Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Los Angeles Times
Los Angeles Times
Politics
Mark Z. Barabak and Janet Hook

Takeaways from the Democratic presidential debate in New Hampshire

MANCHESTER, N.H. _ After the muddle in Iowa came the mash-up in Manchester.

Seven candidates who met the fund-raising and polling criteria set by the Democratic National Committee took the stage Friday night at Saint Anselm College for the presidential campaign's eighth round of debates.

With the effect of Iowa's caucuses diminished by the botched release of results, New Hampshire has gained even more import in the party's nominating fight.

The result was a lively, often combative three hours just four days before the Granite State host the nation's first primary on Tuesday.

Here are 5 takeaways:

BUTTIGIEG TAKES INCOMING

Welcome to the top of the heap, Pete Buttigieg.

The former South Bend, Ind., mayor came into the debate on a burst of momentum from his strong showing in the Iowa caucuses, then ran smack into a pack of rivals eager to cut the 38-year old political wunderkind down to size.

Billionaire Tom Steyer, he of no government experience, said he was worried about Buttigieg's lack of government experience. Minnesota Sen. Amy Klobuchar derided him as a "cool newcomer" _ the "cool" part ripe with condescension _ who was taking cheap shots at Washington.

Joe Biden dissed Buttigieg's youth and said, in essence, what's wrong with the good old days of Obama-Biden?

"I don't know what about the past of Barack Obama and Joe Biden was so bad," the former vice president said, no doubt mindful of his former running mate's continued great popularity among Democrats. "What happened? What is it that he wants to do away with?"

Buttigieg managed to keep, yes, his cool and delivered a pointed riposte, touting the outside-the-Beltway credentials that, for some, are a large part of his attraction.

"If you are looking for the person with the most Washington establishment experience under your belt," he responded, "you've got your candidate and it's not me."

Biden grinned, apparently seeing that one coming from a mile away.

BIDEN STEPS UP

After a humbling fourth-place finish in the Iowa caucuses, Biden must greatly improve his performance in New Hampshire to keep his campaign alive.

So the first thing he did was attempt to lower expectations.

"I took a hit in Iowa, and I'll probably take a hit here," he said in the opening moments of the debate, noting two candidates _ Sens. Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders of Vermont _ have the advantage of coming from neighboring states.

With that out of the way, he turned in a much feistier performance than in the past, taking on Sanders and Buttigieg, in more direct, personal terms.

He faulted Sanders for not saying how much his Medicare for All proposal would cost. He suggested that Buttigieg was too inexperienced to be president.

They were familiar lines of attack, but delivered with greater passion. Boasting of a decades-long political career Biden all but shouted _ with no small amout of hyperbole _"I"ve been part of every major initiative!"

BERNIE, REDUX

Close your eyes. Listen closely. The sound could have been Bernie Sanders speaking in 2016, or at any one of the umpteen campaign events he has held since them.

The unvaried message is a large part of the Vermont senator's appeal to supporters, who find reassurance in the repetitious bashing of billionaires and vows to chase the moneyed class from their privileged perch and create an economy that works for all.

But the Iowa caucuses showed the limits of that approach. While Sanders ran strongly among voters who supported him four years ago he did poorly among new caucus-goers and those who backed his opponent four years ago, Hillary Clinton.

On Friday night, Sanders didn't offer a whole lot new to attract converts or lure fresh supporters. In one of many characteristic moments, he brought a discussion of electability around to two staples of his economic populist campaign.

"The way you bring people together is to make it clear that we're not going to give tax breaks to billionaires and large corporations," Sanders roared, his hands fluttering in emphasis.

"And I'll tell you something else," he went on. "The way you bring people together is by ending the international disgrace of this country being the only major nation on Earth not to guarantee healthcare for all people as a human right."

Sanders won 61% of the New Hampshire vote four years ago against Clinton but seems unlikely to come anywhere near that performance in this large field. The calculation seems to be that a rock-solid base of roughly 25% to 30% of the electorate may be enough to deliver a win Tuesday night.

That, however, is viewing his debate performance through a strategic lens. The simple explanation is that Sanders deeply believes what he says, and always has.

WARREN DIDN'T COME TO FIGHT

She scolded Buttigieg for raising money in a swanky Napa Valley wine cave. She snubbed Sanders, refusing to shake his hand after they differed over whether he'd said a woman couldn't win the White House.

But on Friday night, in contrast to those earlier debates, Elizabeth Warren largely came in peace.

Given an early chance to go on the attack against Sanders, she brushed aside the opportunity, airily telling moderator George Stephanopoulos of ABC that the two have been friends for a long time and agree on some issues and disagree on others.

While several on the stage took turns pummeling Buttigieg, the Massachusestts senator stood by silently. When the discussion turned heated over healthcare, she soothingly chimed in, "We need to bring the most help to the most people as quickly as we can" and spoke of strengthening the Affordable Care Act and using an executive order to bring down drug prices.

(No mention of Medicare for all, the political minefield that left her badly wounded when Warren changed from all-out support to a go-slow approach.)

If the idea was to present a calming contrast with the others brawling on stage, Warren managed to do so.

She grew animated on the issue of money in politics, saying there is no place for a billionaire, like former New York City Mayor Michael S. Bloomberg, to buy his way into the White House and criticizing unnamed others who "suck up to billionaires."

She also spoke forcefully and eloquently on the issues of gun control and racial discrimination.

But passivity has a price, as the most time and attention goes to the candidates throwing off the most sparks.

Warren limped into New Hampshire after a disappointing third-place finish in Iowa and needs a strong showing Tuesday to resuscitate her hopes. It's not clear how much her little-bit-hot, little-bit-cold performance helped her cause.

FEISTY, BUT ALSO FUNNY

The debate was way too long, but it wasn't the snoozer the candidates put on in Iowa.

The exchanges were filled with harsher, more direct attacks. Candidates were on edge, more passionate, in more of a hurry to get their words out.

But there were also light moments, like when Biden hugged Sanders after a moderator brought up a recent comment by Hillary Clinton that "nobody" liked or wanted to work with him.

And after a lot of tense exchanges between Buttigieg and Biden, the former mayor gave a gracious answer when asked about the political risks that might be posed by President Donald Trump's allegations about the business dealings of Biden's son Hunter.

He didn't take the bait.

"No, we're not going to let them change the subject. This is not about Hunter Biden or Vice President Biden or anybody. This is about an abuse of power by the president."

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.