Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Guardian - UK
The Guardian - UK
Sport
Michael Aylwin

South Africa 19-16 British & Irish Lions: third Test player ratings

Eben Etzebeth wins a lineout
Eben Etzebeth helped South Africa rise above the British & Irish Lions. Photograph: Halden Krog/AP

South Africa

15 Willie le Roux More like the Rolls Royce we know him to be after the strait-jacket worn for first two Tests. Lovely timing for Kolbe’s try. 7

14 Cheslin Kolbe Was largely a spectator but then that glimpse, which is all he needs. Brilliant finish for the game’s highlight. 7

13 Lukhanyo Am Less influential this week, much less so than his partner. A rush of blood to his head conceded a crucial late penalty. 4

12 Damian de Allende Industrious. Metres made and top-tackling back by a distance. He embodies these Springboks: precise and hard, very hard. 7

11 Makazole Mapimpi Not nearly as influential as last week. This time, he had to watch his mate on the other flank grab the headlines. 5

10 Handré Pollard Looked better with ball in hand than off boot, missing kicks at a sensitive stage. Made a couple of half-breaks. 5

9 Cobus Reinach Hanging kicks were awkward to deal with and he had a fair amount to tidy up himself. No chance of seeing his electric pace. 6

1 Steven Kitshoff Maybe it’s his red hair, but he certainly takes a more active part in the loose than some props (see Malherbe). 6

2 Bongi Mbonambi A little wayward with his throwing at the lineout, but a willing tackler. Would prefer a more prominent hooker. 5

3 Frans Malherbe Hardly catches the eye with change of pace or soft handling, but he’s there for one reason only. Scrummaged very well. 6

4 Eben Etzebeth The spikiest of a very spiky team. A beacon at the lineout, but it’s the horrible stuff that really marks him out. 8

5 Lood de Jager No game-changing masterclass this time, but he was the top tackler when he went off and always in the thick of it. 7

6 Siya Kolisi (capt) Relatively quiet but did enjoy a good period at end of the first half when the Springboks kept themselves in touch. 6

7 Franco Mostert Moved from lock to flank but his role remained the same: work and lots of it. Even a smashed nose couldn’t slow him down. 7

8 Jasper Wiese Has something of a discipline problem. Pinged three times but he is a handful, beating as many tacklers as any Springbok. 6

REPLACEMENTS: Kwagga Smith (for De Jager, 54) n/a; Marco van Staden (for Kolisi, 56) n/a; Malcolm Marx (for Mbonambi, 56) n/a; Vincent Koch (for Malherbe, 56) n/a; Trevor Nyakane (for Kitshoff, 61) n/a; Herschel Jantjies (for Reinach, 64) n/a; Morne Steyn (for Pollard, 65) n/a; Damian Willemse (for Le Roux, 79) n/a

A dejected Liam Williams after the game
A dejected Liam Williams after the game. Photograph: Dan Sheridan/Inpho/Shutterstock

British & Irish Lions

15 Liam Williams He will wake in cold sweats for years as he remembers the pass he didn’t make. Beaten by Kolbe too. 4

14 Josh Adams Couple of good runs, particularly off Russell’s promptings, but he was not perfect. 5

13 Robbie Henshaw Full of running, including at the death when the lungs must have been burning. 7

12 Bundee Aki Another forceful carrier, but he was caught out a couple of times with disciplinary errors. 5

11 Duhan van der Merwe After last week’s horror show, he repaid Gatland’s faith with an excellent showing. A handful with ball in hand. 7

10 Dan Biggar Missed a tricky early penalty and high ball, and no time to contribute much more, hobbling off after only 10 minutes. 4

9 Ali Price Really lively off the back of rucks and scrums, he is the pick of this tour’s scrum-halves 7

1 Wyn Jones Trundling along fine until he suffered a back injury towards end of first half 4 .

2 Ken Owens He was solid at set piece, particularly the lineout. Steered the driven maul for his try 6

3 Tadhg Furlong His first half, in particular, was superb. He was solid at set piece and a ball of energy around the park. 7

4 Maro Itoje Usual lapses in discipline were costly, but the relentless energy and athleticism much in evidence. 6

5 Alun Wyn Jones (capt) Hard work, as ever, but couldn’t quite whip himself or his team into the requisite fury. 5

6 Courtney Lawes Picked from nowhere, really, after an injury-blighted season, he has been one of the Lions’ best players this series. 7

7 Tom Curry Usually found at the heart of the rough stuff, he won a few and lost a few. 5

8 Jack Conan Best game yet, which is saying something. Withdrawn on the hour for some reason, but still top carrying forward for Lions. 7

REPLACEMENTS: Finn Russell (for Biggar, 11) One of his good days. Very good 8; Mako Vunipola (for W Jones, 44) 6; Luke Cowan-Dickie (for Owens, 54) n/a; Kyle Sinckler (for Furlong, 59) n/a; Conor Murray (for Price, 59) n/a; Adam Beard (for AW Jones, 61) n/a; Sam Simmonds (for Conan, 63) n/a

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.