh) November 3, 2015
Others have made the point about ‘liking’ bad news tweets
Favoriting an article about how 30 people died to read later looked faintly odd with a star, but downright evil with a heart.
— James Ball (@jamesrbuk) November 3, 2015
@laurenlaverne 80% of my faves are stories on my reading list. Rarely stuff I actually like/approve of as haven't read yet
— Sophie Wilkinson (@sophwilkinson) November 3, 2015
While these people make very good points
time for the "what did twitter do instead of addressing abuse solutions" checklist
— a literal psyduck (@sarahjeong) November 3, 2015
So how'd that meeting go? "Our user base didn't grow last quarter. What do we do?" "How about a like button that *sparkles*" "💰💰💰"
— dan sinker (@dansinker) November 3, 2015
Some are more optimistic
Would be very interesting if Twitter are trying to shift the tone of the conversation with the new 'like' heart. Will it becalm the trolls?
— Lauren Laverne (@laurenlaverne) November 3, 2015
Others took to polls to debate the subject
Twitter: you may have wanted to implement the like feature before polls...
— Tom Wilson (@feedthedrummer) November 3, 2015
Twitter's new ❤️ button
— Sue Llewellyn (@suellewellyn) November 3, 2015
Some people think it is ADORBS
But in all seriousness the like button is actually quite cute and I don't know why people are getting upset over a button.
— SmallishBeans (@Smallishbeans) November 3, 2015
And some are already being caught out
@wallaceme God, I nearly hearted this. @nickpickles
— James Manning (@JamesManning) November 3, 2015
People are taking the mickey, too, obviously
wait whats with the like button my body wasnt ready for change like that
— Raphael Gomes (@raphablueberry) November 3, 2015
The new 'Like' button isn't a heart it's a bum
— Adam Hess (@adamhess1) November 3, 2015
When everyone is complaining about the new like button on Twitter and you still have favorites pic.twitter.com/RtLk9QQDbG
— aaliyah (@blackheaux) November 3, 2015
I see the Twitter heart button isn't wearing a poppy.
— Matt Owen (@MJowen174) November 3, 2015
The perfect hybrid story on my TL around now would be Tristram Hunt defending the new heart button on Twitter.
— Rafael Behr (@rafaelbehr) November 3, 2015
why is the fav button a heart lmao
— nina ❀ (@voguewithariana) November 3, 2015
Here is what all British users need, however. Can we sort this?
@laurenlaverne It's the Facebook dilemma all over again... what we need is a 'polite nod' button
— Stuart Taylor (@stuartctaylor) November 3, 2015
Do you like the new “like”? Or was the old star your favourite? Let us know in the comments below.