Get all your news in one place.
100’s of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
Newcastle Herald
Newcastle Herald
National
Ian Kirkwood

Political splits on coal and renewables as much about practicalities as ideologies on climate change

JOEL FITZGIBBON: Both sides of politics have rifts over energy policy.

THE growing ruckus surrounding Hunter MP Joel Fitzgibbon and his ouster from the federal Labor shadow cabinet has exposed more than the ALP version of the climate change fault line that also exists on the conservative side of politics.

It is also an expression of Labor frustration at losing an election that many in the Coalition feared it would win. Now, despite a very shaky start, Mr Morrison is all but lording it over the opposition, which has failed to strike a decent blow despite the leadership switch from Bill Shorten to Anthony Albanese.

Mr Albanese's supporters accused Mr Fitzgibbon of torpedoing Labor's parliamentary plan for this week, which was to try to wedge the Morrison government by portraying Democrat Joe Biden's victory in the US as being won on climate change.

In fact, Mr Fitzgibbon may have done his side a favour: it would not have taken much for the government to point out the widespread disappointment at the Democrat result in the House and the Senate.

President Trump may have lost the White House, but his Republican candidates proved much more popular than their divisive leader.

In a similar vein, outspoken members on Labor's left, including Shortland MP Pat Conroy, might want to describe Mr Fitzgibbon as part of a "small minority" in the ALP caucus with similar views, but the veteran MP is doing nothing more than he should, by standing up for the interests of his electorate, and voicing the concerns that many others with otherwise pro-renewables sentiments will still have, given the technical complexity of turning the grid green.

The problem is not generating power through solar or wind farms. It is maintaining enough power each night, and in times of still or wet weather.

Pumped hydro - along with giant batteries - are routinely touted as answers to the storage problem, but as the NSW Coalition government's Electricity Infrastructure Roadmap, released this week, makes clear, the technological difficulties are substantial.

It's the real-world challenges posed by a renewable conversion, more than any ideological fondness for coal, that worry many of those with doubts about the mission.

Until those doubts are removed - and a "just transition" guaranteed for affected communities - the divide will remain.

ISSUE: 39,463.

IN THE NEWS:

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100’s of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.