The Masked Singer UK viewers are conflicted over whether they have worked out who the celebrity is under the Robin costume.
Despite several predictions that it is JLS star Aston Merrygold, some now believe this is wrong.
All the clues seem to point to the singer - including starting out his career impersonating people, and a link to JLS' album Outta This World.
But now some fans think another celebrity also matches some of the clues given in the latest episode.
Aston isn't the only person who impersonated Michael Jackson as a child - and then there's the clue about being from an exotic place.
Taking to Twitter, fans suggested it had to be Peter Andre who was Robin, and not Aston.
The Mysterious Girl singer grew up in Australia, while he was born in the UK.
Taking to social media, viewers began sharing their thoughts on whether it was in fact Peter on the show, and not JLS star Aston.
One fan tweeted: "Peter Andre used to do impressions of Michael Jackson."
Another agreed: "Robin is Peter Andre."
A third added: "Robin has clues to football but there’s a definite twang of Peter Andre in there."
Meanwhile others did agree he was on the show, but thought he might be a different character altogether.
As predictions continued to swirl over the identity of Badger, some questioned if Peter was behind the mask.
There does seem to be a link to Australia with this character, judging by the clues, and Peter did star in I'm A Celebrity in 2004.
Fans also said it was the leather biker jacket that could be the biggest clue, as Peter often wore them on stage.
A final clue was about an Aladdin lamp that some believed to be a link to his duet with ex-wife Katie Price.
Viewers will just have to wait for more songs and clues ahead of the next big reveal!
The Masked Singer airs Saturdays at 7pm on ITV.
