100s of titles, one news app for just $10 a month.
Dive Deeper:
Newly revealed emails show how far Trump lawyer was willing to go to overturn 2020 election
John Eastman suggested that Pennsylvania throw out thousands of absentee ballots to show Donald Trump leading the state’s vote count.
'Provide some cover': New Eastman emails shed light on his push to overturn Biden's win
He suggested a way for Pennsylvania legislators to cancel Joe Biden's win.
Trump news - live: Emails show 2020 election fraud efforts as Flynn says army ‘persecuting’ him over Russia
Follow the latest updates
Emails: Eastman wanted to toss absentees
Eastman urged Pennsylvania Republicans to simply exclude absentee votes from recount to show Trump won
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
John Eastman used CU email account to send advice on challenging Pa.'s 2020 election results
John Eastman, a lawyer who represented Donald Trump following the president’s 2020 election loss, used his University of Colorado email…
Judge begins reviewing final disputed batch of Eastman emails
John Eastman, the architect of then-President Donald Trump’s last-ditch strategy to overturn the 2020 election, has claimed attorney-client privilege over…
Get all your news in one place
Latest National news:
YES: Shane Bazzi Has Won His Defamation Case Appeal Against Eyebrowless Gibbon Peter Dutton
Refugee advocate Shane Bazzi has won his appeal of the defamation case brought against him by mouldy potato Peter Dutton. 
Read news from The Economist, FT, Bloomberg and more, with one subscription
Learn More
Sweeping new search powers granted to Hunter Valley police
NSW police can now search the homes, cars, planes and boats of convicted drug dealers without a warrant as part…
Scott Morrison backtracks on minimum wage rises amid pressure on cost of living
PM previously called Anthony Albanese a ‘loose unit’ for backing $1 an hour rise, saying it would exacerbate ‘inflationary pressures’
Australia federal election 2022 live: Albanese rules out raising Labor’s 2030 emissions reduction target; 66 Covid deaths
Follow all the day’s news live
'Clothes will burn': Ex-legal service worker tried to cover up 'degrading' assault
The former Aboriginal Legal Service worker has pleaded guilty to a charge of attempting to pervert the course of justice.
From analysis to good news, read the world’s best news in one place
Woman drives drunk twice in one day with three Wild Turkeys under her belt
A court has heard a woman who was caught drink-driving twice in one day was on her way to a…
Coalition costings: $3.3bn in public service cuts to fund election pledges worth $2.3bn
Josh Frydenberg spruiks ‘responsible approach’ and calls on Labor to submit its policies to financial scrutiny

The Email That Shows the Absurdity of the Paperwork Coup

By David A. Graham
The Atlantic; Reuters

One of the most dangerous elements of Donald Trump’s attempt to steal the 2020 election is how it collapsed the gap between two distinct functions: electioneering and election administration. Both are political, insofar as elected officials oversee elections, but they begin from different premises. Election administration starts out with rules for the election and then uses those rules to determine the outcome; a candidate starts out with a goal of winning the election and tries to find a path to achieve it within those rules.

But Trump and his allies approached the aftermath of the 2020 election by treating them as the same. They started with an outcome—Trump had to win—and sought to rewrite the rules after the fact to achieve it. Although he had apparently not reviewed a new set of emails from the conservative legal Svengali John Eastman when he wrote it, this is exactly what Judge David Carter meant when he described Eastman and Trump’s actions as “a coup in search of a legal theory.”

[David A. Graham: A federal judge just told the truth about Trump]

The absurdity and brazenness of this approach is on display in those new emails from Eastman, uncovered in a public-records request in Colorado, where he was a visiting scholar at the University of Colorado. The most interesting messages are an exchange between Eastman and Russ Diamond, a Republican state representative in Pennsylvania.

Diamond wrote to Eastman, intrigued by his theory that a state legislature had the authority to appoint electors, irrespective of the popular vote. The idea is legally dubious—the overwhelming consensus of legal scholars holds that a state legislature can’t simply change its mind about the method of election after the votes are cast—and perhaps even more politically suspect, given that voters are unlikely to appreciate having their votes summarily ignored. The trick, Eastman wrote, was to “provide some cover” for the legislature.

Eastman had already decided—without any proof—that the election was tainted by fraud. “I did not watch the hearings that were held, but I suspect they contained ample evidence of sufficient anomalies and illegal votes to have turned the election from Trump to Biden,” he wrote in a December 4, 2020, email. Instead of proving that, though, he resorted to arithmetic.

[David A. Graham: The paperwork coup]

First, he wanted to discard roughly 10,000 mail-in ballots that arrived after the statutory deadline but during a grace period ordered by the state Supreme Court. Then, he noted that the rejection rate for mail-in ballots had sunk from 4 percent to 0.34 percent, so he recommended throwing out a portion of the remaining ballots, proportional to the overall percentage of absentee votes each candidate received.

“Then, having done that math, you’d be left with a significant Trump lead that would bolster the argument for the Legislature adopting a slate of Trump electors—perfectly within your authority to do anyway, but now
bolstered by the untainted popular vote.”

The idea was a very slightly more refined version of what Trump would try a month later in Georgia, when he begged Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger to somehow conjure just enough votes to give him a victory. “All I want to do is this. I just want to find 11,780 votes, which is one more than we have because we won the state,” he said.

[David A. Graham: The price of a failed impeachment]

Setting aside the poisonous motivation, Eastman’s plan had glaring flaws. First, the 10,000 votes hadn’t been included in the certified election total anyway. Second, they wouldn’t have all been for Biden. And third, as The Washington Post’s Philip Bump calculates, Biden would have won a majority even with Eastman’s math applied.

But the largest, and ultimately insurmountable, problem in turning Pennsylvania into a Trump state was that Joe Biden won substantially more votes in Pennsylvania than Donald Trump. There were early warning signs, as Diamond acknowledged to Eastman, writing: “Honestly, the Trump legal team was not exactly stellar at PA’s hearing, failed to provide the affidavits of their witnesses, and made a glaring error by purporting that more ballots had been returned than mailed out.”

Math tricks weren’t the only idea discussed. Diamond also shared a draft resolution with Eastman that complained that the state Supreme Court had usurped election authority properly belonging to the legislature by extending a deadline for ballots and changing standards for signature verification. But these questions had been litigated, and the legislature didn’t have the right to simply decide that because it didn’t like the outcome of the legal process, it could declare it wrong and ignore it.

[David A. Graham: Democrats are still delusional about Trump]

The brazen motivated reasoning at the heart of Eastman’s project also emerges in a flip-flop on the Electoral Count Act. In his correspondence with Diamond, he wrote that objections in the U.S. Congress to slates of electors would likely fail. “ONLY IF both houses then agree to the objection is the slate deemed invalid. If the House doesn’t agree to the objection, as is almost certain (the vote here being by majority rather than by state), then the objection is not sustained and the slate is counted.”

By January, however, he was pushing the idea that Vice President Mike Pence could reject a slate of electors on his own authority. (Pence disagreed and refused to do so, and Biden was certified the winner.) Nothing about federal law in that time had changed. All that had changed was that Eastman’s earlier attempts had fallen short. He had to look elsewhere to “provide some cover.”

Though everything we already knew about the paperwork coup has demonstrated it, Eastman’s email proves yet again that the MAGA goal was never about the sanctity of elections. It was engineering a Trump victory by any means possible. The ploy failed in 2020, but since then, Trump supporters have mounted a concerted push to take over offices that control elections around the country. Many of them will be working from the Eastman premise that election administration is all about ensuring the outcome they’ve already chosen.

What is inkl?
The world’s most important news, from 100+ trusted global sources, in one place.
Morning Edition
Your daily
news overview

Morning Edition ensures you start your day well informed.

No paywalls, no clickbait, no ads
Enjoy beautiful reading

Content is only half the story. The world's best news experience is free from distraction: ad-free, clickbait-free, and beautifully designed.

Expert Curation
The news you need to know

Stories are ranked by proprietary algorithms based on importance and curated by real news journalists to ensure that you receive the most important stories as they break.

Dive Deeper:
Newly revealed emails show how far Trump lawyer was willing to go to overturn 2020 election
John Eastman suggested that Pennsylvania throw out thousands of absentee ballots to show Donald Trump leading the state’s vote count.
'Provide some cover': New Eastman emails shed light on his push to overturn Biden's win
He suggested a way for Pennsylvania legislators to cancel Joe Biden's win.
Trump news - live: Emails show 2020 election fraud efforts as Flynn says army ‘persecuting’ him over Russia
Follow the latest updates
Emails: Eastman wanted to toss absentees
Eastman urged Pennsylvania Republicans to simply exclude absentee votes from recount to show Trump won
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
John Eastman used CU email account to send advice on challenging Pa.'s 2020 election results
John Eastman, a lawyer who represented Donald Trump following the president’s 2020 election loss, used his University of Colorado email…
Judge begins reviewing final disputed batch of Eastman emails
John Eastman, the architect of then-President Donald Trump’s last-ditch strategy to overturn the 2020 election, has claimed attorney-client privilege over…
Get all your news in one place