Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Daily Mirror
Daily Mirror
Entertainment
Zoe Delaney

Strictly fans blast judges Shirley and Craig for 'reviling' in giving harsh feedback

The week's live offering from Strictly Come Dancing got off to a dramatic start earlier this evening.

As Will Mellor and Nancy Xu wowed the judges with an energetic Charleston to Hush by Kula Shaker, viewers watching at home were divided when it came to deciding if the couple's performance was worthy of such a high score.

Shirley Ballas gushed over the pair after they opened the show tonight, with hard-to-please Craig Revel Horwood even praising the pair despite having a slight issue with Will's 'free arm'.

But head judge Shirley was less complimentary of Ellie Taylor's latest performance on the BBC series - giving some harsh observations on the comedian's Jive to Brown Eyed Girl by Van Morrison with Johannes Radebe.

Strictly fans rushed online to defend Ellie Taylor following some harsh feedback from the judges (BBC)

Looking very serious as she delivered her feedback, Shirley claimed Ellie was "a bit flat footed" during her performance and told the duo how she wasn't super keen on their dance, before going on to award them 6 points.

Craig piped in and claimed the performance lacked punch - something viewers watching at home certainly didn't agree with.

"The way they tear Ellie down is SO uncomfortable to watch. Craig and Shirley seem to revel in it (excuse the pun)," one fan watching at home took to Twitter to say after the criticism.

Craig didn't hold back when delivering his thoughts on Ellie's dance (BBC)

"I always feel like Shirley and Craig are really mean to Ellie every week," another claimed, as a third added: "And it [wasn't] the greatest jive, but why does Shirley always gets to... I would almost say vicious, to Ellie?"

However, some Strictly fans defended Shirley and Craig's comments and reminded other viewers how the show is a competition and it's the judges' job to sometimes deliver bad news.

Shirley was defended by some viewers (BBC)

"I agree with Craig and Shirley her dance was lacklustre #ellie #Strictly," one declared on Twitter, with another pondering: "Why are people so shocked at Ellie’s low score? That jive was not her dance & the comments from Craig and Shirley were fair. Time’s up now for Ellie. She’s had a good run but the rest are pulling ahead. We want a truly competitive final. Dance off this week."

Ellie's points total, 25 out of a possible 40, wasn't the only score to get fans talking earlier this evening.

Despite the four Strictly judges awarding the Coronation Street star Will and his professional dance partner Nancy a combined score of 38 out of a possible 40 points, fans of the BBC show took to social media to raise an eyebrow at the generous scoring.

"38?!??! nah those score are wrong #strictly," one viewer mused on Twitter as Will and Nancy's scores were revealed.

"Ngl, Will didn't deserve that score," another quipped online, as a third simply added: "overmarked! #Strictly."

Not all Strictly fans think Will should have scored so high (BBC)

Another tough Twitter critic declared: "Don't think Will deserved 10s just my opinion. #Strictly."

However, some watching at home sided with Shirley, Craig, Anton Du Beke and Motsi Mabuse.

"Will Mellor solidified his DILF status with that Charleston #Strictly," one cheeky fan quipped.

"Actually 10’s are well deserved," a second agreed, with another of Will's fans adding: "38 points, well deserved, Will’s best dance so far…"

Strictly Come Dancing continues on BBC One at 6PM on Sunday 27th November

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.