Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Canberra Times
The Canberra Times
Alex Crowe

'Their health is being affected': Wood heater ban call comes amid rise in popularity

John Schmitzer says wood fired heaters have become increasingly popular with customers at his store, Heating and Cooling Services in Fyshwick. Picture by James Croucher

Wood heaters are more popular today than they have been in the more than 40 years John Schmitzer has been selling them to customers in Canberra, but the heyday for fireplaces would come to an end under recommendations made to the ACT government.

Mr Schmitzer said wood heaters make up about 40 per cent of sales from the Fyshwick store. Gas heating makes up the second largest share of sales.

He said builders had begun reporting the planned gas ban was frustrating, however, customers were finding a way around it by installing bottled gas.

"There might be more outcry about wood heaters than there has been about gas heaters," he said.

"People love their wood heaters."

Wood heaters would be banned in the ACT after a gradual phase out under recommendations made by the ACT Commissioner for Sustainability and the Environment, Sophie Lewis.

The commissioner has called for a target date for their replacement with electric alternatives in all suburbs except rural areas, mirroring the ACT government's plan to end the use of gas.

The recommendations have followed an investigation undertaken by the office of Commissioner into the health and environmental impacts of wood heaters in the ACT. An investigation report was tabled in the Legislative Assembly on Wednesday and the ACT government is required to respond formally within six months.

ACT Commissioner for Sustainability and the Environment Sophie Lewis has recommended a wood heater ban to improve health for people and the environment. Picture by Keegan Carroll

Dr Lewis has called for the ban on the installation of new wood heaters in all homes, with exclusions only being extended to properties in rural areas.

Home owners would also be required to remove existing wood heaters before a property could be sold.

Dr Lewis said the report has focused on the environmental impact of wood heaters rather than looking at the business space and what any policy intervention might mean for suppliers.

She said the investigation did show there were very few Canberrans who relied on wood heaters as their primary source of heat.

Dr Lewis said people who relied on wood heaters were being deeply affected by them.

"Their health is being affected and their children's health. If we do make these interventions to improve air quality, they'll need help to change their source of heating," she said.

"What this investigation reveals is that there's a tremendous cost to Canberra's health from the use of wood heaters, and to alleviate that, we are going to need to stop installing wood heaters."

Environment Minister Rebecca Vassarotti. Picture by Sitthixay Ditthavong

Environment Minister Rebecca Vassarotti said the report, on top of the numerous letters she receives from impacted Canberrans, demonstrates more needed to be done to ensure policy and regulation of wood heaters properly addressed their negative impacts.

"The commissioner's report provides compelling evidence that the current approach to managing the air quality impacts from wood heaters in the ACT is insufficient to protect human health and the environment of the ACT from issues arising from wood heaters," she said.

"It also highlights the changing global science around what are considered safe airborne fine particulate levels for human health as part of air quality standards."

The report pointed to World Health Organisation research, which found outdoor air pollution was a leading environmental cause of cancer deaths.

"Current research suggests that there is no level of pollution at which health impacts do not occur," the report says.

The commissioner pointed to the 2019 State of the Environment Report, which found wood heaters were responsible more than 80 per cent of the time when particle levels exceeding the daily acceptable amount in Tuggeranong, between 2015 and 2018.

"Particles are associated with increased respiratory symptoms, aggravation of asthma, increased mortality and hospital admissions for heart and lung problems," the report found.

The commissioner said the detrimental environmental impact of wood heaters extended beyond climate change.

"Domestic wood heaters are considered the largest single source of black carbon in most Australian cities.

"A 2005 estimate suggests that approximately half of the firewood supply in Australia is collected privately from local forest and woodland on private property and roadsides, and is mainly from remnant vegetation in inland agricultural areas of south-eastern Australia.

"Even the legal removal of standing dead wood often has a negative impact, by reducing the availability of hollows and input of material to the litter layer which are critical for a range of ecosystems and species.

"The illegal collection of firewood from the territory's reserves is a recurring issue and is associated with penalties."

Dr Lewis has also recommended a register of wood heaters be established to determine the number and age and the introduction of mandatory labelling explaining health risks when heaters and firewood is sold.

"Include explicit messaging about the health risks associated with wood heater usage in ACT government education and communication program," she recommends.

"Develop and apply empirical criteria for determining environmental harm or nuisance from wood heater smoke, such as assessment of smoke composition and air quality monitoring at the affected sites, as part of the EPA [Environment Protection Authority] investigations."

The 2019 State of the Environment Report recommended an increase in air-quality monitoring stations in the ACT and an urgent assessment of air pollutant emissions from diffuse sources.

The ACT Commissioner for Sustainability and the Environment has called for a reconsideration of those recommendations as part of this investigation.

Dr Lewis said the report points to the importance of ensuring the air pollution problem is not replaced with a cold home problem.

"We do not want people who have no alternatives to be suffering because they don't have a heating source," she said.

"We need to be looking at creating safe air in lower-income households and not replacing wood heaters with nothing or something worse."

We've made it a whole lot easier for you to have your say. Our new comment platform requires only one log-in to access articles and to join the discussion on The Canberra Times website. Find out how to register so you can enjoy civil, friendly and engaging discussions. See our moderation policy here.

The ACT Commissioner for Sustainability and the Environment has recommended a wood heater ban to improve health outcomes for both people and the environment. Picture Getty Images
Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.