The Democratic impeachment managers continued to make the case against Donald Trump in the Senate on Thursday, focusing on abuse of power and accusing the administration and Fox News of pushing “completely bogus, Kremlin-pushed” conspiracy theories as a pretext to cheat the 2020 election by leaning on Ukraine for a political favour.
House Judiciary Committee chairman Jerrold Nadler called the president’s conduct “wrong”, “illegal” and “dangerous” while his Intelligence Committee counterpart Adam Schiff closed on an emotional note, declaring: “If the truth doesn’t matter, we’re lost.”
As Republicans again made a point of heavily advertising how bored they were – with one senator even handing out fidget spinners to colleagues – President Trump took to Twitter to shift attention to the 2020 race but could not resist posting a meme of Barack Obama “spying” on him in Trump Tower (itself a groundless conspiracy theory).
Please allow a moment for our live blog to load
Trump seeks to distract with new Obama meme
Kate Ng has more on that witless attempt by the president to divert attention from the Senate impeachment trial.
‘The Constitution is not a suicide pact’
What a superb line that is from Jerry Nadler. “It does not leave us stuck with presidents who abuse their power in unforeseen ways that threaten our security and democracy," he continued.
"Until recently, it did not occur to me that our president would call a foreign leader and demand a sham investigation meant to kneecap his political opponents, all in exchange for releasing vital military aid that the president was already required by law to provide.”
Here's a little more on yesterday's prosecution effort, where the intentions of the Founding Fathers were again poured over with no little passion.
Kamala Harris 'considering' Joe Biden endorsement
The California senator and former state attorney general, who was forced to drop out of the 2020 race in December due to lack of funds, is reportedly considering backing the Democratic front-runner, according to The New York Times.
For now, Harris "remains focused on the ongoing impeachment trial" but her backing would represent a major coup for Biden.
“No decisions have been made about whether she will endorse, which candidate, nor when an endorsement decision will be made,” her spokesman Chris Harris (no relation?) told The NYT.
Trump imposes visa restrictions on pregnant women to target 'criminal' birth tourism
Clark Mindock has this on another attempt by the administration to police's women's bodies - this time as an anti-immigration measure.
Trump pushes ancient Steele Dossier conspiracy theory, complains his defence lawyers will get poor ratings
"So had bad & illegal is that?" the president asks, after extensively quoting an ex-federal prosecutor alleging FBI snooping on his administration.
He's now moaning about the fact that the first day of his legal team's rebuttal comes on a Saturday, when he expects audience numbers to be way down...
...and using Biden's words against him.
That point about Saturday being "Death Valley" for TV ratings betrays his obsession with the subject, a hangover from his Apprentice days, as well as his preoccupation with his status as a perennial political victim, despite his own stooge, Mitch McConnell, setting the rules for the trial.
This is just paranoid raving.
Betsy DeVos says being pro-choice is akin to supporting slavery
Trump's education secretary is one of the longest-serving members of his cabinet, largely because the president has little personal interest in her sector and because she typically (perhaps shrewdly) prefers to keep a low profile.
She's broken with that here though, making an extraordinarily ill-advised and inflammatory comparison in support of the March for Life movement ahead of the president's appearance with them today.
Zoe Tidman has this report.
Trump attending March for Life in DC on Friday
The president is up and advertising his controversial upcoming appearance at a March for Life anti-abortion rally in Washington today.
He also still doesn't know that it's "attorneys general", not "attorney generals".
There was also this via Lindsey Graham on Fox, seeing the president cheerily returning to pushing conspiracy theories right after the Democrats comprehensively dismantled the tactic in the Senate.
On the reweet count, it's currently 4-3 to Fox hack Greg Jarrett against Dan Bongino.
He's also posted a five month old tweet by Candace Owens, hawking her new book, plus several more from offical GOP accounts, Mitch McConnell, Kevin McCarthy, Lee Zeldin, Mike Lee, Tim Scott, Joni Ernst and John Barrasso.
Here's Kate Ng on a very questionable first for the presidency.
Mike Pence calls Trump 'unstoppable' on hot mic
Speaking of Pence, he was caught on a hot mic in conversation with Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu yesterday at the World Holocaust Forum in Jerusalem.
Alex Woodward was listening in.
Democrats call on White House to declassify mystery Jennifer Williams letter
Impeachment manager Zoe Lofgren and the Senate minority leader have both called on the Trump administration to declassify a letter written by Jennifer Williams, an aide to vice president Mike Pence, which was submitted to the impeachment inquiry in the aftermath of her testimony on 19 November.
"A cover-up is not a reason to classify a document," Lofgren said in the chamber on Thursday.
The letter in question is a one page memo focusing on Pence's call with Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine on 18 September, one week before the latter met with Trump at the UN.
Williams also heard the original Trump call on 25 July and told the House about her unease with its contents during her appearance under oath before Christmas.
“I’ve seen the supplemental testimony,” Chuck Schumer told reporters during a break in the trial yesterday. “I’m not sure it should be classified. I agree with the House managers to declassify it.”
"There's no reason that it should be kept classified. It should be made public, regardless of which side it helps. The American people should judge," agreed senator and former Connecticut attorney general Richard Blumenthal after viewing it in a secure Senate briefing room yesterday morning.
The Republicans are, of course, seeking to downplay the matter.
"I don’t know that any other documents are going to make a more compelling case for my Democratic colleagues at this point,” says Trump apologist Mark Meadows.
“For the vast majority of Americans, it’s time to get this over with.”
Lindsey Graham says he will resist pressure to call Bidens as witnesses but asks media to dig deeper into ex-veep's son
Senator Graham was embarrassed by the Democrats yesterday when they ran that vintage footage of him at the Clinton impeachment (although he is understood to have fled the chamber before it aired, perhaps having been tipped off) but, speaking to reporters afterwards, he said he would not bow to either side when the question of calling witnesses next raises its head.
He said he expected to be "under a lot of pressure" from his own side to call Joe and Hunter Biden and the CIA whistleblower to give testimony but pledged: "I'm not going to give in to that pressure, because I don't think it will serve the Senate and the country well."
He appeared to agree with Senate minority leader Chuck Schumer on the need to stop the trial becoming a "circus".
"I want the American people to pick the next president, not me... I am not going to use my vote to extend the trial," he said.
Having reasserted his independence, Graham revealed his more familiar colours by calling on the media to dig deeper into Hunter Biden's career opportunities overseas.
"I don't know how many times it was said by the managers that the Biden conflict of interest allegations has been debunked and there's no scintilla of evidence in terms of conflicts of interest and potential wrongdoing," he said, adding: "So, when the managers tell me this has been looked at and debunked... by who?"
Trump posts Obama 'spying' meme, turns focus to 2020 race
The president took to Twitter to shift attention to the 2020 battle but could not resist posting a meme of Barack Obama “spying” on him in Trump Tower (itself exactly the groundless conspiracy theory the impeachment managers were describing).
He served up favourable polling charts from Florida, Alabama, Texas and Kansas (all states he won in 2016), wondered whether "Sleepy Joe" could edge out "Crazy Bernie" and singled out one brainwashed MAGA fan boy in particular for praise:
But he couldn't entirely resist weighing in on matters in the Senate...
This Sean Hannity tweet actually serves as a helpful illustration of how Fox are covering the impeachment trial (they're not).
John T Bennett has more on Trump's pivot.
Republicans bemoan 'Groundhog Day in the Senate'
GOP senators in the chamber again made a point of heavily advertising how bored they were – with North Carolina senator Richard Burr even handing out 52 fidget spinners to colleagues.
While they case was being laid out for them, they doodled on documents, worked on crosswords and fiddled with their Apple Watches (making a mockery of the custom not to allow electronic devices into the trial), according to The New York Times, all as part of a co-ordinated pantomime intended to loudly illustrate to conservative voters that they were not giving the process the serious attention it deserves.
"It's Groundhog Day in the Senate," moaned John Barrasso of Wyoming to reporters during a break, while Roy Blunt of Missouri praised the opposition's "admirable presentations" but complained: "There's nothing new there".
Again, as a frustrated Chuck Schumer said yesterday, it's worth repeating that if the GOP were really interested in "new" evidence against the president, they would not have voted against hearing from new witnesses and subpoenaing new documents on Tuesday.
Don't be fooled - only one side here is engaging in a "partisan charade" (to borrow Rand Paul's phrase) and it's not the Democrats.
This might have something to do with it.
Here's Peter Stubley on these exasperating hijinks (warning: features Ted Cruz drinking game).
Adam Schiff makes emotional appeal: 'If the truth doesn't matter, we're lost'
The California Democrat leading the impeachment prosecution had already won glowing plaudits for his perfomance on Wednesday from left-leaning pundits but arguable suprassed himself last night with his emotional closing statement.
It's quite something and well worth watching.
Impeachment prosecutors make abuse of power case, attack conspiracy theories
The Democratic impeachment managers continued to make the case against Donald Trump in the Senate on Thursday, focusing on abuse of power and accusing the administration and Fox News of pushing “completely bogus, Kremlin-pushed” conspiracy theories as a pretext to cheat the 2020 election by leaning on Ukraine for a political favour.
Sylvia Garcia shot down the "groundless" corruption allegations against Joe Biden concerning his tenure as vice president - the basis on which Trump asked Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky for a quid pro quo in his notorious 25 July call: a graft investigation in exchange for the release of $391m (£302m) in congressionally-approved military aid to battle Russian aggression.
"There was no basis for the investigation the president was pursuing and pushing. None. He was doing it only for his own political benefit," said the former judge from Texas.
House Intelligence Committee chairman Adam Schiff pointed to a "convergence of interest" between Russian president Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump: "The Russians not only got him to deflect blame from their interference in our democracy, but they got him to withhold military aid."
Schiff also got a laugh by claiming Trump had "made a religious man" out of Putin:
His Judiciary Committee counterpart Jerrold Nadler meanwhile commented: "No president has ever used his office to compel a foreign nation to help him cheat in our elections…The president's conduct is wrong. It is illegal. It is dangerous."
The prosecution team again made brilliant use of video clips - particularly from Fox pundits like Laura Ingraham and Tucker Carlson to shoot down the pro-Trump network's disingeuous efforts to gaslight its viewers.
They also embarrassed Trump loyalist and senator for South Carolina Lindsey Graham by running a vintage excerpt of him speaking during the Bill Clinton that completely contradicts his current stance on proceedings now his own man in the dock.
They also saved their biggest hits for primetime, when American viewers were most likely to be engaged in the latest marathon session:
Here's John T Bennett's report.
Hello and welcome to The Independent's rolling coverage of the Donald Trump administration.
.png?w=600)
