100s of titles, one news app for just $10 a month.
Dive Deeper:
'Tom Hiddleston and Claire Danes make history with new drama The Essex Serpent'
TV columnist Sara Wallis is charmed by snakes, lust and monster-hunting in new Apple TV+ period drama The Essex Serpent,…
The Essex Serpent review: Tom Hiddleston is plausible as a toff who likes mudlarking
Claire Danes and Hiddleston lead the cast of this adaptation – but their backdrop far outshines them
Claire Danes Digs into Mystic Mystery in ‘The Essex Serpent’
Claire Danes says her first role after nearly a decade in hit drama "Homeland" was both "wonderful" and "scary", going…
Gothic "Essex Serpent” needs more bite
If you're expecting "The Thorn Birds" with a dinosaur, you'll be disappointed
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
‘The Essex Serpent’: Dreary detours stop the momentum of classy but murky Apple TV+ series
Claire Danes and Tom Hiddleston star in the story of a town convinced a water monster is doing the devil’s…
What links The Essex Serpent to a brave De Niro impression and a Taylor Swift T-shirt?
As the TV series lands, come down the rabbit hole for a swift visit to Claire Danes, Cannes and Conversations…
Get all your news in one place
Latest Entertainment news:
Anyone Who Abbreviates Breakfast To Anything But ‘Brekkie’ Deserves Immediate Gaol Time
Brekkie or bust.
Read news from The Economist, FT, Bloomberg and more, with one subscription
Learn More
A Spicy Screenshot Gives Us A Clue As To Who Drew Ends Up With After Big Brother Finishes
The hotly anticipated arrival of Tully Smyth into the Big Brother Australia 2022 house is tomorrow night. The producers are…
What Is The Proper Way To Hand Someone An Eclipse Mint Without Awkwardness? An Investigation
Whether giving or receiving, the experience is weird for everyone.
NPH Is Facing Huge Backlash After Someone Resurfaced His Grotesque Amy Winehouse Meat Platter
"That's next level deplorable."
Kourtney Kardashian Travis Barker Have Been Spotted Getting (Legally) Hitched In California
The couple were spotted in low-key wedding garb at a courthouse in California.
From analysis to good news, read the world’s best news in one place
Kylie Jenner Posted Her Driver’s License On Instagram It’s Raised A Whole Lot Of Questions
Hm...
Lismore kicks up its mud-caked heels at free concert following ‘two months of hell’
Residents refused to let a few showers stop them enjoying a star-studded show featuring Paul Kelly and Lime Cordiale

The Essex Serpent review – Claire Danes is magnificent … unlike Tom Hiddleston

By Lucy Mangan
Strangely sluggish … Claire Danes and Tom Hiddleston in The Essex Serpent.
Strangely sluggish … Claire Danes and Tom Hiddleston in The Essex Serpent. Photograph: Apple

Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar, said Freud. But darlings, let me tell you – a snake is never just a snake. And certainly not in The Essex Serpent (Apple TV+), the new six part miniseries adapted by Anna Symon from Sarah Perry’s 2016 bestselling novel of the same name.

At the tail end of the Victorian era and recently liberated by her wealthy, abusive husband’s death from cancer, young widow Cora Seaborne (Claire Danes) abandons London society and moves to Aldwinter on the edge of the Blackwater marshes to pursue a much more fulfilling life as an amateur paleontologist in comfortable clothes. With her she takes her devoted maidservant Martha (Hayley Squires) and her autistic (in modern day terms) son Frankie. Her husband’s former doctor, Luke Garrett (Frank Dillane), becomes a friend – and, in time, a contender at least in his eyes for her affections – and visits often.

When sightings of the legendary monster of the marshes begin, Cora theorises that it may be a living fossil – an icthyosaur-like being that escaped evolutionary pressures in the ancient wetlands – while the locals cleave to superstition and supernatural explanations for what they call “the Blackwater Beast”. Between the two stands the Rev Will Ransome (Tom Hiddleston), a man of God but also of the Enlightenment, keen to keep the growing fears and fancies of his flock under control and not call on divine or diabolic explanation unless all others have been exhausted. In this, he is not helped by his curate Matthew, a fire and brimstone type (whose name is surely meant to evoke the Witchfinder General Matthew Hopkins, who began his career in Essex in the 17th century) who sees the serpent as a sign from God that urgent repentance of the villagers’ sins is needed.

As the friendship between Will, his ailing wife Stella (Clémence Poesy) and Cora grows, so does the attraction between Will and Cora – rather less convincingly on screen than in the book. Perhaps this is down to a lack of chemistry between the leads, or perhaps the miscasting of Hiddleston, who never manages to shed his innate air of suave confidence. It works well when playing a god of mischief amidst a plethora of equally towering egos in the Marvel Cinematic Universe; less so when playing a Victorian vicar humble enough to admit doubts and wrestle with his conscience. Let alone fall in love with a woman cleverer than him, and spend time offering explanations that he is too honest to dismiss out of hand, however much they pain him. It gives his exchanges with Cora a condescending edge that is the death knell to the love and profound yearning that animated their relationship in the novel.

Danes, on the other hand, is magnificent as Cora – brusque, athletic, undisguisably intelligent and every inch a woman gradually being restored to life and self in the wake of her husband’s brutality. In fact, all the women are wonderful, from Squires, who brings vitality and conviction to what could be the slightly worthy part of the Socialist servant eager to bring about change, via Lily-Rose Aslandogdu and Dixie Egerickx as guilt-stricken youngsters who fear they summoned the beast, to Poesy who – as gentle, watchful Stella, is a heartbroken and heartbreaking revelation.

For all that, there is something strangely cold and sluggish about the adaptation of Perry’s book, which despite being a novel of ideas, was lush and vibrant, too. Although it excavated the links between myth, science and religion, it held up love in all its forms to the light as well. Platonic love, sexual love, requited and unrequited romantic love, love of a child, of a vocation, of discovery, of God. It was Wuthering Heights pulled into shape and given intellectual rigour without losing any of its sweeping gothic passion. But on screen, abundance has become austerity, suppressed feeling shades into inertia and the protagonists keep treading and retreading the same small patch of argumentative ground instead of sparking off each other and forging the greater and greater bond on which the story should turn.

Maybe I am simply too much a fan of the book. Symon’s take works perfectly well as a drama that delivers suitably sinuous twists and, under Clio Barnard’s direction, looks grimly fabulous, emerging out of the marsh mists that seem to promise that any malevolence is possible. And Danes grounds and gives a remarkable truth to the whole. But even allowing for the fact that screen adaptations rarely capture the full filigree of a literary novelist’s work (one reason why uncomplicated genre fiction generally fares better – there is more to add, less to lose), it feels like slightly too much has been lost in translation here.

What is inkl?
The world’s most important news, from 100+ trusted global sources, in one place.
Morning Edition
Your daily
news overview

Morning Edition ensures you start your day well informed.

No paywalls, no clickbait, no ads
Enjoy beautiful reading

Content is only half the story. The world's best news experience is free from distraction: ad-free, clickbait-free, and beautifully designed.

Expert Curation
The news you need to know

Stories are ranked by proprietary algorithms based on importance and curated by real news journalists to ensure that you receive the most important stories as they break.

Dive Deeper:
'Tom Hiddleston and Claire Danes make history with new drama The Essex Serpent'
TV columnist Sara Wallis is charmed by snakes, lust and monster-hunting in new Apple TV+ period drama The Essex Serpent,…
The Essex Serpent review: Tom Hiddleston is plausible as a toff who likes mudlarking
Claire Danes and Hiddleston lead the cast of this adaptation – but their backdrop far outshines them
Claire Danes Digs into Mystic Mystery in ‘The Essex Serpent’
Claire Danes says her first role after nearly a decade in hit drama "Homeland" was both "wonderful" and "scary", going…
Gothic "Essex Serpent” needs more bite
If you're expecting "The Thorn Birds" with a dinosaur, you'll be disappointed
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
‘The Essex Serpent’: Dreary detours stop the momentum of classy but murky Apple TV+ series
Claire Danes and Tom Hiddleston star in the story of a town convinced a water monster is doing the devil’s…
What links The Essex Serpent to a brave De Niro impression and a Taylor Swift T-shirt?
As the TV series lands, come down the rabbit hole for a swift visit to Claire Danes, Cannes and Conversations…
Get all your news in one place