Frozen burgers promise dinner-ready convenience when fresh meat isn’t an option. But not all frozen burgers are created equal—some disappoint in taste, texture, or value. We’re breaking down which frozen burgers are a waste of money and highlighting the surprising winners worth your freezer space. This guide helps you shop smart, save money, and still enjoy a juicy burger. Let’s dive in and uncover the truth about frozen burgers so your next cookout doesn’t flop.
Frozen Burgers That You Should Pass On
1. Ball Park Flame-Grilled Beef Patties – Bland and Over-Processed
First up, Ball Park Flame-Grilled patties are fully cooked for microwave convenience, but at a cost. Reviewers noted a flat, processed taste and lack of real beef flavor. Texture is soggy unless heavily dressed, and the extra ingredients overshadow any beef. Skip these if you want a real burger experience—they’re only worth it in a locker-room rush. For a quick fix, though, they fall short.
2. Heritage Angus Burgers – Odd Texture, Overpriced
Though labeled 100% beef, Heritage Angus frozen patties received criticism for a spongy, odd mouthfeel. They also shrink considerably when cooked and lack that satisfying sear. Considering they cost around $2.50 per patty, you’re not getting value. Unless you want Angus premium and don’t care about taste, these are better left on the shelf. Freshly ground meat delivers more flavor for less money.
3. Bubba Burger Original – Fatty but Flawed
Bubba Burgers are well-known, but the original frozen beef patties don’t impress in taste tests. Testers cited blandness and subpar flavor compared to fresh burgers. Similarly, Reddit users report fatigue with fillers and preservatives. If you’re already reaching for convenience, go for a better-tasting brand instead. Budget-savvy shoppers will want to skip these.
4. Good & Gather (Target) – Too Lean, Too Dry
Target’s Good & Gather patties are affordable, but that leanness works against them. The 85/15 mix produced dry burgers with too much char, lacking juicy flavor. While some fans on Reddit appreciate consistency and no fillers, most critics say these need serious fixing to be palatable. As a base for a quick burger, maybe—but not a satisfying one.
5. Kirkland Signature (Costco) – Decent Value, But Below Flavor Expectations
Costco’s Kirkland frozen patties are economical—about $1.55 per burger—but fall short in taste tests. Critics note they lack flavor unless heavily seasoned. Fans say they work for big cookouts where cost matters, but if flavor is your top priority, there are better choices. You might need to doctor them up to mask blandness.
These Frozen Burgers Are Actually Quite Tasty
1. Philly Gourmet 100% Beef Patties – Rich, Real, Refrigerator-Worthy
Surprising star of taste tests, Philly Gourmet’s patties offer fresh-ground texture and beefy flavor that fooled testers into thinking they were homemade. Extras? Just beef—with no fillers. They cook well from frozen and hold juiciness like they were just made. For around $1.37 per patty, they’re a great deal. These are definitely worth stocking in your freezer.
2. Wegmans Seasoned Angus Beef Burgers – Juicy, Savory, Crowd-Pleaser
Wegmans’ seasoned Angus patties landed near the top for juiciness, seasoning, and that crave-worthy Maillard crust. Larger than typical quarter-pounders and salt-seasoned for flavor, these patties taste like they came from a grill. This one’s a winner if you have access. Just the right balance of taste, size, and texture makes these a crowd favorite.
3. Aldi Cattlemen’s Ranch Seasoned Smash Burgers – Viral Smash Hit
Aldi’s Cattlemen’s Ranch smash-style burgers made a big splash on TikTok with crispy edges and a rich sear for around $1 each. Fans call them a “10/10,” praising flavor, price, and ease of cooking. They’re back this season, but only for a limited time, so grab them while you can. Restaurant-style smash technique at grocery prices? Hard to beat.
Worthy Adds: Fresh Frozen Game-Changers
- ButcherBox Grass-Fed Beef Burgers – These 80/20 grass-fed patties are flash-frozen at peak freshness. No fillers and vacuum sealed for real flavor, they deliver a juicy bite with clean beef taste every time.
- 8-oz Wagyu Burgers – For a gourmet experience, these Wagyu patties offer buttery texture and rich marbling normally reserved for high-end restaurants.
- Lily Hill Farm Dry-Aged Burger Patties – Hand-pressed from dry-aged beef, these patties bring steakhouse flavor home. Great if you want quality without messing with ground beef.
Final Bite: Know What You’re Frosting
Not all frozen burgers are equal. Some just aren’t worth the money, while others surprise you with real flavor and texture. Skip the Bland Five and go for Philly Gourmet, Wegmans, or Aldi’s Cattlemen’s Ranch if you want great taste without compromise. And if you’re after premium, try the grass-fed or Wagyu patties above. With these tips, your next frozen burger will be anything but forgettable.
Have a frozen burger you swear by—or one you regret buying? Drop your favorite (or worst!) in the comments—we’re building the ultimate freezer burger guide!
Read More
7 Cheap Ways To Prevent Your Grill From Rusting
Clever Ways To Save Money When Backyard Grilling
The post These 5 Frozen Burgers Are a Waste of Money (But These 3 Are Surprisingly Good) appeared first on Clever Dude Personal Finance & Money.
