It has been hailed as one of Strictly Come Dancing's greatest ever dances as Rose Ayling-Ellis and Giovanni Pernice stunned BBC One viewers with their couple's choice dance on Saturday.
EastEnders actress Rose had promised something for the deaf community and she delivered a powerful performance that saw the music cut out as the pair danced in silence before Clean Bandit featuring Zara Larsson's song Symphony restarted.
But former Strictly pro and Dancing on Ice champion James Jordan said there was one issue with the dance - he thinks it should have been saved.
Read more: Strictly Come Dancing's Aljaz Skorjanec hints at exit in emotional interview
Writing for Hello! magazine, Jordan, who was in Strictly from 2006 to 2013, said: "I would have saved that dance for the final."
Saying it was a "special moment" that deserved the praise it got, he added the impact on the audience couldn't be recreated again.
There was agreement on twitter, with twitter user Sid writing: "My only complaint is Rose and Giovanni didn’t save that for their Showdance."
While HŸDE @thenameishyde said: "If Rose is in the final (as surely she must be), I hope we get an entirely silent show dance."
Get the best stories about the things you love most curated by us and delivered to your inbox every day. Choose what you love here
The judges were as moved by the audience by the couple's dance, with head judge Shirley Ballas saying: "It will be etched in my heart for a long, long time."
While there was dismay that Craig Revel-Horwood 'only' gave the dance a nine, unlike fellow judges Shirley, Motsi Mabuse and Anton Du Beke awarding it 10s.
On Saturday's show Dragons’ Den star Sara Davies was the seventh celebrity to be eliminated after performing with her dance partner Aljaz Skorjanec in the dance off against social media star Tilly Ramsay and her partner Nikita Kuzmin.
Strictly Come Dancing returns to BBC One on Saturday (November 20) at 6.35pm with Musicals Week.
Want our best stories with fewer ads and alerts when the biggest news stories drop? Download our app on iPhone or Android
