COUNCIL officers have refused part-retrospective planning permission for standing stones at a castle near Oban.
David Whitehead made the application for a total of 15 stones, each between two and 2.5 metres tall, at Barcaldine Castle in Benderloch.
But Argyll and Bute Council has ruled against planning permission, saying that the proposal is considered to be in conflict with the local development plan.
Three objections were received from the public, along with one expression of support and two neutral representations.
A council officer said in a handling report: “This application seeks part-retrospective planning permission for the erection of 15 standing stones to form a replica stone circle within the grounds of the category A-listed Barcaldine Castle, Benderloch.
“The application is made in part retrospectively following complaints and a subsequent planning enforcement investigation.
“The stones have been installed in a circle formation, with 13 stones forming the outer ring and two stones positioned in its centre. Each stone varies in size from two to 2.5 metres in height (from ground level). A post and wire fence, access gate, slabbed footpath and benches have also been installed.
“The application includes a further proposed gravel path to surround the replica stone circle. The development is sited on greenfield land to the rear of Barcaldine Castle.
“The castle operates as a luxury bed and breakfast business, with no public access to the building and grounds.”
A supporting statement accompanying the planning application, quoted in the handling report, said: “Barcaldine Castle entertains visitors from all over the world and the business provides direct and indirect employment in the area, which is beneficial for the local and Scottish economy.
“We believe that the improvement to the landscape offers our guests a more desirable place to stay. In addition, the castle hosts many weddings during the course of the year and as such offers greater opportunities for the professional photographer in his choice of location for the bride and groom and their guests.
“We are confident that when the stone circle is included in the marketing of the castle as a venue, it will increase the likelihood of the location being the preferred choice for the marriage ceremony and as a result contributing to the viability of the hospitality business.
“There will be hidden outdoor speakers and soft, complimentary Gaelic music will be audible, which will add to the atmosphere and guest/visitor experience. We will also be able to offer intimate outdoor weddings in this area.”
The council official said: “The inappropriate use of materials and siting of the stone circle in close proximity to the castle are problematic within the sensitive setting.
“The development detracts from the cultural and historical importance of the site and introduces a replica structure that conflicts with the established character and historical understanding of the castle.
“There are no other material considerations of sufficient significance to indicate that it would be appropriate to grant planning permission in this instance.”
