100s of titles, one news app for just $10 a month.
Dive Deeper:
Clarence Thomas: “Tremendously bad” Supreme Court leak shatters public trust
"When you lose that trust, especially in the institution that I'm in, it changes the institution fundamentally."
Clarence Thomas says leak of opinion to overturn Roe is like an ‘infidelity’ that eroded trust in Supreme Court
Long-serving sitting justice tells right-wing think tank that opinion leak was ‘tremendously bad’
Supreme Court meets for first time since bombshell leak of draft opinion overturning Roe v Wade
‘This is an institution unravelling before our eyes,’ former clerk says
Justice Thomas on SCOTUS Leak: "You begin to look over your shoulder"
Thomas on the Rehnquist Court: “We may have been a dysfunctional family, but we were a family.”
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Alito’s draft opinion overturning Roe is still the only one circulated inside Supreme Court
A rattled Supreme Court will meet Thursday for the first time since the abortion opinion was reported.
A look at 3 common beliefs about the Supreme Court's upcoming abortion ruling
WASHINGTON — The leaked Supreme Court draft opinion overruling Roe v. Wade set off a political firestorm about the future…
Get all your news in one place
Latest Politics news:
‘Devastated’ Morrison reveals what’s next after stunning election defeat
Former prime minister Scott Morrison has spoken out following his brutal election defeat, saying he's "going back to being a…
Read news from The Economist, FT, Bloomberg and more, with one subscription
Learn More
Industry-led research is key to improved economic outcomes
In its short history, Australia has built a proud tradition of research excellence across our institutions. In mainstream commentary we…
Below the Line: How might our new, more diverse parliament change Australia and the Asia-Pacific? – podcast
Right from the outset, it is clear Prime Minister Anthony Albanese’s agenda is very different to his predecessor Scott Morrison’s…
Alan Kohler: Here’s a crazy idea for the Liberal Party – sensible policies
If the Liberal Party goes to the right, whatever that means, it will be doomed and politics in Australia will…
How the NRA evolved from backing a 1934 ban on machine guns to blocking nearly all firearm restrictions today
The mass shootings at a Buffalo, New York, supermarket and an elementary school in Uvalde, Texas, just 10 days apart,…
From analysis to good news, read the world’s best news in one place
Who is Peter Dutton? The ex-cop tipped to be the next leader of the Liberal Party
Former minister Peter Dutton is expected to run unopposed to be the next leader of the Liberal Party and, in…
Calls for new innovation patents after old scheme abolished
There are fresh calls for a new innovation patent scheme to be launched by the federal government to help local SMEs…

Thomas blasts disclosure of draft Supreme Court opinion as 'tremendously bad'

By Josh Gerstein
Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas speaks at the Heritage Foundation on Oct. 21, 2021. | Drew Angerer/Getty Images

Justice Clarence Thomas, the longest-serving sitting member of the Supreme Court, declared Friday that the publication of a draft majority opinion on abortion has permanently damaged trust within the nation's highest court and is a symptom of a broader decline in America's institutions.

"I do think that what happened at the court is tremendously bad," Thomas declared during a discussion at a conference for Black conservatives in Dallas. "I wonder how long we’re going to have these institutions at the rate we're undermining them and then I wonder when they're gone or destabilized what we will have as a country and I don’t think the prospects are good if we continue to lose them."

Thomas, an appointee of President George H.W. Bush and one of the court's staunchest conservatives, suggested that the unprecedented public release of the draft opinion overturning Roe v. Wade has prompted the justices and their aides to look at each other with suspicion.

"When you lose that trust, especially in the institution that I'm in, it changes the institution fundamentally. You begin to look over your shoulder," Thomas said. "It's kind of like infidelity that you can explain it, but you can't undo it."

Thomas said that before the release of the draft opinion — made public by POLITICO last week — he considered that sort of disclosure unthinkable.

"If someone said that one line of one opinion would be leaked by anyone ... you would say: 'That's impossible. No one would ever do that,'" the justice said. "That was verboten. It was beyond anyone's understanding or at least anyone's imagination."

Speaking at the Old Parkland Conference, Thomas did not criticize any of his colleagues by name, but he indicated that the atmosphere on the court now is different than it was a few years ago.

"This is not the court of that era," said Thomas, who was confirmed in 1991. "I sat with Ruth Ginsburg for almost 30 years and she was actually an easy colleague to deal with. ... We may have been a dysfunctional family, but we were a family."

At times, Thomas seemed to suggest that a fellow justice or law clerk might be responsible for the disclosure.

"Anybody who would, for example, have an attitude to leak documents, that is your general attitude, that is your future on the bench," he said.

Release of the opinion led to demonstrations at the Supreme Court and at the homes of several conservative justices, prompting the erection of an eight-foot high fence outside the court and increased security around the justices themselves. Thomas lamented those protests and argued that conservatives don't engage in such tactics.

"You would never visit Supreme Court justice[s'] houses when things didn't go our way," Thomas said. "We didn't throw temper tantrums. ... It is incumbent on us to always act appropriately and not to repay tit for tat."

Thomas did not comment on the substance of the 67-page draft opinion written by his conservative colleague, Justice Samuel Alito, but at one point Thomas embraced one of the arguments in it over stare decisis: the principle that respect for precedent justifies upholding prior court opinions even if they're erroneous. Alito's opinion argues that stare decisis should not be an obstacle to overturning the 49-year-old precedent guaranteeing a federal constitutional right to abortion.

"When someone uses stare decisis that means they're out of arguments," Thomas said.

Thomas also ventured into discussion of some topics sitting justices rarely opine on publicly. He defended the Senate’s refusal to consider Judge Merrick Garland when President Barack Obama nominated him in 2016 to fill the vacancy caused by the death of Justice Antonin Scalia. The Senate was simply following a policy articulated by then-Sen. Joe Biden, when he chaired the Senate Judiciary Committee, of not confirming a Supreme Court nominee in the last year of a president's term, Thomas asserted.

The professor who questioned Thomas at the event, John Yoo of Berkeley Law School, did not ask Thomas about a raft of criticism he received for participating in cases related to the 2020 election and the congressional investigation into the storming of the Capitol on Jan. 6 despite the fact that his wife, Virginia Thomas, was in contact with the White House chief of staff on Jan. 6 and was urging President Donald Trump to continue to fight the election results showing him defeated.

Yoo initially referred to the draft in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization as "the alleged draft Dobbs opinion." However, on the day after POLITICO published the document, Chief Justice John Roberts issued a statement acknowledging its authenticity and announcing an investigation into the disclosure.

Yoo repeatedly joked about the disclosure during their joint appearance Friday night, saying at one juncture that he might make public the notes Thomas took at other sessions of the conference.

"Well, I know where to go. POLITICO will publish anything I give them now," Yoo said, drawing laughter from Thomas.

Myah Ward contributed to this report.

What is inkl?
The world’s most important news, from 100+ trusted global sources, in one place.
Morning Edition
Your daily
news overview

Morning Edition ensures you start your day well informed.

No paywalls, no clickbait, no ads
Enjoy beautiful reading

Content is only half the story. The world's best news experience is free from distraction: ad-free, clickbait-free, and beautifully designed.

Expert Curation
The news you need to know

Stories are ranked by proprietary algorithms based on importance and curated by real news journalists to ensure that you receive the most important stories as they break.

Dive Deeper:
Clarence Thomas: “Tremendously bad” Supreme Court leak shatters public trust
"When you lose that trust, especially in the institution that I'm in, it changes the institution fundamentally."
Clarence Thomas says leak of opinion to overturn Roe is like an ‘infidelity’ that eroded trust in Supreme Court
Long-serving sitting justice tells right-wing think tank that opinion leak was ‘tremendously bad’
Supreme Court meets for first time since bombshell leak of draft opinion overturning Roe v Wade
‘This is an institution unravelling before our eyes,’ former clerk says
Justice Thomas on SCOTUS Leak: "You begin to look over your shoulder"
Thomas on the Rehnquist Court: “We may have been a dysfunctional family, but we were a family.”
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Alito’s draft opinion overturning Roe is still the only one circulated inside Supreme Court
A rattled Supreme Court will meet Thursday for the first time since the abortion opinion was reported.
A look at 3 common beliefs about the Supreme Court's upcoming abortion ruling
WASHINGTON — The leaked Supreme Court draft opinion overruling Roe v. Wade set off a political firestorm about the future…
Get all your news in one place